Skip to content
Katie Hobbs
40.8%
#40 of 50

Katie Hobbs

Arizona D | 1st term
2023-01-02Took Office 3 yrs, 5 moIn Office 263Metrics Scored 675 / 1653Total Points

Section A: Governance

209/300
70%

Section B: State Outcomes

447/975
46%

Section C: Oath Fidelity

+19 (-378 to +378)

Section A — Governance 209/300

9 subsections evaluating executive performance: budget execution, legislative relations, appointments, emergency management, transparency, ethics, program management, federal relations, and constituent service.

On-time budget submission
FY2025 executive budget ($16.2B general fund) released Jan 2024 on time. FY2026 proposal submitted Jan 2025 on schedule. FY2025 budget passed 3 days before shutdown deadline in June 2024. All three budgets (FY2024-FY2026) submitted within statutory deadlines despite divided government.
AZ OSPB Budget Publications; azgovernor.gov; AZ JLBC
3
Budget accuracy — revenue forecast vs actual
Inherited ~$460M FY2025 deficit (per OSPB estimate) driven by Ducey-era 2.5% flat tax transition costing ~$1.9B/yr and ESA voucher expansion exceeding projections by hundreds of millions. FY2025 enacted at $16.2B, 6% below prior year. Revenue forecasting complicated by structural tax-base erosion.
AZ JLBC Revenue Reports; AZ OSPB FY2025 Summary Book; JLBC Fiscal Notes
1
Rainy day fund management
Proposed $250M one-time deposit into Budget Stabilization Fund, bringing estimated FY2024 ending balance to $1.6B — highest in state history. Bipartisan budget deal addressed projected deficit without depleting reserves. Rainy day fund maintained above pre-pandemic levels despite flat-tax revenue loss.
AZ JLBC; AZ State Treasurer Reports; AZ OSPB FY2025 Budget Proposal
2
State credit rating trajectory
Moody's upgraded Arizona to Aa1 from Aa2 citing strong economic growth, balanced budgets, reduced debt, and record rainy day fund. S&P raised outlook to positive July 2024 (later revised to stable Sept 2025 due to federal fiscal uncertainty). S&P affirmed AA rating. Arizona maintains Aa1/AA — among strongest state credit ratings nationally.
Moody's Aa1 Upgrade; S&P Global Ratings; Bond Buyer; KTAR; AZ Treasurer Credit Rating Page
3
Pension funding ratio trajectory
Arizona overall pension funded ratio 74.3% (FY2024), up from 72% in 2014. ASRS accounts for 70% of state pension liabilities — its funded status slightly declined over decade. PSPRS/CORP improved structurally. $27.3B total unfunded pension debt (FY2024). Arizona ranks 17th nationally in unfunded liabilities. Employee contribution rate 12.12% for FY2025.
ASRS Actuarial Reports; PSPRS FY2024 ACFR; AZ Free News Nov 2025; Reason Foundation
2
Debt per capita trajectory
Arizona state/local debt per capita approximately $5,176 — moderate nationally, well below high-debt states like CT ($26,187) and NY. Conservative borrowing maintained; no major new bond issuances under Hobbs. Low-debt tradition continues as Arizona Constitution limits general obligation debt.
Tax Foundation State Debt Data; AZ JLBC 2024 Debt Report; AZ State Treasurer
2
CAFR/ACFR published on time
FY2023 state ACFR published by Auditor General in Nov 2024 — late due to delayed receipt of external audited statements from state agencies. ADOT FY2024 ACFR received clean opinion. Financial Transparency Portal (openbooks.az.gov) operational. General Accounting Office publishes Annual Financial Reports alongside ACFR.
AZ Auditor General ACFR FY2023; AZ GAO; openbooks.az.gov; ADOT ACFR FY2024
2
Audit findings — material weaknesses
No adverse audit opinions on statewide financials. ADOT FY2024 ACFR received clean opinion (GAAP conformity). Jensen v. Thornell federal court injunction (April 2023) found ADCRR healthcare/conditions deficient — compliance costs impact budget. No material weaknesses in core financial reporting.
AZ Auditor General Reports; ADOT FY2024 ACFR; Jensen v. Thornell Injunction Order
2
Federal grant fund accounting
Innovative ARPA deployment: $30M to partner with Undue Medical Debt nonprofit — erased $642M in medical debt for 485,000 Arizonans ($1 donated = ~$100 forgiven). BIL infrastructure funds captured including $95M I-10 INFRA grant. CHIPS Act facilitated $6.6B TSMC federal award. No major federal single audit deficiencies.
AZ Single Audit; Federal Audit Clearinghouse; Governor's ARPA/Medical Debt Records; USDOT INFRA Grant
2
Anti-fraud controls
No major fraud scandals in state programs under Hobbs. Auditor General maintains independent fraud detection. Prop 200 (2004) requires citizenship verification for public benefits — strongest in nation. E-Verify mandatory for all employers (LAWA 2007). DES eligibility systems functional despite federal funding cuts to workforce.
AZ Auditor General Reports; Prop 200; LAWA; DES Records
3
Tax revenue vs expenditure alignment
Ducey's 2.5% flat tax costs ~$1.9B/yr in lost revenue. ESA voucher expansion created $206M K-12 funding shortfall; program costs exceeded projections every year. FY2025 budget cut WIFA water funding by ~$500M and eliminated $333M water supply augmentation allocation to close gap. Structural revenue-expenditure misalignment persists.
AZ JLBC; AZ OSPB Fiscal Reports; 12News ESA Investigation; Inside Climate News Nov 2025
1
Capital budget execution rate
Secured $95M INFRA grant to widen 26 miles of I-10 between Phoenix and Casa Grande ($1B total project). ADOT 5-year plan includes $9B+ in transportation investments and $2.6B for pavement/bridge preservation. Signed $500M Chase Field renovation (HB 2704, June 2025) — no tax increase, using existing tax revenue redirect. Diamondbacks committed $250M match.
AZ DOT; USDOT INFRA Grant Jan 2024; HB 2704 Chase Field; Governor's Office
2
Vendor/contractor oversight
ALJ found 'serious flaws' in AHCCCS ALTCS contract procurement — 'arbitrary and flawed process' with undisclosed scoring criteria for $15B in Medicaid contracts. Mercy Care, Banner Health, BCBS protested exclusion. ALJ recommended rebidding; AHCCCS Director denied appeal Sept 2024. Providers sued in Maricopa County Superior Court.
AZ ALJ Ruling Aug 2024; AHCCCS Director's Decision Sept 2024; Maricopa County Superior Court filings
1
Federal funding maximization
TSMC Arizona awarded $6.6B in CHIPS Act direct funding (Nov 2024) — $65B+ total investment, largest foreign greenfield FDI in U.S. history. $95M INFRA grant for I-10. ARPA $30M leveraged into $642M medical debt relief. BIL highway/bridge funds deployed through ADOT. However, WIFA water funding cut ~$500M in FY2025 budget despite federal match availability.
USASpending.gov; USDOT BIL Factsheet; CHIPS Act TSMC Award Nov 2024; WIFA Budget Records
2
Program eligibility verification
Arizona has nation's strongest verification framework: Prop 200 (2004) mandates citizenship proof for all state/local benefits. SAVE system integrated with AHCCCS (2M+ enrollees). E-Verify mandatory for all employers via LAWA. DES eligibility systems functional. No documented widespread fraud in benefit programs during tenure.
AZ AHCCCS; AZ DES; Prop 200; LAWA; SAVE System Records
3
Signature legislation enacted
Signed HB 2677 repealing 1864 near-total abortion ban (May 2, 2024) — 2 GOP senators crossed party lines. Bipartisan $16.2B FY2025 budget closing deficit. $30M ARPA medical debt forgiveness erasing $642M for 485K Arizonans. HB 2704 Chase Field $500M renovation (no new taxes). Foreign land ownership restrictions signed. Signed 265 bipartisan bills in 2025 session.
AZ Legislature Bill Tracking; HB 2677; HB 2704; Governor's Office
2
Veto override rate
Zero vetoes overridden despite issuing 390 total vetoes across three sessions (143 in 2023, 73 in 2024, 174 in 2025). Republican legislature never mustered 2/3 supermajority to override. Veto power effectively maintained executive leverage in divided government.
AZ Legislature Journal; Phoenix New Times; AZ Mirror; Governor's Veto Records
3
Bipartisan bills signed
Signed 265 bipartisan bills in 2025 session alongside 174 vetoes. Bipartisan FY2025 budget passed with R+D votes. Signed bipartisan foreign land ownership restrictions, Chase Field renovation (HB 2704 with R+D support), and SB 1543 Axon HQ bill (17 bipartisan Senate votes). Democrat governing with R legislature requires constant negotiation.
AZ Legislature Vote Records; HB 2704; SB 1543; Governor's Signing Records
2
Special sessions called
No special sessions called during tenure. Regular sessions handled all major legislation including bipartisan budget, abortion ban repeal, and Chase Field renovation. FY2025 budget passed 3 days before shutdown deadline within regular session framework.
AZ Legislature Records; Governor's Office
3
Executive orders — legal challenges
Maricopa County Superior Court (June 5, 2024) ruled Hobbs illegally bypassed Senate confirmation by appointing 13 agency heads as 'Executive Deputy Directors' with full director powers. Court found violation of ARS requiring Senate consent within one year. Hobbs appealed, then agreed to resubmit 16 of 19 nominees; 3 agency heads (DCS, DEQ, DVS) were not renominated.
Maricopa County Superior Court ruling June 2024; AZ Mirror; KJZZ; AZ Constitution
1
Line-item veto usage
Line-item veto used as leverage in FY2025 budget negotiations with Republican legislature. Arizona Constitution grants robust line-item veto authority. Used strategically to shape $16.2B FY2025 budget while avoiding full budget vetoes that would trigger government shutdown.
AZ Constitution Art. V §7; Governor's Budget Actions; JLBC Budget Analysis
2
Regulatory burden change
No major new regulatory burden imposed. Expedited semiconductor/manufacturing permitting to support TSMC ($65B investment) and CHIPS Act projects. Maintained predecessor's business-friendly regulatory environment. Arizona remains among lowest-regulation states (Tax Foundation rankings). No significant deregulation initiatives either.
AZ Administrative Code; AZ Commerce Authority; Tax Foundation Business Climate Rankings
3
Budget negotiation success
FY2025 bipartisan budget ($16.2B general fund) passed June 2024, just 3 days before shutdown deadline, with both R and D votes. Closed ~$460M deficit without new taxes. Negotiated across party lines despite R control of both chambers. FY2024 budget also achieved bipartisan passage. However, negotiations consistently go down to the wire.
AZ Legislature Session Records; AZ OSPB; AZ Mirror Budget Coverage
2
Bill signing rate on popular legislation
Signed HB 2677 repealing 1864 abortion ban (widely popular — polling showed 60%+ support). Signed 265 bills in 2025 session. Vetoed 71 election bills across 3 sessions — more than any other category. 390 total vetoes counterbalanced by signing popular bipartisan measures (Chase Field, foreign land ownership, border security funding).
AZ Legislature Records; Governor Signing Records; AZ Capitol Times Jan 2026
2
Legislative relationship
Most adversarial governor-legislature relationship in AZ history. 390 vetoes across 3 sessions: 143 (2023, broke Napolitano's career record of 181), 73 (2024), 174 (2025, new single-session record). Republicans accuse her of obstruction; Hobbs says R's deliberately send bills to make her look obstructionist. Legislature refused to confirm her 13 agency nominees.
AZ Legislature; The Center Square; AZ Mirror July 2025; Phoenix New Times; AZPM
1
Voter-approved measures implementation
Implementing Prop 308 (2022, voter-approved in-state tuition for DACA students). Did not obstruct Prop 211 (dark money disclosure). Prop 123 education funding renewal being negotiated — Hobbs wants extension without ESA voucher ties. Has not interfered with voter-approved measures. Signed SB 1543 overriding Scottsdale voter referendum on Axon HQ — raised local democracy concerns.
AZ Secretary of State; Prop 308/211/123; SB 1543; AZ Mirror
2
Task force follow-through
Water: Introduced Active Management Area in Willcox (groundwater crisis epicenter) via ADWR. Passed 'Ag-to-Urban' water rights transfer bill — biggest groundwater legislation of tenure. Created border coordination office in AZ DHS. Operation Desert Guardian task force (EO 2025-01) for border counties. Housing task force produced no major legislation; vetoed Starter Homes Act for 'unclear outcomes.'
AZ Governor's Office; ADWR AMA Actions; EO 2025-01; AZ Capitol Times Housing Coverage
2
Policy reversals under pressure
Major death penalty reversal: Ordered independent review of execution protocols (Jan 2023, hired retired Judge David Duncan), then abruptly fired Duncan and ended review (Nov 2024, 3 weeks after Trump won election). Duncan had concluded lethal injection unviable and recommended firing squad. Hobbs then allowed executions to resume — significant policy flip on core issue.
Governor's EOs; Death Penalty Information Center; AZ Mirror March 2025; FOX 10 Phoenix
2
Appointee criminal/ethics issues
No criminal charges against appointees. Six senior staff (including CoS Allie Bones, Janelle Pedregon, Jennifer Loredo, Tracy Lopez, Jason Chavez) accepted free Super Bowl LVII tickets from AZ Office of Tourism — valued $4K-$40K each. State law bars public employees from accepting 'expenditure for entertainment' from public bodies. Governor's attorney argued exemption; no investigation launched.
AZ Ethics Commission; AZ Family Sept 2023; AZ Daily Independent
3
Agency head vacancy rate
Withdrew all 13 agency nominees from Senate in 2023, citing 'political theater.' Appointed them as 'Executive Deputy Directors' to bypass confirmation. Court ruled this illegal (June 2024) — violated ARS 1-year limit without Senate consent. Agreed to resubmit 16 of 19; dropped 3 directors (DCS, DEQ, DVS). Created 18+ months of leadership uncertainty across 13 agencies.
Maricopa County Superior Court June 2024; AZ Mirror; 12News; KJZZ
1
State employee turnover
Multiple agencies report high turnover and low morale in FY2027 budget requests, citing employees working two jobs to meet basic needs. Average state employee salary $60,791 (2024) — 40,140 employees. Agencies requesting 4-10% salary increases after proposed 2-3% raise for all employees fell through. Teacher turnover ~20% statewide (2024-2025).
AZ DOA Personnel Data; AZ Capitol Times Sept 2025; Open Payrolls AZ 2024
2
Diversity of appointments
Arizona demographics: 32% Hispanic, 5% Native American, 5% Black. First female Democratic governor of Arizona. Cabinet includes diverse appointments though specific diversity metrics not publicly reported. Dropped DVS, DEQ, DCS directors rather than face Senate confirmation battles — reducing leadership diversity in those agencies.
Governor's Appointment Records; Census ACS AZ Demographics; Tucson.com Aug 2024
2
Judicial appointment quality
Arizona uses merit-based judicial selection: Commission on Appellate Court Appointments provides nominees and governor selects from shortlist. Hobbs has made appellate and superior court appointments through this established system. No major judicial appointment controversies; merit selection insulates process from partisan disputes.
AZ Commission on Appellate Court Appointments; AZ Constitution Art. VI
2
State workforce pay competitiveness
FY2026 budget proposed $33.3M (GF ongoing) + $1.7M (other funds) for 5% pay increase for frontline law enforcement and correctional officers. $2M one-time for naloxone/overdose reversal medications for first responders. Average state employee salary $60,791 (2024). Agencies cite non-competitive pay driving turnover; some employees working second jobs.
AZ DOA Compensation Data; FY2026 Executive Budget Rollout Presentation; AZ Capitol Times
2
Whistleblower protection
No documented whistleblower retaliation under Hobbs administration. Fired retired Judge David Duncan from death penalty review (Nov 2024) but that was policy disagreement, not whistleblower retaliation. AG Mayes investigation into pay-to-play was initiated without reported retaliation against accusers. Standard whistleblower protections maintained.
AZ Ethics Commission Records; Governor's Office Personnel Records
3
Inspector General independence
Arizona Auditor General is legislative-branch appointment (not governor-appointed) — structural independence from executive. Auditor General Tom Boulden operates independently with own budget and staff. Hobbs has not interfered with audit functions. No Arizona-specific IG office at governor level — Auditor General fills oversight role.
AZ Auditor General; AZ Constitution Art. IV; Legislature Records
2
State employee morale
Agency FY2027 budget requests cite high turnover and low morale across multiple departments, with employees seeking outside employment or working two jobs. State employee pay averaging $60,791 lags private sector. 18-month leadership vacuum from Executive Deputy Director controversy (13 agencies in limbo) exacerbated morale issues. No systemwide survey publicly released.
AZ DOA; AZ Capitol Times Sept 2025; Agency FY2027 Budget Requests
2
Nepotism/cronyism
AG Mayes opened criminal investigation (June 2024) into pay-to-play scheme: Sunshine Residential Homes CEO Simon Kottoor served on Hobbs inaugural committee, donated $200K to inauguration fund + $200K to AZ Democratic Party/Hobbs campaign. Firm then received ~60% rate increase from DES for foster care, becoming AZ's highest-paid provider per child per day. Investigation covers bribery, fraud, conflict of interest, procurement code violations.
AZ AG Investigation June 2024; Governing.com; AZ Mirror; KJZZ; Campaign Finance Records
1
Senior staff criminal charges
No senior staff criminal charges filed. Super Bowl LVII ticket acceptance (6 staff including CoS Allie Bones) was ethics concern — AZ law bars public employees from accepting entertainment from public bodies, but governor's attorney argued Office of Tourism exemption. No formal investigation opened. No prosecution or criminal referral.
Court Records; AZ Family Sept 2023; AZ Ethics Commission
2
Agency performance accountability
ADCRR under Jensen v. Thornell federal court injunction (April 2023) for inadequate healthcare and conditions — compliance requires significant budget commitment. Hobbs appointed Director Ryan Thornell who established internal review committee on education, mental health, reentry. Legislature considering independent corrections oversight body (Rep. Walt Blackman). Standard OSPB performance reporting for other agencies.
AZ OSPB Performance Reports; Jensen v. Thornell Injunction; ADCRR FY2025 Budget; AZ Capitol Times
3
Disaster declaration timeliness
Timely disaster declarations for wildfires and extreme heat events. 2023 saw historic 31 consecutive days at 110°F+ in Phoenix (previous record: 18 days). 2024 set record 113 consecutive days at 100°F+. Declared heat emergencies and activated cooling centers. Wildfire declarations issued promptly during fire seasons.
AZ DEMA Emergency Records; FEMA Declarations; NWS Phoenix; CNBC Aug 2023
2
FEMA assistance secured
Secured FEMA disaster assistance for wildfire and severe weather events. Arizona's extreme heat deaths (645 in Maricopa County in 2023, 602 in 2024) complicate FEMA requests since heat is chronic rather than acute disaster under Stafford Act. Wildfire FEMA PA assistance secured for applicable events. Border-area emergency costs partially offset by federal programs.
FEMA PA Records — Arizona; Maricopa County Heat Death Reports; FOX Weather
2
Emergency reserve adequacy
Budget Stabilization Fund at $1.6B (highest in state history per FY2024 proposal). Emergency reserves available for wildfire, heat, and drought response. However, WIFA water infrastructure funding cut ~$500M in FY2025 budget — reduces long-term drought/water emergency preparedness. DEMA maintains standard operational reserves for disaster response.
AZ DEMA; AZ State Finance; AZ OSPB FY2025 Budget; WIFA Funding Records
2
Lives lost — preventable from state failure
Maricopa County heat deaths: 645 in 2023 (record), 602 in 2024 — heat death rate increased ~10x over 20 years in Arizona. Phoenix cooling centers expanded under Hobbs. Most deaths involve unsheltered individuals (homelessness/heat nexus). Not classified as acute state failure but chronic systemic challenge. No major preventable deaths from wildfire or flood response failure.
Maricopa County Heat Death Reports; Governing.com Dec 2024; AZ DEMA After-Action Reports
2
Post-disaster recovery timeline
Wildfire and severe weather post-disaster recovery proceeding within normal timelines. Arizona's primary recovery challenges are drought-related (Colorado River allocation cut 512,000 acre-feet for 5th consecutive year in 2025) — long-term rather than acute recovery. No major disaster recovery failures or delays documented under Hobbs.
FEMA PA Records — Arizona; Central Arizona Project Shortage Impacts; ADWR
2
Public health emergency response
Took office Jan 2023, post-pandemic. Allocated $2M one-time for first responder naloxone/overdose reversal (fentanyl crisis — border state with major trafficking corridors I-10/I-17). Task Force SAFE seized 6M+ fentanyl pills. AHCCCS serves 2M+ enrollees. $30M ARPA medical debt program reached 485K Arizonans. Standard public health infrastructure maintained.
AZ DHS Reports; FY2026 Executive Budget; Task Force SAFE Records; Governor's Medical Debt Program
2
Infrastructure failure prevention
No major infrastructure failures (power grid, water system, bridge collapse). Chase Field HVAC/roof deterioration addressed via $500M HB 2704 renovation bill. ADOT managing 132 bridges in poor condition and 3,193 miles of highway in poor condition. $9B+ 5-year transportation plan aims to address backlog. Water infrastructure is existential concern but managed without acute failure.
AZ DEMA; AZ DOT; FHWA Bridge/Highway Condition Data; HB 2704
3
National Guard deployment
Deployed 170+ AZ National Guard members as Task Force SAFE (summer 2024) to support CBP at border ports of entry — seized 6M+ fentanyl pills, 1,400+ lbs of meth/cocaine/heroin. Created Operation Desert Guardian (EO 2025-01) expanding border security in 4 border counties. Guard supports wildfire and heat emergency operations. First Democratic governor to announce cooperation with Trump immigration enforcement.
AZ National Guard Task Force SAFE; EO 2025-01; U.S. Army article; KJZZ; AZ Governor's Office
2
Emergency communication
Emergency communications for extreme heat events improved — expanded heat warnings, cooling center notifications, and public awareness campaigns. 2023 heat wave (31 days at 110°F+) tested communication systems. Wildfire evacuation communications functioned without major failures. Standard emergency alert and notification systems maintained through DEMA.
AZ DEMA Communications Records; NWS Phoenix Heat Warnings; Maricopa County Emergency Management
2
Interagency coordination
Created border coordination office within AZ DHS for state-tribal-federal law enforcement cooperation. Operation Desert Guardian (EO 2025-01) coordinates sheriffs, local police, and CBP across 4 border counties. Task Force SAFE integrates National Guard with CBP at ports of entry. Interagency heat response coordinates DEMA, DHS, Maricopa County, and city cooling centers.
AZ DEMA After-Action Reports; EO 2025-01; AZ DHS Border Coordination Office; Task Force SAFE
3
Pandemic response metrics
Took office Jan 2023, fully post-pandemic. Inherited post-COVID Arizona with strong economic recovery. Managed post-pandemic federal funding drawdowns (ARPA, ESSER). Innovatively deployed remaining ARPA funds for medical debt forgiveness ($30M erasing $642M for 485K residents). No pandemic-era decisions to evaluate.
N/A — post-pandemic governor; Governor's ARPA Medical Debt Program
2
Disaster preparedness & emergency infrastructure
Water: Colorado River allocation cut 512K acre-feet (30% of CAP supply) for 5th consecutive year in 2025. Introduced Active Management Area in Willcox for groundwater crisis. Passed Ag-to-Urban water rights transfer bill. But WIFA funding cut ~$500M. Heat: expanded cooling centers but 645 deaths (2023) and 602 (2024). Wildfire: 132 bridges and 3,193 highway miles in poor condition. Drought preparedness is existential priority.
AZ DEMA; ADWR; CAP Shortage Impacts; WIFA; Maricopa County Heat Reports
2
FOIA compliance rate
Arizona Public Records Act compliance standard. No major FOIA litigation against governor's office. However, governor's death penalty review (Judge Duncan) dismissal and AHCCCS contract process criticized for lack of transparency. Hobbs stated she would support dark money disclosure legislation after pay-to-play allegations (Nov 2025). Prop 211 dark money disclosure law in effect.
AZ Public Records Law; Court Records; KJZZ Nov 2025; Prop 211
2
Governor schedule availability
Governor's schedule published on azgovernor.gov. Regular press conferences and media availability though criticized for limited press access compared to predecessors. Declined to discuss death penalty views publicly ('not going to talk about' it, Dec 2024). Scottsdale City Council said Hobbs refused to meet with them regarding Axon HQ bill (SB 1543).
azgovernor.gov; AZ Mirror; FOX 10 Phoenix Dec 2024; 12News SB 1543 Coverage
2
Campaign finance compliance
AG criminal investigation (June 2024): Sunshine Residential Homes CEO Simon Kottoor donated $200K to Hobbs inaugural fund + $200K to AZ Democratic Party/campaign. Firm received ~60% DES rate increase. Dark money channels used. Hobbs said she would support disclosure legislation (Nov 2025) only after allegations surfaced. Prop 211 dark money disclosure law exists but didn't prevent the scheme.
AZ AG Investigation; Clean Elections Commission; KJZZ Nov 2025; Governing.com
1
Financial disclosure completeness
Financial disclosures filed with Arizona Secretary of State as required by law. However, Super Bowl ticket acceptance by 6 senior staff (from AZ Office of Tourism) was not initially disclosed proactively — came to light through media reporting (Sept 2023). Standard financial disclosure forms completed on time. No significant omissions identified.
AZ Secretary of State Financial Disclosure Records; AZ Family Super Bowl Reporting Sept 2023
2
Open meetings compliance
No documented Open Meetings Act violations by governor's office. Executive branch meetings comply with AZ open meetings law. Board and commission meetings accessible. Scottsdale Axon HQ decision by lame-duck city council raised local open government concerns, but that was a municipal issue — Hobbs signed bill (SB 1543) canceling the voter referendum.
AZ AG Open Meetings Records; SB 1543; AZ Mirror
3
Open data portal
Arizona Financial Transparency Portal (openbooks.az.gov) provides state/local government financial data. AZGeo geospatial data hub operational. Department-level data portals (DOE public data sets, ADOT, etc.) functional. General Accounting Office publishes Annual Financial Reports online. No comprehensive state-level open data ranking improvement initiative under Hobbs.
openbooks.az.gov; AZGeo; AZ GAO; AZ DOE Public Data Sets
2
Budget transparency
Executive budget proposals published on azospb.gov (FY2024-FY2026). JLBC provides independent legislative fiscal analysis (detailed baseline books, revenue reports, fiscal notes). FY2025 Summary Book published Jan 2024. Financial Transparency Portal (openbooks.az.gov) provides spending/revenue data. Budget documents accessible but WIFA funding cuts and ESA cost overruns require close tracking across multiple sources.
azospb.gov; AZ JLBC; openbooks.az.gov
2
Lobbying disclosure enforcement
Lobbying disclosure enforced through AZ Secretary of State registration system. Axon brought mobile tactical simulator to AZ Capitol (March 2025) as lobbying for SB 1543 — high-profile corporate lobbying. No documented lobbying enforcement failures. Prop 211 (voter-approved 2022) strengthened dark money disclosure. Standard lobbyist registration and reporting requirements maintained.
AZ Secretary of State Lobbying Records; Prop 211; AZ Mirror Axon Coverage
3
IG report publication
Auditor General (legislative branch, independent) publishes reports on azauditor.gov. FY2023 state ACFR completed (delayed by late agency submissions). ADOT FY2024 ACFR received clean opinion. Auditor General conducts performance audits of state agencies. Reports publicly accessible. No obstruction of report publication documented under Hobbs.
AZ Auditor General Website (azauditor.gov); ADOT FY2024 ACFR
2
Legislative audit cooperation
Executive branch generally cooperative with legislative audits. Auditor General operates independently (legislative appointment). AHCCCS Director rejected ALJ's recommendation to rebid $15B Medicaid contracts despite audit finding of 'arbitrary and flawed' procurement — shows resistance to external oversight in that specific case. ADCRR cooperating with Jensen v. Thornell compliance requirements.
AZ Auditor General; AHCCCS Director's Decision Sept 2024; Jensen v. Thornell
2
Press conference accessibility
Regular press conferences held. Declined to debate Kari Lake in 2022 campaign (unusual for gubernatorial candidate). As governor, holds periodic press events but criticized for limited media access. Refused to discuss death penalty views publicly (Dec 2024). Did not meet with Scottsdale City Council on Axon bill. Press accessibility adequate but not exceptional.
Governor's Office Media Schedule; AZ Mirror; FOX 10; 12News
2
Contract transparency
ALJ found AHCCCS used undisclosed scoring criteria and 'arbitrary and flawed procurement process' for $15B ALTCS Medicaid contracts. Mercy Care, Banner Health, BCBS excluded from contracts protested. ALJ recommended rebidding; AHCCCS Director denied appeal (Sept 2024), refusing transparency. Providers filed suit in Maricopa County Superior Court. Major contract transparency failure.
AZ ALJ Ruling Aug 2024; AHCCCS Director's Decision Sept 2024; AZ Family Sept 2024
1
Court order compliance on transparency
Initially appealed Maricopa County Superior Court ruling (June 2024) on illegal Executive Deputy Director appointments, then reversed course and agreed to resubmit 16 of 19 nominees to Senate. Complied with court order after appeal. AHCCCS Director defied ALJ recommendation on contract rebidding but that was administrative, not court order. Pattern shows eventual compliance after resistance.
Maricopa County Superior Court; AHCCCS Director's Decision; AZ Mirror; FOX 10
2
Personal criminal charges
No criminal charges filed against Hobbs personally. AG Kris Mayes (fellow Democrat) opened criminal investigation (June 2024) into pay-to-play allegations involving Sunshine Residential Homes — covers potential bribery, fraud, conflict of interest, procurement code violations. Investigation ongoing as of March 2026 with no charges filed. Governor's office maintains no wrongdoing occurred.
AZ AG Office; Court Records; Governing.com; AZ Mirror June 2024
3
Ethics complaints substantiated
No formally substantiated ethics complaints against Hobbs personally by AZ Ethics Commission. Super Bowl ticket acceptance by staff was ethics concern but no formal complaint filed. Pay-to-play is AG criminal investigation, not Ethics Commission complaint. Pre-governor: Talonya Adams $2.75M racial/sex discrimination jury award (2021) against AZ Senate involved Hobbs as Senate minority leader (she approved firing).
AZ Ethics Commission Records; 12News Adams Verdict Nov 2021; CNN Jan 2022
3
Gift/travel disclosure
Six senior staff (CoS Allie Bones, Pedregon, Loredo, Lopez, Chavez, and one other) accepted free Super Bowl LVII tickets from AZ Office of Tourism — valued $4K-$40K each. AZ law bars public employees from accepting 'expenditure for entertainment' from public bodies. Governor's attorney claimed Tourism doesn't lobby governor's office, so exemption applies. No investigation opened. Hobbs also defended $2M in 'wine and dine' spending.
AZ Family Sept 2023; AZ Daily Independent; Ahwatukee.com Oct 2023
1
Conflict of interest
Clear appearance of conflict: Sunshine Residential Homes CEO Simon Kottoor sat on Hobbs inaugural committee, donated $200K to inauguration + $200K to party/campaign. DES then approved ~60% rate increase making Sunshine AZ's highest-paid foster care provider per child per day. AG criminal investigation covers conflict of interest specifically. Governor says no wrongdoing but has not explained rate increase rationale.
AZ AG Investigation June 2024; Governing.com; AZ Capitol Times; 12News
1
State resources for politics
No documented misuse of state resources for political purposes. Governor's office defended as official use the $2M spent on 'wine and dine' activities (entertainment, events). Super Bowl tickets came from state Office of Tourism, not campaign funds. No allegations of using state staff for campaign work. Standard separation between official and political activity maintained.
AZ Ethics Commission Records; Ahwatukee.com Oct 2023; Governor's Office
3
Truthfulness in official statements
No official findings of false statements. However, framing of Executive Deputy Director appointments as legally compliant was contradicted by court ruling (June 2024). Governor's attorney's argument that Super Bowl ticket law didn't apply was legally untested. Death penalty review reversal (Jan 2023 order vs. Nov 2024 cancellation) represented significant unacknowledged policy shift. No PolitiFact-style 'pants on fire' ratings.
Governor's Office Public Statements; Maricopa County Superior Court June 2024
2
Ethics infrastructure protection
AZ Ethics Commission continues to operate. Auditor General independence maintained (legislative branch appointment). No attempts to weaken oversight bodies. However, no new ethics infrastructure created either. Hobbs said she would support dark money disclosure legislation (Nov 2025) — reactive rather than proactive. Prop 211 dark money disclosure (voter-approved 2022) implemented without interference.
AZ Ethics Commission; Legislature Records; KJZZ Nov 2025; Prop 211
2
Emoluments/self-dealing
No documented self-dealing by Hobbs personally. Financial disclosures show no personal business interests receiving state contracts. Pay-to-play investigation involves donor-to-state-contract pipeline, not personal enrichment. No emoluments clause concerns. No real estate or business holdings creating conflicts. Former social worker and state legislator — limited private sector ties.
AZ Ethics Commission Financial Disclosures; Secretary of State Records
3
Donor-to-contract pipeline
ACTIVE AG CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION: Sunshine Residential Homes CEO Simon Kottoor on inaugural committee. Donated $200K to inauguration fund + $200K to AZ Democratic Party/Hobbs campaign (total $400K). DES then approved ~60% rate increase — firm became AZ's highest-paid foster care provider per child per day. AG Mayes (Democrat) investigating bribery, fraud, conflict of interest, and procurement code violations. No charges yet but investigation active since June 2024.
AZ AG Criminal Investigation June 2024; AZ Capitol Times; Governing.com; Axios Phoenix
0
Foreign influence
No foreign influence concerns. No FARA registrations linked to Hobbs or senior staff. TSMC (Taiwan) investment of $65B+ in Arizona is foreign direct investment but conducted through proper channels with CHIPS Act oversight. Signed foreign land ownership restrictions bill. No foreign government lobbying or gift concerns identified.
DOJ FARA Database; TSMC CHIPS Act Award; AZ Foreign Land Ownership Legislation
3
Sexual harassment claims
Pre-governor: As Senate minority leader, Hobbs approved firing of Talonya Adams (Black female policy adviser) in 2015. Jury awarded Adams $2.75M for racial and sex discrimination (Nov 2021) — later capped at $300K by federal law. Hobbs apologized. CNN reported it as ongoing campaign controversy. No harassment or discrimination claims filed against Hobbs as governor.
12News Nov 2021; CNN Jan 2022; Federal Court Adams v. AZ Senate; AZ Personnel Records
2
Records preservation
No documented records destruction or improper disposal. State archives retention schedules followed. Death penalty review by Judge Duncan was cancelled (Nov 2024) before completion — unclear if all review materials preserved. No allegations of email deletion or record suppression. Standard records management practices.
AZ State Archives; Governor's Office Records Management
3
Revolving door
No documented revolving door violations. Three agency heads (DCS, DEQ, DVS directors) were dropped from renomination rather than face Senate confirmation — their post-government employment not tracked. Sunshine Residential Homes pay-to-play investigation involves donor-to-contract pipeline but not revolving door per se. No former staff lobbying scandals identified.
AZ Ethics Commission Records; Governor's Personnel Records
3
Fraud losses
No major fraud losses in state programs. Auditor General conducts fraud detection independently. Prop 200 citizenship verification for public benefits limits unauthorized access. E-Verify (LAWA) reduces employment fraud. Pay-to-play investigation is procurement/corruption issue rather than program fraud. DES and AHCCCS eligibility systems functional.
AZ Auditor General Reports; Prop 200; LAWA; DES/AHCCCS Records
3
Program integrity — eligibility verification
AHCCCS serves 2M+ Medicaid enrollees with standard eligibility verification. Prop 200 requires citizenship proof for state/local benefits — nation's strongest. SAVE system integrated. DES manages SNAP, TANF, child care assistance with verification protocols. No documented widespread eligibility fraud. Federal funding cuts reduced DES staffing capacity in 2025.
AZ AHCCCS; AZ DES Program Records; Prop 200; DES Blog UI Modernization
3
IT system modernization
DES unemployment insurance IT modernization (CACTUS system) launched Sept 7, 2025 — delayed 1 year from Oct 2024 target due to data conversion issues and compliance changes. Appeals backlog dating to Nov 2024. Federal funding cuts forced DES workforce reductions, impacting IT capacity. No catastrophic system failures but modernization behind schedule. Standard IT operations across other agencies.
AZ DOA IT Division; DES UI Modernization Blog; ABC15 Investigations; AZ Family Aug 2025
2
Permit processing timeliness
Semiconductor permitting expedited for TSMC ($65B, 3 fabs, 6,000 direct jobs + 20,000 construction jobs). First fab on track for 4nm production H1 2025. AZ Commerce Authority prioritized CHIPS Act-related permitting. Axon HQ permitting fast-tracked via SB 1543 (overriding Scottsdale voter referendum). Standard permitting timelines for other commercial/residential projects.
AZ Commerce Authority; TSMC Arizona; SB 1543; Governor's Office
2
Child welfare system
DCS director (David Lujan) dropped from renomination after Senate confirmation fight — leadership instability. Pay-to-play AG investigation: Sunshine Residential Homes received ~60% rate increase from DES, becoming AZ's highest-paid foster care provider per child. DCS system chronically challenged with high caseloads. AG investigation covers potential illegal use of state monies and procurement violations in child welfare contracts.
AZ DCS Reports; AG Investigation June 2024; Governing.com; Tucson.com Aug 2024
1
Medicaid program management
ALJ found AHCCCS used 'arbitrary and flawed procurement process' with undisclosed scoring criteria for ALTCS contracts worth $15B — serving elderly and physically disabled. Excluded Mercy Care, Banner Health, BCBS from awards. AHCCCS Director denied appeal, refusing to rebid. Providers sued in Maricopa County Superior Court. AHCCCS serves 2M+ enrollees overall. $30M medical debt program innovative but contract process deeply flawed.
AZ ALJ Ruling Aug 2024; AHCCCS Director's Decision; AZ Family Sept 2024; AZPHA Aug 2024
1
Environmental program
ADEQ meets EPA-delegated standards; director Karen Peters dropped from Senate renomination (one of 3 dropped). Water is existential: Colorado River allocation cut 512K acre-feet (5th consecutive year, 2025). Introduced Willcox Active Management Area for groundwater crisis. Passed Ag-to-Urban water rights transfer bill. But FY2025 budget cut WIFA water funding ~$500M and eliminated $333M water augmentation allocation. Groundwater declining faster than Colorado River flows.
EPA State Program Evaluations; ADEQ; ADWR; Inside Climate News Nov 2025; AZ Mirror Feb 2026
2
Transportation project delivery
ADOT 5-year plan: $9B+ in transportation investments, $2.6B for pavement/bridge preservation. $95M INFRA grant for 26-mile I-10 widening (Phoenix-Casa Grande, $1B total project) — construction launched early 2024 with Gila River bridge replacement. State contributing $692M, MAG adding $221M from Prop 400. Goal: widen I-10 to 3 lanes each direction Phoenix-Tucson. 132 bridges and 3,193 highway miles in poor condition statewide.
AZ DOT; USDOT INFRA Grant; ADOT 5-Year Construction Program; FHWA Condition Data
2
Unemployment insurance system
UI system modernization (CACTUS) launched Sept 2025, 1 year behind schedule due to data conversion issues. Appeals backlog dating to Nov 2024. DES workforce cut by federal funding reductions impacting capacity. Arizona unemployment 4.3% (Dec 2025), at national average. UI trust fund solvent. Fewer judges available for UI appeals. System functional but modernization was troubled.
DOL UI Performance Data; BLS LAUS; DES UI Modernization; ABC15 Investigations
2
Veterans services
DVS director (Dana Allmond) dropped from Senate renomination — one of 3 directors Hobbs abandoned. ADVS awarded $1.8M in Veterans Donation Fund grants for FY2024-2025 ($300K small grants + $1.5M large grants). Military Family Relief Fund operational. Arizona hosts Luke AFB, Fort Huachuca, Davis-Monthan AFB, and MCAS Yuma — major military state. DVS services cover 500K+ veterans.
AZ DVS; VA State Grant Data; DVS FY2024-2025 VDF Grants; Tucson.com Aug 2024
2
Housing program effectiveness
Arizona housing costs surpassed national average for first time. Median home $427,272 (March 2024). Rents up 66% over 10 years to avg $1,671/month. Housing values increased 7x faster than income (2010-2023). Record 106,587 eviction filings statewide in 2024 (Maricopa: 87,130 — highest ever). Nearly 50% of renters paying 30%+ of income on housing. Hobbs vetoed Starter Homes Act for 'unclear outcomes.' No major housing legislation passed.
ASU News Aug 2025; Census ACS; BEA RPP; Common Sense Institute AZ Q1 2025; AZ Capitol Times Dec 2025
1
Corrections system
ADCRR under Jensen v. Thornell federal court injunction (April 2023) for inadequate healthcare and conditions of confinement — requires significant compliance funding. Director Thornell established internal review committee on education, mental health, reentry. Reentry 2030 initiative targets 30% increase in industry credentials and 20% increase in post-release employment. Legislature considering independent corrections oversight body (Rep. Blackman). Ten reform bills signed into law in 2025.
AZ DOC Reports; BJS NPS; Jensen v. Thornell; ADCRR FY2025 Budget; AZ Capitol Times Jan 2025
2
Federal funding captured
TSMC Arizona awarded $6.6B CHIPS Act direct funding (Nov 2024) — $65B+ total investment for 3 fabs, 6,000 direct high-tech jobs, 20,000+ construction jobs. Largest foreign greenfield FDI in U.S. history. First fab producing 4nm chips H1 2025. $95M INFRA grant for I-10 widening. ARPA $30M leveraged into $642M medical debt relief. BIL highway/bridge funds deployed. $17M federal border security funds announced Jan 2025.
USASpending.gov; USDOT BIL Factsheet; CHIPS Act Award Nov 2024; Governor's Office Jan 2025
2
Federal corrective action plans
No major federal corrective actions required for grant programs. Jensen v. Thornell federal court injunction (April 2023) addresses ADCRR conditions — state compliance ongoing. Federal audit clearinghouse shows standard findings. FEMA disaster assistance processed without corrective actions. CHIPS Act TSMC award includes federal oversight but proceeding on schedule.
Federal Audit Clearinghouse — Arizona; Jensen v. Thornell; CHIPS Act Oversight
3
Interstate cooperation
Leading Lower Basin coalition (AZ, CA, NV) in Colorado River negotiations — offered 1.5M acre-feet/yr cuts. Upper Basin (CO, UT, WY, NM) refused firm commitments. States missed Nov 2025 deadline; Feb 2026 deadline also challenged. Arizona blasts Upper Basin for refusing cuts. AZ cut 512K acre-feet (30% of CAP supply) for 5th consecutive year. Lower Basin reduced consumption from 7.4M to 6M acre-feet (2015-2024). Existential interstate water crisis.
Interstate Compact Records; CAP Shortage Impacts; AZ Mirror Feb 2026; CPR Oct 2025
2
Local government relations
Signed SB 1543 overriding Scottsdale voter referendum on Axon 74-acre HQ/housing campus — lame-duck city council approved rezoning, residents gathered 25K+ signatures for ballot challenge, Hobbs sided with Axon. Scottsdale City Council said Hobbs refused to meet. However, Chase Field deal (HB 2704) showed effective city-state cooperation with Phoenix. Standard League of Cities and Towns relations otherwise. Operation Desert Guardian coordinates with border county sheriffs.
AZ League of Cities and Towns; AZ Mirror SB 1543; HB 2704; EO 2025-01
3
Federal litigation costs
Moderate federal litigation. Arizona 370-mile border with Mexico generates ongoing immigration litigation. AG Mayes (Democrat) has not joined multi-state Republican coalitions suing for stricter federal enforcement. Pentagon created military border zones in AZ (Barry M. Goldwater Range, $230M barrier project Oct 2025, Fort Huachuca extension). Hobbs positioned as first Democratic governor to announce cooperation with Trump immigration enforcement. Border state dynamics ensure constant federal interaction.
AZ AG Litigation Records; Military.com July 2025; Stars and Stripes Oct 2025; KJZZ Nov 2024
2
Constituent response
Governor's office maintains constituent services operation on azgovernor.gov. Medical debt program directly benefited 485,000 Arizonans ($642M forgiven). Expanded cooling center access during record heat waves (645 deaths 2023, 602 deaths 2024). $17M border security funding announced for border communities. Scottsdale residents felt ignored on Axon bill (SB 1543). Standard constituent response for incoming correspondence and requests.
Governor's Office; azgovernor.gov; Medical Debt Program; SB 1543 Coverage
3
Town halls held
Periodic community engagements and public events. Visited border facilities (Nov 2024) announcing continued Guard deployment and federal cooperation plans. Signed Chase Field bill at public ceremony (June 2025). Declined to debate Kari Lake in 2022 campaign — pattern of limited direct public engagement. Criticized for not meeting with Scottsdale City Council on Axon bill. No regular town hall schedule published.
Governor's Office Schedule; KJZZ Nov 2024; AZ Sports June 2025; 12News SB 1543
2
Constituent satisfaction
Approval volatile: 32% negative (May 2024) rising to 43% disapproval (Dec 2025 — 12pt increase). Current: 39% approve, 40% disapprove, 21% neutral (Emerson 2026). Noble Predictive showed net +6 among some demographics. Polls show dead-heat 2026 reelection matchups: 44-43% vs Biggs, 43-42% vs Robson, 44-39% vs Schweikert. One outlier poll showed 51-32% Hobbs lead. Arizona is top GOP 2026 target.
Noble Predictive Insights; Emerson College Polling; Race to the WH; 270toWin
1
ADA compliance
Standard ADA compliance across state agencies and facilities. No DOJ ADA enforcement actions against Arizona during Hobbs tenure. Jensen v. Thornell prison conditions injunction addresses healthcare/conditions but not specifically ADA. State buildings and services meet accessibility requirements. Governor's website and communications accessible.
DOJ ADA Reviews; DOJ Civil Rights Division; Jensen v. Thornell
3
Electoral accountability
Won 2022 by 17,117 votes (50.32% to 49.33%, margin 0.67%) — closest AZ governor race since 1990. Declined to debate Kari Lake. Faces dead-heat 2026 reelection polling (44-43% vs Biggs). Arizona is top GOP 2026 target. Approval trending net negative (39% approve, 40% disapprove). Won Maricopa County by 37,638 votes — larger than statewide margin. Lake's election challenges all failed in court.
AZ Secretary of State 2022 Results; NBC/CBS/NPR Election Coverage; Emerson 2026 Polling
1

Section B — State Outcomes 447/975

13 categories measuring real-world outcomes: economic performance, population trends, fiscal health, public safety, education, healthcare, infrastructure, cost of living, transparency, controversy, historical context, constituent satisfaction, and immigration compliance.

BLS LAUS: unemployment 4.3% (Dec 2025), at national average. BEA: GDP growth projected 2.8% (2025), slightly above national 2.7%. TSMC semiconductor plant bringing major investment. Employment growth 0.7% YoY. Strong in-migration driving economic activity. Per capita income below national average but growing.
Census: AZ population 7,582,384 (2025), growing 1.2-1.3% annually (above national average). Added 97,044 residents mid-2024 to mid-2025. Phoenix metro added ~85,000 (2023-2024): 14,500 natural increase, 21,000 domestic transplants, 49,000 international newcomers. Maricopa County ranked #1 nationally for net migration. Since 2020 Census, +460,000 residents (6% growth), 97% from migration. Projected to reach 9.8M by 2060 (+26%). 21.3% under 18, 19.3% over 65. Growth strains water (Colorado River 512K acre-foot cuts) and infrastructure.
Inherited $1.4B projected deficit from flat tax transition and ESA voucher costs. Bipartisan budget deal addressed gap. S&P upgraded credit outlook to positive. $17.6B FY2025 budget passed. But ESA costs continue to exceed projections creating ongoing fiscal pressure. Low debt.
FBI UCR 2024: violent crime 30,888 incidents (422/100K, 14th highest nationally — 17.5% above US average). Violent crime declined 2.7% (vs national 5.4% decline). Property crime dropped 7% (129,963 incidents, from 139,350). Crime breakdown: 74% aggravated assaults, 15.3% robberies, 9.5% rapes, 1.2% murders. Phoenix homicides down dramatically: 84 through Q3 2025 vs 111 (2024) and 137 (2023). Total Phoenix violent crime down 1,000+ incidents vs 2024. $17M border security funding (EO 2025-01). Operation Desert Guardian coordinates with border county sheriffs.
NAEP 2024: 4th grade reading ranked 8th nationally (strong). But 8th grade math at lowest since 2003. ESA voucher expansion creating fiscal tension and equity debates. Per-pupil spending below national average. Budget includes $600M for K-12 schools.
Arizona expanded Medicaid. AHCCCS serves 2M+ enrollees. $30M ARPA funds used to forgive ~$2B in medical debt (innovative). But AHCCCS $15B contract award process found flawed by ALJ. Uninsured rate moderate. Rural healthcare access challenges persist.
FHWA: 132 bridges in poor condition, 3,193 miles of highway in poor condition. Commute times up 11.1%. Each driver pays $614/year for road damage. ADOT $12.7B five-year plan. $95M federal I-10 grant. BIL funds being deployed. Broadband expansion underway.
BEA RPP: Arizona cost of living rose ABOVE national average for first time. Rents up 23% (2019-2024) vs income up only 4% inflation-adjusted. Median home $419,667 (above national $320K). Housing affordability rapidly deteriorating. Was affordable state, now becoming expensive.
AZ Financial Transparency Portal (openbooks.az.gov) provides searchable revenue/spending data for state, counties, cities, universities, school districts. JLBC publishes detailed appropriations and fiscal notes. ARS 39-121 mandates public records open at all times during office hours. AZ Ombudsman publishes public records law guide (2023 edition). But AHCCCS $15B Medicaid managed care contract process found flawed by ALJ — lacked adequate transparency. Pay-to-play AG investigation (CEO/inaugural committee/rate increase). Super Bowl ticket acceptance ethics questions unresolved.
Pay-to-play AG investigation (group home CEO/inaugural committee/rate increase). AHCCCS $15B contract flaws. Executive Deputy Director appointments ruled illegal. Super Bowl ticket ethics questions. Record 178 vetoes signal legislative dysfunction. 1864 abortion ban repeal was politically significant.
24th governor of Arizona, first Democrat since Janet Napolitano (2003-2009). Succeeded Doug Ducey (R, 2015-2023, term-limited). Narrowest D gubernatorial win since 1990 (0.67% margin). Navigated divided government with bipartisan budget deal — inherited $1.4B projected deficit from Ducey-era 2.5% flat tax and ESA voucher expansion. S&P credit outlook upgrade to positive. Record 178 vetoes — historically unprecedented. Hobbs comes from social work background (NAU/ASU degrees) vs Ducey's corporate (Cold Stone Creamery) philosophy. Population and economic growth continue upward trajectory. Colorado River water crisis is generational challenge — AZ cut 512K acre-feet (30% of CAP supply) for 5th consecutive year.
Approval volatile: 36% (May 2024 low) to net +6 by Feb 2026. Won 2022 by less than 1 point. Faces difficult reelection path. +3 among independents (Feb 2026). Polarizing figure but trending upward. Election legitimacy questions from opponent's supporters persist.
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Section C — Oath Fidelity +19 (-378 to +378)

126 items scored -3 to +3 measuring fidelity to constitutional oath. Grounded in Supreme Court precedent and constitutional text.

+3Exemplary +2Strong +1Adequate 0Neutral -1Concerning -2Failing -3Hostile

Protection of Life

Declaration of Independence; 5th/14th Amendments
Score: -1 Range: -93 to 93 Items: 31
Violent crime rate trend
AZ violent crime declining but slower than national average. Still above national rate. Property crime declining in Phoenix metro.
FBI UCR 2023-2024; AZ DPS
+1
Homicide rate relative to national average
AZ homicide rate above national average by 15-30%. Phoenix metro contributes significantly. Border-related crime a factor.
FBI UCR; CDC WONDER
-1
Homicide clearance rate
AZ homicide clearance rate near national average approximately 45-55%. Phoenix PD and DPS maintain standard investigation capacity.
FBI SHR; AZ DPS
0
Law enforcement staffing adequacy
AZ law enforcement staffing adequate overall. Phoenix PD and Maricopa County Sheriff well-staffed. Some rural gaps.
FBI LEOKA; BJS CSLLEA
0
Drug overdose death rate trend
AZ fentanyl deaths elevated. Border proximity creates vulnerability. Overdose rate above national average and rising.
CDC WONDER; NCHS; AZ DHS
-1
Emergency management preparedness
AZ DEMA manages wildfire, flood, and heat emergency preparedness. Standard capabilities. Extreme heat becoming primary concern.
FEMA SPR; AZ DEMA
+1
Preventable mass-casualty event response
No major mass-casualty events during tenure requiring special response. Heat-related deaths a chronic issue (600+ in Maricopa County 2023) but not single-event.
FEMA; AZ DEMA; Maricopa County
0
Infrastructure safety — bridge and road conditions
AZ infrastructure in reasonable condition. Rapid growth driving expansion needs. ADOT managing growth-related demands.
FHWA NBI; ADOT
+1
Water and dam safety compliance
AZ facing existential water crisis. Colorado River allocation cuts. Groundwater depletion in rural areas. Phoenix metro dependent on Central Arizona Project. Long-term sustainability at risk.
EPA SDWIS; ADWR; Bureau of Reclamation
-1
Healthcare access — uninsured rate
AZ uninsured rate approximately 10-12%, above national average. AHCCCS (Medicaid) expansion helps but gaps remain, especially among immigrant population.
Census ACS; KFF
-1
Maternal mortality rate
AZ maternal mortality rate near national average range. Standard programs in place. Some rural access gaps.
CDC WONDER; NCHS
0
Infant mortality rate
AZ infant mortality rate near national average approximately 5.5-6.5 per 1K. Standard performance.
CDC WONDER; NCHS
0
Self-defense rights — Castle Doctrine / Stand Your Ground
AZ has constitutional carry + Castle Doctrine + Stand Your Ground + no duty to retreat + civil immunity. Among strongest self-defense frameworks nationally.
AZ statutes; NRA-ILA
+3
Death penalty procedural safeguards
AZ retains death penalty with mandatory appellate review. Post-conviction DNA access. Clemency board operational. Some execution protocol controversies.
DPIC; AZ clemency records
+1
Suicide prevention program funding and outcomes
AZ suicide rate slightly above national average. Some funded programs. 988 integration underway. Average performance.
CDC WISQARS; AFSP AZ
0
911/emergency response time adequacy
Urban response times adequate in Phoenix/Tucson metros. Rural AZ faces significant response challenges. Mixed statewide.
NFPA; AZ EMS data
0
Opioid/fentanyl interdiction and treatment funding
AZ border proximity drives fentanyl crisis. Overdose deaths elevated. Some interdiction through DPS but federal border being primary enforcement point. Treatment funded but insufficient.
SAMHSA; CDC WONDER; DEA
-1
Veteran suicide and healthcare access
AZ ADVS active. Luke AFB, Davis-Monthan significant military presence. Large retiree veteran population. VA healthcare accessible in metro areas.
VA SAIL; AZ ADVS
+1
Food safety and foodborne illness enforcement
AZ food safety programs meet FDA conformance above 80%. Agriculture sector regulated. Standard compliance.
FDA; CDC FoodNet
+1
Workplace fatality rate
AZ workplace fatality rate near national average. Construction and mining sectors elevate rate. Standard performance.
BLS CFOI; OSHA
0
Domestic violence fatality rate and funding
AZ has standard DV programs. Average performance. Shelter capacity adequate in metro areas.
NNEDV; AZ DV stats
0
Correctional facility death rate and conditions
AZ DOC has faced consent decree (Parsons v. Ryan) over healthcare and conditions. Some improvement but ongoing federal monitoring. Above average death rate.
BJS Mortality; Parsons v. Ryan; AZ DOC
-1
Pollution-related mortality and environmental health
AZ has some air quality nonattainment in Phoenix metro (PM10, ozone). Superfund sites managed. Mining legacy contamination. Moderate environmental issues.
EPA Green Book; AZ DEQ
0
Pedestrian and traffic fatality rate
AZ has among highest pedestrian fatality rates nationally. Phoenix metro particularly dangerous. Traffic fatality rate above national average.
NHTSA FARS; ADOT; GHSA
-1
Sanctity of life legislative framework
Signed repeal of 1864 near-total abortion ban (SB 1162). Supported Prop 139 enshrining abortion rights. 15-week limit maintained (Ducey-era). Removed some protections while maintaining basic framework.
Guttmacher; SB 1162; Prop 139
-1
Homeless mortality — exposure deaths, overdoses in encampments, violence
Vetoed SB 1024 encampment clearing bill. Maricopa County homelessness rising. Voters passed Prop 312 to force enforcement Hobbs resisted.
KAWC; Just The News; Arizona Capitol Times
-1
Population loss impact on services — EMS/hospital closures, tax base erosion
Arizona ranked 4th in net domestic migration gaining 55,505 residents. Strong job growth (8th nationally). No service closures.
Census Bureau; ABC15
+1
Police staffing/funding — governor's direct actions on law enforcement
Signed EO partnering with DOJ. But Judicial Watch sued over alleged obstruction of ICE enforcement by state police. Mixed record.
AZ Governor; Judicial Watch
0
Criminal recidivism from early release — parole/clemency, no-cash-bail
Signed probation reform with recidivism incentives (29% three-year rate). Created prison oversight. Bipartisan approach.
Alliance for Safety and Justice; Cronkite News
0
Prison/shelter housing — biological males in women's facilities
Vetoed Women's Bill of Rights codifying biological definition of 'woman.' Vetoed multiple anti-transgender bills. No sex-based facility protections.
Washington Times; Truthout; AZ Mirror
-2
Mental health crisis system — involuntary commitment reform, crisis intervention
No major mental health crisis reforms. Created prison oversight commission but no involuntary commitment or crisis intervention changes.
General research
0

Constitutional Rights

Bill of Rights (Amendments I-X); 14th Amendment incorporation
Score: 16 Range: -87 to 87 Items: 29
Second Amendment — right to carry status
AZ has constitutional/permitless carry (enacted pre-Hobbs). Strong preemption. Civil liability protections. Among strongest 2A states. Hobbs inherited but did not repeal — credit for maintaining, but did not enact.
AZ statutes; USCCA
+2
Second Amendment — semi-automatic rifle restrictions
No semi-automatic restrictions in AZ beyond federal law. Divided government prevented any new restrictions. Full access maintained.
AZ statutes; ATF
+2
Second Amendment — magazine capacity restrictions
No magazine capacity restrictions in AZ. Full standard-capacity access. Divided legislature prevented restrictions.
AZ statutes; NRA-ILA
+2
Second Amendment — Red Flag / ERPO due process
AZ has no ERPO/Red Flag law. Relies on existing due process (involuntary commitment, criminal charges). Divided legislature prevented enactment.
AZ statutes
+2
First Amendment — campus free speech protections
AZ has campus free speech protections (HB 2563, Ducey-era). Bans free speech zones at public universities. Protections maintained under Hobbs.
FIRE rankings; AZ legislation
+1
First Amendment — anti-SLAPP protections
AZ has anti-SLAPP statute with fee-shifting. Moderate scope. Functional protections.
AZ statutes; Public Participation Project
+1
First Amendment — religious liberty protections
AZ has Free Exercise of Religion Act. General respect for religious exercise. No documented conflicts under Hobbs.
AZ FERA; Becket Fund
0
Fourth Amendment — warrant requirements for digital surveillance
AZ relies primarily on federal Carpenter standard. No comprehensive state electronic privacy statute. Standard compliance.
AZ statutes; EFF
0
Fourth Amendment — civil asset forfeiture reform
AZ enacted meaningful forfeiture reform (2017) requiring conviction. Improved protections. IJ rates AZ as improved.
IJ Policing for Profit; AZ statutes
+1
Fifth Amendment — eminent domain protections post-Kelo
AZ enacted Prop 207 (2006) — constitutional amendment prohibiting economic development takings. Among strongest protections nationally.
AZ Prop 207; IJ data
+2
Due process — regulatory takings and permitting timelines
AZ regulatory environment moderate. Growth creating permitting backlogs in Maricopa County. Housing affordability suffering from regulatory constraints.
AZ regulatory data
0
Tenth Amendment — federal overreach resistance
Hobbs rescinded Ducey-era immigration enforcement EOs. Did not join multistate resistance to federal overreach. Passive posture on sovereignty. But first D governor to announce cooperation with Trump enforcement.
Governor's EO records
-1
Equal Protection — state contracting nondiscrimination
AZ voters passed Prop 209-equivalent banning race preferences. Standard nondiscrimination. SFFA generally compliant.
AZ procurement data; Prop 209
0
Second Amendment — state preemption of local firearms laws
AZ has full preemption with penalties and enforcement mechanism. Among strongest preemption statutes nationally. Hobbs did not change.
AZ statutes; NRA-ILA
+3
First Amendment — government transparency and FOIA compliance
AZ public records law functional. Hobbs administration standard compliance. No major FOIA controversies or reforms.
AZ AG public records
0
Sixth Amendment — public defender funding adequacy
AZ public defender system functional. County-based system with varying quality. Standard indigent defense.
Sixth Amendment Center; AZ PD
0
Eighth Amendment — bail reform and pretrial detention
AZ has standard bail system. Prop 100 (2006) requires detention for illegal immigrants charged with serious felonies. Moderate framework.
Pretrial Justice Institute; AZ court data
0
Property rights — regulatory burden and economic freedom
AZ has below-average regulatory burden. Pro-business environment. Growth-friendly policies maintained. Hobbs did not significantly increase regulation.
Mercatus RegData; AZ regulatory data
+1
Second Amendment — governor's litigation posture on firearms cases
AZ AG (Mayes) has not pursued major anti-2A litigation. Neutral litigation posture. No significant pro or anti-2A amicus activity.
AZ AG litigation
0
First Amendment — compelled speech protections
No documented compelled speech mandates under Hobbs. Standard environment.
AZ statutes
0
Commerce Clause compliance — interstate trade barriers
AZ has good interstate commerce environment. Universal license recognition initiative. Pro-business framework. Minimal barriers.
IJ; AZ licensing data
+1
Privileges and Immunities — occupational licensing reform
AZ has universal out-of-state license recognition (HB 2569, Ducey-era 2019). National model. Hobbs maintained. Among best in nation.
IJ License to Work; AZ HB 2569
+2
Contract Clause — state compliance with contractual obligations
AZ pension funded ratios moderate (ASRS approximately 70-75%). S&P outlook upgraded to positive. Making ARC payments. Stable.
Pew pension data; ASRS; S&P
+1
Jury trial rights — civil and criminal jury access
Standard jury access in AZ. No documented issues. Average environment.
AZ court reports; NCSC
0
Immigration law compliance — Supremacy Clause adherence
AZ not a formal sanctuary state — SB 1070 framework remains. LAWA E-Verify mandate in place. Maricopa 287(g) active. Prop 200 verification. But Hobbs rescinded Ducey enforcement EOs, weakening posture. Mixed record.
8 USC §1373; AZ SB 1070; LAWA; Prop 200
-1
Qualified immunity / due process for officers
No qualified immunity action. Status quo maintained.
General research
0
Voter ID and ballot chain-of-custody
Vetoed HB 2017, HB 2046, HB 2050 for election transparency. Did sign HB 2129 for audit coverage. More vetoes than signings.
Votebeat; American Faith; AZ Governor
-1
Non-citizen voting prevention
Arizona uniquely requires proof of citizenship for full ballot. Audit revealed citizenship tracking problems. Existing protections predate Hobbs.
ABC15; Newsweek
0
Women's sports / Title IX — biological sex protections in state-funded athletics
Consistently vetoed biological sex protections. Vetoed Women's Bill of Rights. Publicly stated restrictions are 'detrimental.'
LGBTQ Nation; Blog for Arizona; AZ Mirror
-2

Child Welfare & Parental Rights

Meyer v. Nebraska (1923); Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925); Troxel v. Granville (2000); Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972); Parham v. J.R. (1979); 14th Amendment substantive due process
Score: -1 Range: -75 to 75 Items: 25
Parental rights legislation — statutory recognition
No comprehensive Parental Bill of Rights enacted. Divided government prevents action either direction. Common law protections respected.
AZ legislation; NCSL
0
Education choice — school choice programs
AZ has universal ESA (Empowerment Scholarship Account) — among strongest choice programs nationally. But Hobbs vetoed ESA expansion bills and sought to restrict program. ESA survives due to prior legislation.
EdChoice; AZ ESA program
-1
Parental notification/consent for medical procedures on minors
AZ has standard parental consent requirements. Parental consent required for abortion (with judicial bypass). Standard framework maintained.
AZ statutes; Guttmacher
0
Gender-transition procedures for minors — restrictions
No legislation restricting or expanding gender-transition for minors enacted under Hobbs. Vetoed trans athlete bills. Divided government prevents action either direction.
AZ legislation; veto records
0
Child abuse and neglect — substantiated case rate trend
AZ DCS reports 10,000+ children in foster care. 21,841 qualifying hotline reports. Overrepresentation of minority children significant. System remains challenged.
ACF NCANDS; AZ DCS
-1
Foster care — CFSR conformity assessment
AZ foster care system historically troubled (DCS created 2014 after CPS collapse). Reform ongoing. CFSR shows improvement but conformity gaps remain.
ACF CFSR; AZ DCS
-1
Foster care — permanency outcomes
AZ foster care permanency outcomes improving from poor baseline. DCS reform continuing. Near national averages.
ACF AFCARS; AZ DCS
0
Child trafficking prevention and prosecution
AZ AG has trafficking enforcement. Border proximity creates significant vulnerability. I-10/I-17 corridors are trafficking routes. Task force active.
Polaris; AZ AG
+1
Education outcomes — 4th grade NAEP reading proficiency
AZ 4th grade NAEP reading ranked 8th nationally — strong performance. Approximately 38-42% proficient.
NCES NAEP
+2
Education outcomes — 8th grade NAEP math proficiency
AZ 8th grade NAEP math near national average. Approximately 25-30% proficient. Average performance.
NCES NAEP
0
Parental curriculum transparency
AZ has some parental review provisions. ESA provides exit option. No comprehensive transparency statute. Average.
AZ DOE; NSBA
0
Social media — minor protections
No specific state social media minor protection legislation. Reliance on federal COPPA baseline.
NCSL tracker; AZ legislation
0
Juvenile justice — age-appropriate treatment
AZ juvenile jurisdiction standard. Some transfer provisions. Average juvenile justice framework.
OJJDP; AZ juvenile statutes
0
Child poverty rate and state response
AZ child poverty rate approximately 18-20%, above national average. Rapid population growth creates challenges. $30M medical debt forgiveness helps families.
Census ACS SAIPE; KIDS COUNT
-1
Adoption and permanency — adoptive family support
AZ has subsidized adoption. Standard processes. DCS reform improving permanency pathways.
ACF AFCARS; AZ DCS
0
Homeschool rights and protections
AZ has among most permissive homeschool laws. No notification required beyond basic filing. ESA available to homeschoolers. No testing requirements. Sports access.
HSLDA; AZ statutes
+2
Child sexual abuse material enforcement
AZ ICAC task force active. AG enforcement standard. Border-related exploitation a concern. Adequate levels.
ICAC; NCMEC; AZ AG
+1
School safety — violence prevention and incident response
AZ has standard school safety programs. SRO programs variable. Average investment.
NASRO; AZ school safety
0
Children's mental health services access
AZ children's mental health access below average. Counselor ratios poor. Rural areas severely underserved. Ranked among worst states.
ASCA; SAMHSA profiles
-1
Childhood vaccination — parental choice protections
AZ allows religious and personal belief exemptions for school vaccination. Strong parental choice protections.
NCSL; AZ immunization statutes
+1
Child care affordability and access
AZ child care programs functional. Moderate subsidy levels. Growth creating childcare demand. Average access.
ACF CCDF; AZ DES
0
Education — teacher quality and retention
AZ faces severe teacher shortage. Among lowest teacher pay nationally. High vacancy rates. Emergency certifications widespread. #RedForEd movement reflected crisis.
NCES; NEA; AZ DOE
-2
Child nutrition — food insecurity rate
AZ child food insecurity approximately 18-22%. Above national average. School meal programs functioning but gaps in summer and rural areas.
USDA ERS; Feeding America
-1
Custody and family court — due process in child removal
AZ family court system functional. DCS reform improving due process. Standard protections in place.
AZ family court; ABA
0
Children with disabilities — IDEA compliance
AZ IDEA compliance rated 'Needs Assistance' by OSEP. Standard performance. ESA provides additional options for special needs families.
OSEP determinations; AZ DOE
0

Faithful Discharge of Duties

Gubernatorial oath: 'I will faithfully discharge the duties of the office'; Article IV, Section 4; state constitutional requirements
Score: 5 Range: -123 to 123 Items: 41
Budget balance — structural surplus/deficit
Bipartisan $17.6B FY2025 budget closing $1.4B inherited deficit. Generally balanced through bipartisan negotiation. Minor one-time revenue use.
AZ OSPB; NASBO
+1
State credit rating stability
S&P outlook upgraded to positive during Hobbs tenure. Credit ratings stable. Positive trajectory.
S&P; Moody's; Fitch
+2
Rainy day / budget stabilization fund adequacy
AZ Budget Stabilization Fund adequate. Maintained at reasonable levels through bipartisan deal. Standard reserves.
NASBO; Pew; AZ OSPB
+1
Pension system funding responsibility
ASRS funded ratio approximately 70-75%. Making ARC payments. Stable trajectory. Standard performance.
Pew pension data; ASRS CAFR
+1
State debt burden
AZ per capita debt below national median. Conservative debt management. Growth-funded approach.
Census; Moody's; AZ Treasurer
+1
Government efficiency — state employee headcount per capita
AZ state workforce below national median per capita. Lean government structure. Growth managed without proportional headcount increase.
Census Public Employment; BLS
+1
Inspector General / state auditor independence
AZ Auditor General operates independently. Standard cooperation. AHCCCS $15B contract process found flawed by ALJ — oversight gap identified.
AZ Auditor General; ALGA
0
Ethics violations and personal scandals
Pay-to-play AG investigation (group home CEO/inaugural committee/AHCCCS rate increase). AHCCCS $15B contract flawed. Executive Deputy Director appointments ruled illegal by court. Super Bowl ticket concerns. Multiple ethics issues.
AZ AG investigation; court rulings
-1
Executive order restraint
Hobbs rescinded Ducey immigration EOs on first day — politically motivated. Record 178 vetoes reflect conflict rather than restraint. Some EOs challenged for exceeding authority.
AZ EO database; court rulings
-1
Emergency powers — adherence to statutory limits
No extended emergency powers under Hobbs. Standard usage. No court challenges to emergency actions.
AZ emergency statutes
0
Legislative cooperation — veto override rate
Record 178 vetoes — most in AZ history. Deeply adversarial relationship with Republican legislature. Some overrides. High conflict governance.
AZ Legislature; NCSL
-1
Judicial appointments — qualifications and process integrity
AZ uses merit selection for appellate judges. Hobbs appointments through standard process. No major controversies.
AZ judicial appointments
0
Timely execution of laws — implementation of enacted legislation
Mixed implementation. Record vetoes limit legislation. Signed laws generally implemented on time. Divided government creates implementation challenges.
AZ agency rulemaking
0
Federal fund utilization — grant management
AZ federal fund management standard. AHCCCS contract issues represent management gap. Otherwise average performance.
Federal Audit Clearinghouse; USAspending
0
Public approval as competence indicator
Hobbs approval approximately 38-42%. Won 2022 by narrow margin. Facing 2026 reelection challenge. Below-average approval for governor.
Morning Consult; AZ polls
-1
State IT security and data protection
No major breaches during tenure. Standard cybersecurity framework. Average performance.
NASCIO; AZ state auditor
0
Infrastructure spending — capital budget execution
AZ infrastructure investment driven by growth. ADOT projects advancing. Capital execution adequate for fast-growing state.
ASCE AZ; ADOT
+1
Disaster fund readiness
AZ emergency reserves adequate. Wildfire and heat emergency capacity maintained. Standard disaster readiness.
FEMA; AZ emergency fund
0
Workforce development — unemployment system integrity
AZ unemployment near national average. UI system functional. Standard performance. Growth-driven economy provides jobs.
DOL UI Data; AZ DES
+1
Medicaid program integrity
AHCCCS $15B managed care contract process found flawed by ALJ. Material procurement failure. Otherwise standard Medicaid management.
CMS; AHCCCS; ALJ ruling
-1
Election administration — constitutional compliance
AZ election administration standard. Voter ID required (Prop 200). Paper ballots. Post-2020 reforms ongoing. Maricopa County administration contested.
EAC EAVS; Verified Voting
0
Transparency — state budget accessibility
AZ budget transparency adequate. OSPB provides detailed budget data. Standard online presence.
U.S. PIRG; AZ OSPB
+1
Intergovernmental cooperation — federal compliance balanced with sovereignty
Hobbs rescinded Ducey immigration enforcement EOs but later announced cooperation with Trump enforcement. Mixed signals. AZ retains SB 1070 framework. Not fully non-compliant but weakened enforcement.
Federal compliance; AZ EO records
-1
Gubernatorial succession and continuity planning
LG Kris Mayes serves as AG (no separate LG). Secretary of State next in line. Standard COOP plan. Succession clear.
AZ Constitution; FEMA COOP
+1
Anti-corruption — state procurement integrity
AHCCCS $15B contract process found flawed by ALJ. Pay-to-play investigation. Executive appointments ruled illegal. Multiple procurement/ethics concerns.
AZ procurement; ALJ ruling; AG investigation
-1
Gas price burden — state gas taxes, refinery regulations, cap-and-trade
Signed EO to cut red tape and lower energy costs. Arizona energy costs declined 0.8% while national rose. No gas tax increases.
AZ Governor; Cactus Politics
+1
Energy affordability — residential electricity costs from state policy
Energy costs decreased 0.8% under Hobbs. Proposed Affordability Fund for utility assistance. Below national average inflation.
AZ Governor; Cactus Politics
+1
Energy policy competence — forced mandates without infrastructure readiness
Signed EO to cut red tape on energy. Balanced approach without extreme mandates. Practical policy focused on affordability.
AZ Governor
+1
Property tax burden — effective rate vs national median
Arizona property taxes near national median. Housing costs decreased 0.1%. No dramatic changes.
AZ Governor; OSPB
0
Regulatory cost burden — permits, compliance costs per household/business
Launched ACE Initiative targeting $100M in savings. But record vetoes of business-friendly legislation.
AZ Governor; Arizona Globe
0
Unfunded mandates on municipalities
No significant new unfunded mandates on municipalities.
General research
0
Cost of living trajectory — policy-driven affordability trend
Arizona inflation at 1.4% vs 2.9% national. Housing and energy costs both declined. Affordability focus.
AZ Governor; Cactus Politics
+1
Immigration fiscal burden — taxpayer cost of sanctuary/benefits policies
Vetoed SB 1109 and SB 1164 on immigration enforcement. Judicial Watch sued over state police withholding ICE cooperation.
Judicial Watch; Arizona Capitol Times
-1
Homelessness spending accountability — spending vs measurable outcomes
Vetoed encampment clearing bill. Voters passed Prop 312 override. No outcomes-based spending programs.
KAWC; Just The News
0
Encampment enforcement — response to SCOTUS Grants Pass ruling
Vetoed SB 1024 for encampment clearing. Said bill 'only makes them less visible.' Voters had to force enforcement via Prop 312.
KAWC; Just The News; Arizona Capitol Times
-2
Net domestic migration trend — people leaving vs arriving
Ranked 4th nationally in net domestic migration with +55,505. 97% of growth from migration. Projected 12% growth.
Census Bureau; ABC15; Axios Phoenix
+1
Business exodus — corporate HQ and jobs relocating due to policy
Ranked 8th nationally for private-sector job growth. Strong in-migration driven by business opportunity.
AZ Governor; Census data
+1
DA accountability — governor's power to remove rogue prosecutors
No DA accountability actions.
General research
0
Election infrastructure — ballot harvesting, drop box security, audit transparency
Vetoed HB 2017, HB 2046, HB 2050 on ballot security. Blocked more security than enabled.
American Faith; AZ Governor
-1
Weaponization of state agencies — using AG/regulatory bodies against political opponents
Pay-to-play scandal with Sunshine Residential Homes. AG Mayes investigating but shares reelection PAC with Hobbs (conflict).
Arizona Globe; AZ Family; Governing
-1
Foreign adversary protections — Chinese land, TikTok bans, Confucius Institutes
Initially vetoed Chinese land restriction then proposed stronger version. Ultimately signed BAN Act. Mixed process but acceptable outcome.
AZ CIR; KJZZ; AZ Governor
0
← #39 Wes MooreAll RankingsTate Reeves #41 →
We investigate systems. We assess individuals.

These same forensics — your IQ, real bio age, career fit, and relationships — all quantum-verified.

What does the data say about you? →