Skip to content
Spencer Cox
69.6%
#1 of 50

Spencer Cox

Utah R | 2nd term
2021-01-04Took Office 5 yrs, 5 moIn Office 263Metrics Scored 1150 / 1653Total Points

Section A: Governance

277/300
92%

Section B: State Outcomes

687/975
70%

Section C: Oath Fidelity

+186 (-378 to +378)

Section A — Governance 277/300

9 subsections evaluating executive performance: budget execution, legislative relations, appointments, emergency management, transparency, ethics, program management, federal relations, and constituent service.

On-time budget submission
Budget recommendations submitted on time for all five legislative sessions (2021-2025). • FY2026 proposed budget of $30.7B submitted Dec 2024 • Utah's 45-day annual general session runs Jan-Mar with governor's recommendations due before session opens
UT GOPB Budget Recommendations FY2022-FY2026; UT Constitution Art. VII; Fox13 Dec 2024
3
Budget accuracy — revenue forecast vs actual
Revenue forecasts consistently accurate across five budget cycles. • Utah's tech-driven economy (Silicon Slopes) outperformed projections, producing surpluses each year • FY2026 enacted budget: $30.8B ($12.7B from state funds — General Fund + Income Tax Fund + Uniform School Fund) • GOPB and Legislative Fiscal Analyst forecasts aligned closely
UT GOPB Revenue Data FY2021-FY2026; UT Legislative Fiscal Analyst Revenue Reports; Utah Legislature Budget Summary 2025
3
Rainy day fund management
Rainy Day Fund among highest per capita nationally, hitting record-high balance by FY2025. • 2024 legislation authorized Treasurer to invest 10% of select rainy-day funds in precious metals for diversification • State also maintains Income Tax Fund Budget Reserve and $36.2M State Sovereignty Fund • Among 16 states with rainy day savings still below Pew median of 49 days of general fund spending, but strong absolute reserves
UT State Treasurer Rainy Day Fund Reports; Pew Charitable Trusts State Reserves 2024-2025; UT Legislature Budget Reserve Act
3
State credit rating trajectory
Utah holds AAA/Aaa from all three agencies — never rated below AAA. • S&P since 1965, Moody's since 1973, Fitch since 1992 • Moody's reaffirmed Aaa in June 2025 citing 'robustly expanding economy, formidable budget reserves, minimal leverage, and exemplary fiscal governance' • Only 14 states hold Aaa from all three • Low borrowing costs save taxpayers millions on infrastructure bonds
Moody's Aaa Reaffirmation June 2025; S&P Global Ratings — Utah; Fitch AAA; UT State Treasurer Credit Rating History
3
Pension funding ratio trajectory
URS aggregate funded ratio rose to 92.1% (Jan 2024 actuarial valuation), up from 91.1% prior year — among most well-funded statewide pension plans nationally. • Funded status at 94.4% as of Dec 31, 2023 • Fund net position: $47.9B as of Dec 2024 • 9.2% investment return in 2024 generated $970M above expected assets • Tier 2 hybrid defined contribution plan (enacted 2011) limits future unfunded liability growth
URS Actuarial Valuation Jan 2024; URS Economic Impact Report March 2025; Salt Lake Tribune Feb 2025
3
Debt per capita trajectory
Utah among four states (with NE, TN, SD) reporting less than $1,000 per capita long-term debt at end of 2023 — ranked 49th nationally (second-lowest). • Total GO debt: $1.2B as of Nov 2024 after $366.8M principal reduction • Debt at 14.4% of Constitutional Debt Limit — a 35-year low in relative debt levels • Active debt reduction during Cox tenure
UT State Treasurer 2024 Debt Affordability Study; Reason Foundation Gov Finance 2025; Deseret News Nov 2025
3
CAFR/ACFR published on time
ACFR published within statutory deadlines each year of Cox tenure. • FY2023 ACFR completed on schedule by State Treasurer's Office • State Auditor completed FY2024 ACFR audit by Dec 30, 2025 • No late filings during Cox's five years in office
UT State Treasurer ACFR Publications FY2021-FY2024; UT State Auditor ACFR Audit Records
3
Audit findings — material weaknesses
Clean (unmodified) audit opinions on state ACFR throughout Cox tenure. • No material weaknesses identified in statewide financial statement audits 2021-2025 • State Auditor John Dougall (elected, independent) publishes all reports publicly • Financial controls consistently rated among strongest nationally
UT State Auditor Office Annual Reports 2021-2025; auditor.utah.gov
3
Federal grant fund accounting
Federal grants managed within compliance throughout Cox tenure. • Single Audit findings minimal — no material non-compliance with federal program requirements • Utah received $7.3B+ in federal grants (ARPA, IIJA, IRA) with proper accounting • No suspended or disallowed grants • Great Salt Lake received $50M federal Bureau of Reclamation investment (Dec 2024) — largest ever federal commitment to the lake
UT Single Audit Reports FY2021-FY2024; USASpending.gov — Utah; Bureau of Reclamation Dec 2024
3
Anti-fraud controls — federal programs
Relatively modest pandemic UI fraud losses compared to most states. • DWS implemented identity verification early in COVID surge: state driver's license matching, automated cross-matching with government records, new hire data • Small population (3.3M) limited exposure • Fraud detection includes public tips, employer wage file matching, interstate data sharing, and in-person investigations
UT DWS OIG Reports; DOL OIG — Utah; UT DWS Fraud Detection Methods; jobs.utah.gov
2
Tax revenue vs expenditure alignment
Consistent surpluses every fiscal year 2021-2025. • Revenue regularly exceeded expenditures due to conservative budgeting and booming tech economy • Utah ranked #1 in ALEC Rich States Poor States economic outlook for 18 consecutive years (through 2025) • Lawmakers cut taxes five years in a row totaling $1.4B • Income tax constitutionally earmarked for education ensures alignment between revenue source and spending
UT Legislative Fiscal Analyst Budget Reports; ALEC Rich States Poor States 2025; UT GOPB Revenue Data
3
Capital budget execution rate
Major capital projects delivered effectively across tenure. • $1B+ Utah State Correctional Facility completed and opened July 2022 — 1.3M sq ft on 170 acres, replacing aging Draper prison; 2,464 inmates transferred successfully • Former 600-acre Draper prison site ('The Point') broke ground Dec 2024 for 7,400 housing units and 30,000 jobs • FrontRunner 2X double-tracking project at $1.44B progressing
UT Division of Facilities Construction Management; Utah News Dispatch Dec 2024; FrontRunner 2X Project Office
3
Vendor/contractor oversight
No major contractor scandals during Cox's five-year tenure. • Division of Purchasing maintains transparent contract database • Prison relocation ($1B+) and FrontRunner 2X ($1.44B) — largest capital projects — delivered without procurement fraud • State Auditor procurement reviews found no systemic issues
UT Division of Purchasing Records; UT State Auditor Procurement Reviews 2021-2025
3
Federal funding maximization
Captured IIJA infrastructure and ARPA COVID relief funds, but conservative philosophy limits pursuit of some discretionary federal programs. • Secured $50M Bureau of Reclamation investment for Great Salt Lake (Dec 2024) — largest federal commitment to the lake • Medicaid expansion limited to 100% FPL via 1115 waiver (not full 138% FPL as voters approved in Prop 3), leaving ~40,000 in coverage gap
USASpending.gov — Utah; Bureau of Reclamation Great Salt Lake Dec 2024; CMS 1115 Waiver — Utah; KFF Medicaid Brief
2
Program eligibility verification systems
DWS and DHHS eligibility systems functional and well-maintained with low error rates. • SAVE system used for public benefits verification • E-Verify mandated for employers with 150+ employees and all public employers/contractors • Utah's 2.9% unemployment (2024) means low UI caseloads and manageable verification workload
UT DWS Program Reports; UT DHHS Eligibility Data; HB 116 E-Verify Requirements
3
Signature legislation enacted
Multiple landmark laws signed during tenure. • Utah Social Media Regulation Act (SB 152 + HB 311, signed March 2023) — first-in-nation social media protections for minors requiring age verification and parental consent • First-in-nation universal regulatory sandbox (HB 217, 2021) allowing any industry to test innovations • Five consecutive years of tax cuts totaling $1.4B • Housing affordability bills, AI governance framework, education funding increases
SB 152/HB 311 (2023); HB 217 Regulatory Sandbox (2021); UT Legislature Bill Tracking; ALEC Rich States Poor States 2025
3
Veto override rate
One veto overridden in five years: HB 11 transgender sports ban (March 2022). • Senate override: 21-8; House override: 56-18 • Cox vetoed citing only 4 trans athletes among 75,000 students and concern about litigation costs • Legislature later indemnified school districts • Otherwise minimal veto use — works collaboratively with R-supermajority legislature pre-signing
UT Legislature Journal; Governor's Veto Records; HB 11 Override Vote March 25, 2022; CNN/AP
3
Bipartisan bills signed
Utah legislature is heavily R (~80% supermajority in both chambers), limiting bipartisan dynamics. • Cox launched nationally recognized 'Disagree Better' initiative as NGA Chair (July 2023) — hosted bipartisan events with governors in NH, CO, TN, DC • Stanford study confirmed ads had measurable depolarizing impact • Initiative continues as independent nonprofit • But legislative votes remain predominantly party-line due to composition
UT Legislature Vote Records; NGA Disagree Better Initiative July 2023; Stanford Polarization and Social Change Lab Study 2024
2
Special sessions called
Special sessions used judiciously and completed efficiently. • Nov 9, 2021: redistricting (constitutionally required after 2020 Census) — legislature approved House, Senate, and Congressional maps in one day • Dec 2024: redistricting appeal • Additional session to repeal collective bargaining ban • Regular 45-day sessions sufficient for most legislative business
UT Governor's Proclamations; UT Legislature Special Session Records 2021-2024; KSL Nov 2021
3
Executive orders — legal challenges
Conservative executive order use — approximately 6-15 EOs per year (2021-2024), no EOs struck down by courts. • Mainly for emergency declarations (flooding, drought) and administrative matters • Notable EOs: state employee mental health leave (EO 2021-15), military leave increase (EO 2024-02) • Created time-limited task forces via EO (e.g., EO 2023-01 on agency data sharing)
governor.utah.gov/executive-orders; UT Court Records
3
Line-item veto usage
Judicious use of line-item veto authority under UT Constitution Art. VII §8. • No line-item veto overrides during tenure • Used as fiscal discipline tool in a $30.8B budget • Relationship with R-supermajority legislature allows pre-negotiation that reduces need for line-item vetoes • Budget passed on time every session with minimal contention
UT Constitution Art. VII §8; Governor's Budget Actions 2021-2025; UT Legislative Fiscal Analyst
3
Regulatory burden change
Utah consistently ranked among least-regulated states. • Signed HB 217 (March 2021) creating first-in-nation universal regulatory sandbox — any industry can test innovations without full licensing • Built on prior fintech sandbox (2019) and insurance sandbox (2020) • Utah sandbox model replicated by Canada and other states • ALEC ranks Utah #1 for economic outlook 18 consecutive years partly due to low regulatory burden
HB 217 (2021); UT Office of Administrative Rules; Libertas Institute/US News March 2021; IAALS; ALEC 2025
3
Budget negotiation success
Budgets passed on time every session (2021-2025) with zero government shutdowns. • FY2026 budget of $30.8B enacted smoothly during 2025 General Session • R-supermajority in both chambers (Senate ~23-6, House ~59-16) ensures cooperative budget process • Cox's budget proposals closely matched final enacted amounts — FY2026 proposed $30.7B vs enacted $30.8B
UT Legislative Fiscal Analyst Budget Records 2021-2025; UT Legislature 2025 Session Budget Summary
3
Bill signing rate on popular legislation
High alignment with constituent priorities reflected in 56.5% reelection margin (Nov 2024). • Signed first-in-nation social media protections for minors (SB 152/HB 311, 2023) • Signed five consecutive years of tax cuts ($1.4B total) • Signed education funding increases and housing affordability measures • Signed Great Salt Lake emergency funding ($200M+ combined state/private commitment)
UT Legislature Records 2021-2025; Governor's Signing Records
3
Legislative relationship
Strong working relationship with R-supermajority legislature — only one veto overridden in five years (HB 11, 2022). • Some tensions over Amendment D (Aug 2024 special session) where legislature sought constitutional amendment to allow repealing citizen initiatives • A judge voided Amendment D for misleading ballot language; Cox supported legislature's position, straining relationships with initiative advocates • Generally productive partnership
UT Legislature Session Records; Axios SLC Sept 2024 (Amendment D); KSL March 2022 (HB 11)
3
Implementation of voter-approved measures
Mixed record on honoring voter-approved measures. • Legislature modified voter-approved Medicaid expansion (Prop 3, 2018) from 138% FPL to 100% FPL via 1115 waiver — leaving ~40,000 in coverage gap • Legislature attempted Amendment D (Aug 2024) to constitutionally allow repealing citizen initiatives — judge voided it for misleading ballot language • Cox sided with legislature on both issues, angering initiative advocates • Utah Supreme Court ruled legislature overstepped on redistricting initiative (Better Boundaries)
Prop 3 (2018); CMS 1115 Waiver; Better Boundaries v. Legislature; Axios SLC Sept 2024
2
Task force follow-through
Task forces produced concrete results. • Great Salt Lake: appointed Commissioner Brian Steed, secured $200M+ combined funding (state + private), set goal to fill lake by 2034 Olympics • Water conservation task force led to mandatory conservation measures • Housing task force produced legislation but housing remains 'severely unaffordable' (median multiple 5.1) • 'Disagree Better' became standalone nonprofit beyond NGA tenure
UT Governor's Water Task Force; Great Salt Lake Commissioner Reports; NGA Disagree Better; UT Housing Reports
3
Policy reversals under pressure
Brand of civility sometimes at odds with culture-war legislation signed. • Vetoed HB 11 trans sports ban (March 2022) citing only 4 trans athletes among 75,000 students — legislature overrode 56-18/21-8 • Later signed HB 132 (Jan 2023) banning trans procedures for minors • Endorsed Trump despite 'Disagree Better' brand, costing him Democratic approval (dropped 54% to 28% among Dems, April 2023 to April 2025)
HB 11 Veto March 2022; HB 132 (2023); Deseret News April 2025 Approval Poll; KSL Nov 2025
2
Appointee criminal/ethics issues
No appointee criminal or ethics issues documented during five-year tenure. • Appointments made through merit-based processes for agency heads, board members, and judicial nominees • Executive Branch Ethics Commission handles complaints — no substantiated complaints against appointees • Cox acknowledged in Jan 2023 that three Ethics Commission member terms had expired without replacement, called it 'inexcusable,' and appointed replacements immediately
UT Court Records; UT State Auditor; UT Executive Branch Ethics Commission; Salt Lake Tribune Jan 2023
3
Agency head vacancy rate
Agency head positions filled promptly across DHHS, DWS, UDOT, DEQ, DTS, and other departments. • Low vacancy rate in cabinet-level leadership • Cox served as Lt. Governor for 7 years (2013-2020), giving him deep knowledge of state government structure and personnel • Appointed Great Salt Lake Commissioner (Brian Steed) and Colorado River Authority Commissioner as new specialized positions
Governor's Appointment Records 2021-2025; UT Executive Branch Org Chart
3
State employee turnover
Elevated turnover driven by Utah's ultra-competitive private sector — 2.9% unemployment (2024), lowest tier nationally. • Silicon Slopes tech sector (information jobs pay 47.6% above UT average) draws talent from state positions • Cox secured FY2024 pay raises averaging 2.5% plus 3.75% targeted performance increases, but state pay still lags private sector • DHRM exploring PTO consolidation reform
UT DHRM Workforce Reports; BLS LAUS UT 2024; UT Legislature Compensation Bill FY2024; UPEA/DHRM Leave Reform
2
Diversity of appointments
Appointments reflect Utah demographics, constrained by the state's homogeneity (~78% White, ~15% Hispanic, ~2% Black, ~3% Asian). • Limited racial diversity due to population composition and applicant pool • Appointed Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson — first woman in the role elected on same ticket • Some gender diversity in judicial and board appointments
Governor's Appointment Records; Census ACS UT Demographics 2023; Ballotpedia UT Appointees
2
Judicial appointment quality
Judges appointed through merit-based Judicial Nominating Commission process — nominees vetted by commission before governor selects, then confirmed by Senate. • 2024 appointments: Third District Court (Pehrson, Daynes), Fourth District (Kasey Wright), Second District Juvenile (Ryan Evershed) • Also appointed Business and Chancery Court judge • All nominees rated qualified by commission; no controversy over judicial appointments
UT Judicial Nominating Commission Records; governor.utah.gov Appointment Press Releases 2024; UT State Bar
3
State workforce pay competitiveness
State pay lags Utah's booming private sector despite annual adjustments. • FY2024: 2.5% base + 3.75% targeted performance increases • Median home price along Wasatch Front hit $547,700 (Q4 2024) — 'severely unaffordable' ratio of 5.1 • Tech sector average salary 47.6% above state mean • Turnover savings from unfilled positions further constrain compensation
UT DHRM Compensation Reports; BLS OES UT Data; UT Legislature Compensation Bill; UT Housing Affordability Report 2024
2
Whistleblower protection
Utah Protection of Public Employees Act (UT Code §67-21) provides whistleblower protections prohibiting retaliation. • State Auditor operates fraud/waste/abuse hotline • No documented retaliation cases against executive branch whistleblowers during Cox tenure • Protections cover reporting to supervisors, legislators, auditor, or law enforcement
UT Code §67-21; UT State Auditor Fraud Hotline; auditor.utah.gov
3
Inspector General independence
State Auditor John Dougall (elected, independent of governor) operates without interference from Cox administration. • Critical reports published publicly on auditor.utah.gov, including DCFS audit (Jan 2026) that found 'concerning patterns' — published without executive branch pushback • Legislative Audit Subcommittee also independent • No efforts by Cox to undermine audit independence
UT State Auditor Office Records; auditor.utah.gov; Utah News Dispatch Jan 2026 DCFS Audit
3
State employee morale
Generally adequate morale despite retention challenges from ultra-competitive private sector (2.9% unemployment). • Cox issued EO 2021-15 granting state employees leave for mental/emotional health treatment — proactive approach to wellbeing • DHRM conducts employee engagement surveys • Compensation gap (state vs Silicon Slopes tech sector) remains primary morale challenge • Cox proposed state employee pay increases each budget cycle
UT DHRM Employee Engagement Survey; EO 2021-15; UT GOPB Budget Recommendations
2
Nepotism/cronyism
No documented nepotism in state hiring during Cox tenure. • Cox grew up on a farm in Fairview, Sanpete County — no family business conflicts with state government • Executive Branch Ethics Commission monitors for nepotism/cronyism • Background (dairy farmer, small-town mayor, county commissioner, state legislator, Lt. Governor) is public service-focused rather than business-connected
UT Ethics Records; UT Executive Branch Ethics Commission; Cox Biography
3
Senior staff criminal charges
No senior staff charged with crimes during five-year tenure. • Cox-Henderson administration (Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson) maintained clean record • Chief of Staff and senior advisors operated without legal controversy • No indictments, arrests, or criminal investigations involving governor's office personnel
UT Court Records; Federal Court Dockets — Utah
3
Agency performance accountability
State agencies generally performing well, with performance management systems tracking outcomes. • UDOT ranked among best state DOTs nationally • DTS digital government services rated top-tier • DWS managed 2.9% unemployment effectively • One notable exception: DCFS audit (Jan 2026) found 'concerning patterns' in child welfare casework — Cox administration cooperated with audit findings • No catastrophic agency failures
UT Governor's Office Performance Reports; Utah News Dispatch Jan 2026 DCFS Audit; UDOT Rankings
3
Disaster declaration timeliness
Timely disaster declarations throughout tenure, enabling FEMA assistance. • Drought emergencies (multiple years) • Flooding (EO 2021-14, Sept 2021; EO 2024-01, Aug 2024) • Wildfire emergencies • Great Salt Lake ecological emergency • Cox declared drought emergency his first year in office (2021) • Earthquake preparedness maintained for Wasatch Fault Zone (magnitude 7.0+ risk)
UT Division of Emergency Management Records; EO 2021-14; EO 2024-01; UT Geological Survey Wasatch Fault
3
FEMA Public Assistance secured
Secured FEMA Public Assistance for qualifying disasters, though Utah has fewer major federal disaster declarations than coastal/hurricane states. • Flooding events (2021, 2024) received FEMA PA • Unique challenges: drought, wildfire, earthquake risk (Wasatch Front), and Great Salt Lake toxic dust threat • Secured $50M Bureau of Reclamation investment for Great Salt Lake (Dec 2024) — largest federal environmental commitment to the lake
FEMA PA Records — Utah; Bureau of Reclamation Dec 2024 Great Salt Lake Award
2
Emergency reserve adequacy
Combined state reserves hit record highs by FY2025. • Layered reserves: Budget Reserve Account, Income Tax Fund Reserve, and $36.2M State Sovereignty Fund • AAA credit rating from all three agencies reflects reserve adequacy • Treasurer authorized to invest 10% of rainy-day funds in precious metals (2024 legislation) for diversification • Conservative fiscal management ensures reserves grow in surplus years
UT State Treasurer Reports FY2021-FY2025; Pew Charitable Trusts State Reserves 2024
3
Lives lost — preventable from state failure
No preventable mass casualty events from state infrastructure or management failure during five-year tenure. • No bridge collapses, dam failures, or water system contamination despite aging infrastructure and drought stress • Great Salt Lake receding threatens toxic dust exposure (arsenic, heavy metals from exposed lakebed) but no mass casualty event materialized • Cox proactively allocated emergency funding and appointed commissioner to address the lake crisis
UT DEM Records; CDC WONDER — Utah; USGS Great Salt Lake Data; Great Salt Lake Commissioner Reports
3
Post-disaster recovery
No major post-disaster failures during tenure. • 2020 Magna earthquake (M5.7) recovery completed during Cox's early tenure — building inspections and repairs managed effectively • Wildfire recovery across multiple seasons progressed well • Flooding recovery (2021, 2024) handled through emergency declarations and FEMA coordination • Utah's relatively compact population along Wasatch Front aids concentrated recovery efforts
FEMA PA Records; UT DEM After-Action Reports; USGS Magna Earthquake Data
3
Public health emergency response
Balanced COVID approach — no strict lockdowns, encouraged vaccination. • Took office Jan 4, 2021 mid-pandemic • Utah achieved 76% one-dose / 67% fully vaccinated rate • COVID death rate below national average — demographic factors (youngest median age nationally, ~31 years) account for roughly half the advantage per Gardner Policy Institute analysis • Launched mental health initiative via EO 2021-15 (state employee mental health leave) • Economic recovery faster than most states
CDC COVID Data Tracker — Utah; Kem Gardner Policy Institute COVID Demographics; EO 2021-15; BLS Employment Recovery
2
Infrastructure failure prevention
No major infrastructure failures during Cox tenure. • Power grid integrated with Western Interconnection (not isolated like Texas ERCOT) — no grid failure events • Water infrastructure maintained despite severe drought and Great Salt Lake crisis • Municipal water systems functional; no boil-water advisories or contamination events at state level • $10M dam safety allocation in FY2026 budget recommendations
UT Division of Public Utilities; Western Electricity Coordinating Council; GOPB FY2026 Budget Recommendations
3
National Guard deployment appropriateness
National Guard deployed appropriately with no controversial or politically motivated deployments. • Deployed for wildfires and emergency support • Camp Williams (UT National Guard installation) well-maintained • Guard also supported COVID response operations in 2021 • Hill Air Force Base (Ogden) and Dugway Proving Grounds provide strong federal military presence — good state-federal military coordination
UT National Guard Records; Camp Williams Operations; Hill AFB Public Affairs
3
Emergency communication
Cox among most accessible governors nationally for emergency communication. • Active on social media (X/Twitter @GovCox) with direct public engagement during wildfires, drought, and flooding • Held virtual town halls during emergencies (e.g., Dec 2023 housing/Olympics town hall) • Regular press availability • 'Disagree Better' brand built on authentic, candid communication style • Emergency alerts effectively distributed through state systems
UT DEM Communication Records; @GovCox social media; Governor's Office Media Schedule; Deseret News Dec 2023
3
Interagency coordination
Good interagency coordination aided by Utah's relatively compact government structure. • Great Salt Lake response required coordination between DEM, DEQ, Water Resources, Agriculture, and federal agencies (Bureau of Reclamation, USGS) — Cox created Commissioner position to centralize coordination • Colorado River Authority of Utah (created 2021) coordinates interstate water issues from Governor's Office • State-federal coordination effective across Hill AFB, Dugway, and public lands (64.4% federally owned)
UT DEM After-Action Reports; Great Salt Lake Commissioner Office; Colorado River Authority of Utah
3
Pandemic response metrics
Utah COVID death rate below national average, with economic recovery among fastest nationally. • Youngest median age nationally (~31) a key factor in lower death rate • 76% received at least one dose, 67% fully vaccinated — moderate uptake consistent with state demographics • 2.9% unemployment by 2024, GDP growth among highest • No strict lockdowns — balanced approach preserved economic output while maintaining healthcare system capacity
CDC COVID Data Tracker — Utah; BLS LAUS Recovery Data; BEA GDP — Utah; coronavirus-dashboard.utah.gov
2
Disaster preparedness & emergency infrastructure
Comprehensive preparedness approach addressing multiple threats. • Great Salt Lake crisis is existential — shrinking lakebed exposes toxic dust (arsenic, heavy metals) threatening 2.5M Wasatch Front residents; Cox appointed Commissioner Brian Steed, secured $200M+ combined funding, set 2034 fill goal • Wasatch Fault earthquake preparedness maintained (M5.7 Magna quake 2020 tested systems) • Wildfire mitigation ongoing • $10M dam safety in FY2026 budget • Water conservation mandates enacted
UT DEM; Great Salt Lake Commissioner reports
2
FOIA/open records compliance
GRAMA compliance generally adequate but imperfect. • State Records Committee handles appeals — some complaints about response times from media • No major wrongful denials by governor's office • DCFS fatality reviews (2023-2025) found to be 'more heavily redacted than necessary' per Jan 2026 audit, suggesting some transparency limitations in sensitive areas • Overall compliance functional
UT State Records Committee Decisions; Utah News Dispatch Jan 2026 DCFS Audit
2
Governor's schedule availability
Cox among most accessible governors nationally. • Active on X/Twitter (@GovCox) with direct constituent engagement • Governor's schedule publicly available on governor.utah.gov • Virtual town halls (e.g., Dec 2023 housing/Olympics town hall) • 'Disagree Better' brand built on personal accessibility and candor — acknowledged mistakes publicly (e.g., Ethics Commission vacancy lapse) • Former small-town mayor/county commissioner brings grassroots accessibility ethic
governor.utah.gov; @GovCox social media; Deseret News Dec 2023; Salt Lake Tribune March 2023
3
Campaign finance compliance
Campaign finance reports filed on time for 2020 and 2024 gubernatorial campaigns with no violations documented. • Won 2020 with 63.2%, 2024 with 56.5% • Lt. Governor's office (Deidre Henderson) oversees campaign finance compliance • Raised and reported funds transparently in both competitive primary (vs. Phil Lyman, 2024 — 54.4%) and general election campaigns
UT Lt. Governor Campaign Finance Records; 2020 and 2024 UT Election Results; Ballotpedia
3
Financial disclosure
Personal financial disclosures filed as required throughout tenure. • Cox background is modest — grew up on family dairy farm in Fairview (Sanpete County, pop. ~800) • Former VP/General Counsel of CentraCom (family telecom business) • No significant business conflicts • Lives on family farm in Fairview — no Wasatch Front real estate conflicts
UT Financial Disclosure Filings; Cox Biography; Western Governors' Association Bio
3
Open meetings compliance
No major Open and Public Meetings Act violations during Cox tenure. • OPMA requires public notice and access to government deliberations • Legislature's special session on Amendment D (Aug 2024) drew criticism for rushed process but met technical notice requirements • Governor's office has not been cited for OPMA violations
UT Open and Public Meetings Act Records; UT Code §52-4
3
Open data portal
Utah's open data portal (opendata.utah.gov) ranked #1 nationally (tied) by Center for Data Innovation — scored maximum 8/8 points. • Portal hosts datasets from every state agency • DTS (Division of Technology Services) maintains platform • Among top six states nationally alongside Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, New York, and Oklahoma
opendata.utah.gov; Center for Data Innovation State Open Data Rankings; UT DTS
3
Budget transparency
Budget fully transparent through multiple channels. • GOPB recommendations and Legislative Fiscal Analyst reports published publicly • COBI (Comprehensive Online Budget Information) at cobi.utah.gov provides line-item budget data • $30.8B FY2026 budget details available online including $12.7B from state funds • Income tax constitutionally earmarked for education creates built-in transparency for largest revenue source • State Treasurer publishes Debt Affordability Study annually
UT GOPB Budget Publications; cobi.utah.gov; UT State Treasurer 2024 Debt Affordability Study
3
Lobbying disclosure
Standard compliance with lobbying disclosure requirements. • Lobbying disclosure managed through Lt. Governor Henderson's office • Lobbyist registration database publicly searchable • Compliant with UT Code §36-11 (Lobbyist Disclosure and Regulation Act) • No major lobbying scandals during Cox tenure
UT Lt. Governor Lobbyist Registration; UT Code §36-11
3
IG report publication
State Auditor John Dougall publishes all reports promptly on auditor.utah.gov. • Recent reports include DCFS casework audit (Jan 2026), state ACFR audits, procurement reviews, and agency-specific audits • Reports accessible to public without delay • Legislative Audit Subcommittee reviews also published • Cox administration cooperates with audit publication — no attempts to suppress or delay unfavorable findings
auditor.utah.gov; UT State Auditor Recent Audit Reports
3
Legislative audit cooperation
Full cooperation with elected State Auditor and Legislative Audit Subcommittee throughout tenure. • Executive branch agencies provide records and access for audits without obstruction • DCFS audit (Jan 2026) demonstrated system works — auditors found problems, administration accepted findings • No documented instances of executive branch obstruction of legislative oversight • Child Welfare Legislative Oversight Panel (CWLOP) reviews DCFS in closed meetings with full cooperation
UT State Auditor Records; Legislative Audit Subcommittee; CWLOP Records
3
Press conference accessibility
Cox rated among most accessible governors nationally for media. • Regular press conferences, virtual town halls, direct social media engagement on @GovCox • Hosted NPR interview (July 2023), Harvard Kennedy School event, BYU/Wheatley Institute forum (Feb 2024) • 'Disagree Better' initiative required constant media engagement across national platforms • No documented refusal of press access or media avoidance • Candid style includes publicly acknowledging mistakes
Governor's Office Media Schedule; NPR July 2023; Harvard Kennedy School; Press Gallery Reports
3
State contract transparency
No major transparency issues with state procurement contracts. • Contracts publicly available through Division of Purchasing online database • Largest contracts during tenure ($1B+ prison, $1.44B FrontRunner 2X) managed through standard procurement processes without secrecy allegations • State Auditor conducts periodic procurement reviews — no systemic transparency failures found • COBI budget system provides spending transparency
UT Division of Purchasing Contract Database; cobi.utah.gov; UT State Auditor Procurement Reviews
3
Court order compliance
Complied with court orders throughout tenure — no defiance of judicial authority. • When federal judge issued preliminary injunction against Social Media Regulation Act (Sept 2024, Judge Shelby), state complied and pursued legislative revision rather than defiance • Supported legislature's appeal of redistricting ruling through proper legal channels (special session Dec 2024) • US Supreme Court rejected Utah public lands case (Jan 2025) — state accepted ruling
UT Court Records; NetChoice v. Utah Sept 2024; Utah v. US (public lands) Jan 2025
3
Personal criminal charges
No criminal charges, investigations, or allegations during five-year tenure. • JD from Washington and Lee Law School — legal training reflects awareness of ethical boundaries • Rose through local government (city council, mayor, county commissioner, state rep, Lt. Governor) over 16 years without legal issues
UT Court Records; Federal Court Dockets; Cox Biography — Ballotpedia
3
Ethics complaints — substantiated
No substantiated ethics complaints against Cox. • Executive Branch Ethics Commission (created 2013) has jurisdiction over Governor, Lt. Governor, AG, Auditor, Treasurer • Cox acknowledged in Jan 2023 that he had allowed three commission member terms to expire without replacement — called it 'inexcusable' and immediately appointed new members • Transparency about his own oversight lapse demonstrates accountability
UT Executive Branch Ethics Commission Records; Salt Lake Tribune Jan 2023
3
Gift/travel disclosure
Gift and travel disclosures filed as required with no controversies. • NGA Chair role (2023-2024) required national travel for 'Disagree Better' events in NH, CO, TN, DC — all properly disclosed • Modest personal background (Fairview dairy farm) means limited exposure to gift/travel controversies
UT Financial Disclosure Records; NGA Chair Travel Records 2023-2024
3
Conflict of interest
No documented conflicts of interest during tenure. • Financial interests are limited — family dairy farm in rural Fairview (Sanpete County) and former involvement in CentraCom (family telecom company) • No real estate holdings along booming Wasatch Front where most state policy impacts occur • No stock conflicts with Silicon Slopes tech sector
UT Ethics Records; UT Financial Disclosure Filings
3
State resources for political purposes
No documented misuse of state resources for political purposes. • Cox lives on his family farm in Fairview (~130 miles from Salt Lake City) rather than full-time at Kearns Mansion (governor's residence) • No allegations of using state employees, vehicles, or facilities for campaign activities during 2024 reelection • State Auditor monitoring found no issues
UT Ethics Records; UT State Auditor Oversight
3
Truthfulness in official statements
No documented misleading official statements — nationally recognized for candid, honest communication. • Acknowledged Ethics Commission vacancy lapse as 'inexcusable' and fixed it immediately (Jan 2023) • Wrote public letter explaining HB 11 veto rationale with specific data (4 trans athletes among 75,000 students) • 'Disagree Better' brand built on authentic communication • Stanford study confirmed his public messaging had genuine depolarizing impact
Governor's Public Statements; HB 11 Veto Letter March 2022; Stanford Polarization Study 2024; Salt Lake Tribune Jan 2023
3
Protection of ethics infrastructure
Supported Executive Branch Ethics Commission — no efforts to undermine oversight. • When criticized for allowing three commission member terms to expire (Jan 2023), Cox immediately appointed replacements rather than defending the lapse • Commission budget maintained • State Auditor independence preserved — no interference with critical DCFS audit (Jan 2026) or other unfavorable reports
UT Executive Branch Ethics Commission Budget Records; Salt Lake Tribune Jan 2023; auditor.utah.gov
3
Emoluments/self-dealing
No documented self-dealing or emoluments issues. • Grew up on family dairy farm in Fairview, Sanpete County • Former VP/General Counsel of CentraCom (family telecom business — rural broadband) • No ownership in real estate development, tech companies, or industries directly affected by state policy • Rural agricultural background limits self-dealing exposure • Wife Abby and four children live on family farm
UT Financial Disclosure Records; Cox Biography — WGA; Deseret News Jan 2021 Profile
3
Campaign donor to state contract pipeline
No documented donor-to-contract pipeline during five-year tenure. • Campaign donors not shown to have received preferential state contract treatment • Division of Purchasing maintains competitive bidding processes • $1B+ prison project and $1.44B FrontRunner 2X awarded through standard procurement — no allegations of donor favoritism • State Auditor procurement reviews found no systemic issues linking donations to contracts
UT Campaign Finance Records; UT Division of Purchasing; UT State Auditor Procurement Reviews
3
Foreign influence
No foreign influence concerns. • No FARA registrations linked to Cox or administration officials • International engagement focused on trade missions and 2034 Winter Olympics bid (Salt Lake City selected) — legitimate international activity • No foreign government donations to campaigns or foundations • Rural background and domestic policy focus limit foreign entanglement exposure
DOJ FARA Database; UT International Trade Reports; SLC 2034 Olympics
3
Sexual harassment claims
No sexual harassment claims against governor's office during five-year tenure. • Cox-Henderson administration (first governor-Lt. Governor team with a woman in the pair elected on same ticket) has maintained professional workplace • No complaints filed through DHRM or Executive Branch Ethics Commission channels • No media allegations or legal actions
UT DHRM Records; UT Executive Branch Ethics Commission
3
Records preservation
No documented records preservation violations. • State Archives maintains official records per GRAMA requirements • Governor's executive orders, proclamations, and official correspondence properly archived • No allegations of records destruction, deletion of emails, or use of private communication channels to evade records laws • DCFS fatality review redaction concerns (Jan 2026 audit) relate to DCFS practice, not governor's office records
UT State Archives; GRAMA Records; UT State Auditor
3
Revolving door
No major revolving door concerns during Cox tenure. • No senior officials documented moving directly to lobbying or industry positions that create conflicts • Utah's relatively small government and dominant LDS institutional culture limits revolving door dynamics compared to larger states • No documented cases of former Cox appointees lobbying their former agencies within restricted periods
UT Ethics Records; UT Lt. Governor Lobbyist Registration Database
3
Fraud losses in state programs
Minimal fraud losses in state programs. • DWS implemented multi-layered fraud detection: public tips, state/national new hire cross-matching, employer wage files, automated government record checks, in-person investigations, and interstate data sharing • Small population (3.4M) limits exposure • UI fraud losses modest relative to national pandemic experience • No major fraud scandals in Medicaid, SNAP, or other state-administered programs
UT DWS OIG Reports; DOL OIG — Utah; jobs.utah.gov/ui/fraud
3
Program integrity — eligibility verification
Eligibility verification systems functional with low error rates in federal programs. • SAVE system used for public benefits verification • E-Verify mandated for employers with 150+ employees and all public employers/contractors per HB 116 (2011) • Medicaid eligibility managed through 1115 waiver framework covering adults to 100% FPL • DWS identity verification includes driver's license matching and cross-agency data • CMS compliance maintained
UT DWS Reports; CMS Medicaid Reviews — Utah; HB 116 E-Verify; SAVE System
3
IT system modernization
Utah's Division of Technology Services (DTS) maintains modern IT infrastructure. • Open data portal ranked #1 nationally (tied) by Center for Data Innovation • Silicon Slopes tech ecosystem provides deep talent pool (21,000+ new Utah County residents in 2024, 5% tech sector growth YoY) • AI governance framework legislation signed • Cox created data-sharing task force via EO 2023-01 to improve cross-agency IT coordination
UT DTS Technology Reports; Center for Data Innovation Rankings; EO 2023-01; CNBC Silicon Slopes Dec 2024
3
Permit processing timeliness
Business permits processed quickly — Utah ranked #1 for economic outlook 18 consecutive years (ALEC Rich States Poor States). • First-in-nation universal regulatory sandbox (HB 217, 2021) allows any industry to test innovations without full licensing • Right-to-work state, no estate/inheritance tax, low workers' comp costs ($0.86) • Department of Commerce processes efficient • Silicon Slopes generated 21,000+ new Utah County residents in 2024 alone
UT Department of Commerce; ALEC Rich States Poor States 2025; HB 217 (2021); Census Business Dynamics
3
Child welfare system
DCFS faces significant challenges exposed by Jan 2026 legislative audit. • 'Concerning patterns in a significant number of cases' — slow investigations, weak supervisor oversight • Fatality reviews (2023-2025) omitted policy violations and were over-redacted • In 71% of 2024 foster care placements, no accusation of physical or sexual abuse — 44% of removals involved housing/homelessness • System functional but reforms needed • Cox administration accepted audit findings
UT State Auditor DCFS Audit Jan 2026; Utah News Dispatch Jan 2026; ACF CFSR Results — Utah; UT DCFS Annual Report FY2023
2
Medicaid program management
Partial Medicaid expansion falls short of what voters authorized. • Implemented via 1115 waiver covering adults 0-100% FPL — modified from voter-approved Prop 3 (2018) that authorized full expansion to 138% FPL • Coverage gap of ~40,000 people between 100-138% FPL remains • Approximately 70,000-90,000 covered under waiver (vs ~130,000 under full expansion) • CMS approved waiver renewed July 2024
CMS 1115 Waiver — Utah (renewed July 2024); KFF Medicaid Brief; UT DHHS Medicaid Data; Prop 3 (2018)
2
Environmental program
Wasatch Front air quality remains challenging, but recent milestone achieved. • SLC ranked 9th-worst nationally for ozone and 19th-worst for short-term particle pollution (2024, American Lung Assoc) • Average 18 high-PM2.5 days per year during winter inversions (ammonium nitrate = 70% of PM mass) • EPA removed Wasatch Front from 'serious' PM2.5 nonattainment list (Nov 2025) — a milestone • Great Salt Lake shrinkage threatens new toxic dust (arsenic, heavy metals) • Cox allocated $200M+ and appointed commissioner for lake crisis
EPA AQI Data; American Lung Assoc 2024 Report; UT DEQ; Salt Lake Tribune Nov 2025; USGS Great Salt Lake Data
2
Transportation project delivery
UDOT project delivery ranked among best state DOTs nationally. • I-15 expansion through Davis County advancing • FrontRunner 2X double-tracking project ($1.44B) — 11 new double-track sections will bring system to 58% double-tracked, increasing frequency to every 15 min peak/30 min off-peak; revenue service target 2030 • The Point development (former Draper prison, 600 acres) broke ground Dec 2024 for 15M sq ft of development • UDOT manages $30B+ road network effectively
UDOT Project Delivery Reports; FrontRunner 2X Project Office; FHWA Data — Utah; The Point Groundbreaking Dec 2024
3
Unemployment insurance system
DWS UI system performed well throughout tenure. • Utah's 2.9% unemployment (2024) — among lowest nationally — means naturally low UI claim volume • System modernized with identity verification, automated cross-matching, and online filing • Fraud detection multi-layered (public tips, employer wage files, interstate data sharing) • Post-COVID claims volume returned to pre-pandemic levels quickly due to rapid economic recovery
UT DWS UI Performance Data; DOL UI Weekly Claims — Utah; BLS LAUS UT 2024
3
Veterans services
Adequate veterans services backed by strong federal military presence. • Hill Air Force Base (Ogden, 27,000+ employees — UT's largest employer), Dugway Proving Grounds, Tooele Army Depot, Camp Williams (National Guard) • Cox signed EO 2024-02 increasing military leave for state employees • Federal lands (64.4% of UT) include major DOD installations • Good state-federal military coordination
UT DVMA Annual Reports; VA State Data — Utah; EO 2024-02; Hill AFB Economic Impact; Gardner Policy Institute
3
Housing program effectiveness
Severe housing affordability crisis — Utah's clearest governance challenge. • Median single-family home price hit $547,700 (Q4 2024) — ranked 9th most expensive nationally • Median multiple ratio: 5.1 ('severely unaffordable'); Washington and Salt Lake counties above 5.1 • Homes under $300K scarce along Wasatch Front • Rents increased avg 6%+ annually 2014-2024 • Cox proposed $50M for homeless services in FY2026 budget • The Point development (7,400 units) is long-term supply response • Housing crisis driving outmigration
Kem Gardner Policy Institute Housing Report 2024; Census ACS UT Housing; HUD PIT Count — Utah; GOPB FY2026 Budget
1
Corrections system
New facility delivered, but reform work ongoing. • Utah State Correctional Facility completed and opened July 2022 — $1B+, 1.3M sq ft on 170 acres near SLC airport; 2,464 inmates transferred from aging Draper prison • Former 600-acre Draper site repurposed as 'The Point' development (broke ground Dec 2024) • Recidivism rates moderate • New facility designed for modern rehabilitation programming • Cost overruns were manageable
UT DOC Reports; Utah State Correctional Facility Wikipedia; Utah News Dispatch Dec 2024; BJS NPS — Utah
2
Federal funding captured
Captured IIJA, ARPA, and IRA investments, but conservative philosophy limits pursuit of discretionary programs. • Secured $50M Bureau of Reclamation investment for Great Salt Lake (Dec 2024) — largest federal environmental investment in the lake • FrontRunner 2X seeking Full Funding Grant Agreement from FTA ($1.44B project) • Medicaid limited to 100% FPL waiver vs 138% full expansion • Federal funding maximized for transportation but not for social programs
USASpending.gov — Utah; Bureau of Reclamation Dec 2024; FTA FrontRunner 2X Profile; Census Federal Aid
2
Federal corrective action plans
Minimal federal corrective actions required during Cox tenure. • Single Audit findings minimal — no material non-compliance with federal program requirements • CMS renewed Utah's 1115 Medicaid waiver (July 2024) without major corrective actions • Federal highway funding (FHWA) maintained without compliance issues • No suspended or disallowed federal grants • Great Salt Lake received increased federal attention and funding
Federal Agency Reviews — Utah; CMS 1115 Waiver Renewal July 2024; FHWA Compliance — Utah
3
Interstate cooperation
Elected NGA Chair (July 2023) — first UT governor as NGA Chair since Jon Huntsman. • Led national 'Disagree Better' initiative with bipartisan events in NH, CO, TN, DC • Active in Western Governors' Association • Colorado River Authority of Utah (created 2021) coordinates with 6 other basin states — Utah receives 23% of Upper Basin water • Upper Colorado River Commission approved tribal MOU (March 2024) • Good interstate relationships on water, public lands (64.4% federally owned), and wildfire management
NGA Chair 2023-2024; Western Governors' Association; Upper Colorado River Commission MOU March 2024; Colorado River Authority of Utah
3
Local government relations
Generally good local government relations, shaped by Cox's own local government experience (Fairview city councilman, mayor, Sanpete County commissioner). • 29 counties endorsed Cox's 2024 reelection • Some tensions over housing policy (state preemption of local zoning for housing density) • Great Salt Lake water allocation affects agricultural communities • Legislature's Amendment D controversy created friction with cities supporting citizen initiatives
UT Association of Counties; UT League of Cities and Towns; Deseret News April 2024 County Endorsements
2
Federal litigation costs
Litigation costs manageable but public lands dispute was expensive and unsuccessful. • Utah sued to challenge federal retention of 18.5M acres of 'unappropriated' land (64.4% of state is federally owned, second-highest nationally) — US Supreme Court rejected case Jan 2025 without explanation • Social media law (SB 152) enjoined by federal judge (Sept 2024, NetChoice v. Utah) • Redistricting litigation ongoing
UT AG Litigation Reports; Utah v. US (public lands) Jan 2025; NetChoice v. Utah Sept 2024; Federal Court Dockets
2
Constituent inquiry response
Constituent engagement is a core value, rooted in grassroots background. • Former small-town mayor (Fairview, pop. ~800) and county commissioner brings grassroots accessibility • Active on @GovCox (X/Twitter) with direct constituent responses • Governor's office maintains constituent services team • Virtual town halls streamed from Kearns Mansion • 'Disagree Better' ethos extends to constituent interactions — willing to engage with critics publicly
Governor's Office Constituent Services; @GovCox social media; Deseret News Dec 2023 Town Hall
3
Town halls held
Cox rated among most accessible governors nationally for public engagement. • Regular town halls including virtual events (Dec 2023 housing/Olympics town hall) and in-person community meetings across Utah • NGA 'Disagree Better' tour: Manchester NH (Sept 2023), Denver CO (Nov 2023), Washington DC (Feb 2024, featuring Supreme Court Justices Sotomayor and Barrett), Nashville TN (May 2024)
Governor's Office Schedule; NGA Disagree Better Events 2023-2024; Deseret News Feb 2024
3
Constituent satisfaction
ABC News ranked Cox second-highest governor approval nationally (62%) in April 2024, though polarization has eroded bipartisan appeal. • Approval settled to 52% by 2025 • Republican approval stable at 66-68% • Democratic approval dropped sharply from 54% (April 2023) to 28% (April 2025) — 26-point decline as culture-war legislation and Trump endorsement eroded cross-party appeal • Still net-positive overall
ABC News April 2024 Governor Approval; Deseret News April 2025 Poll; KSL Nov 2025
3
ADA compliance
Standard ADA compliance across state facilities and digital services. • New Utah State Correctional Facility (opened July 2022) built to modern ADA standards • State websites meet accessibility requirements • Open data portal (opendata.utah.gov) accessible • No DOJ ADA complaints or enforcement actions during Cox tenure
UT DHHS ADA Reports; DOJ ADA Reviews; UT State Correctional Facility Specs
3
Electoral accountability
Electoral mandate confirmed twice — promised to serve only two terms (through 2028). • Won 2020 with 63.2% • Won 2024 reelection: Republican primary 54.4% vs Phil Lyman (Trump-backed), then general election 56.5% vs Democrat Brian King (31%), with Lyman write-in at 7.6% • Won despite Lyman's fraud/corruption allegations and write-in challenge — demonstrating broad constituent support across competitive contests
UT Lt. Governor Election Results 2020; 2024 Primary/General Results; Ballotpedia; Axios SLC Nov 2024
3

Section B — State Outcomes 687/975

13 categories measuring real-world outcomes: economic performance, population trends, fiscal health, public safety, education, healthcare, infrastructure, cost of living, transparency, controversy, historical context, constituent satisfaction, and immigration compliance.

Economic performance excellent by virtually all measures. • BEA SAGDP: UT GDP growth among fastest nationally • BLS LAUS: unemployment 2.9% (2024) — consistently among lowest in nation • Tech sector ('Silicon Slopes') booming • BLS CES: strong job growth • Census ACS: median household income $86,833 (well above national) • Low poverty rate
UT population: 3,506,838 (Jul 2024), up 50,392 from 2023 (1.5% growth); by Jul 2025: 3,551,150 (1.3% growth, slowing). • Natural change (births minus deaths) generated 57% of 2025 growth vs 43% from net migration — a reversal from prior years when migration dominated • Youngest median age in nation (~31) • Utah County alone added 21,853 residents (43% of state growth, 2024); Tooele County fastest growth rate (3.1%) • 45 of 72 counties saw more deaths than births but migration offset losses in all but 16 • Birth rate highest nationally • Growing tax base but growth straining housing and infrastructure
Among best-managed state budgets nationally. • AAA credit from all three agencies • $1.2B Rainy Day Fund • Consistent surpluses • Pension 95% funded (among best) • Low debt per capita • Conservative fiscal management • Tax reform maintaining income and sales tax balance
Overall crime decreased 11.4% from 2023 to 2024. • FBI UCR/BCI 2024: UT violent crime rate 230/100K — 36.1% below national average (ranked 30th-safest) • Property crime: 1,409/100K (20% below national) • Violent crime in 2023 was 232/100K, now lower than pre-pandemic 2019 rate of 237 • 2024 breakdown: aggravated assaults 61.7%, rapes 25.3%, robberies 11.9%, murders 1.1% • Property crime down 14% (2022-2023) • I-15 corridor monitored for human trafficking • Opioid/fentanyl crisis present but overdose death rate below national average • Some domestic violence rate concerns persist
Reasonable outcomes despite lowest-in-nation per-pupil spending. • NAEP 2022: UT scores near or slightly above national average • Per-pupil spending ~$9,500 (lowest nationally) due to large youth population • HS graduation ~88% (above national) • University system strong (U of U, BYU, USU) • Chronic underfunding concern
Mixed healthcare picture. • Census ACS: uninsured 8.4% (improving with partial Medicaid expansion) • CDC: life expectancy ~79.0 (near national average) • Low obesity rate • Mental health crisis significant — highest youth suicide rate trends • Rural healthcare access challenges
Infrastructure above national average but major environmental threats. • ASCE: UT infrastructure grade above national average • UDOT well-managed; roads in good condition • Transit system (UTA) functional • Broadband expansion progressing • Great Salt Lake crisis (ecological infrastructure) and water infrastructure under severe drought stress
Previously affordable state becoming unaffordable for middle class. • BEA RPP: 101-104 (slightly above national) • Housing: median home ~$510K (2024) — up significantly • Salt Lake City/Provo metros increasingly expensive • Rent increases outpacing wages • Property tax moderate
Mixed transparency record — strong budget transparency but GRAMA weakened. • Cox signed several bills weakening GRAMA in 2025: State Records Committee (7-member volunteer panel, 98% court-upheld rulings) replaced with administrative law judge; HB 69 increased costs for record appeal • Society of Professional Journalists gave UT Legislature 2025 'Black Hole Award' for undermining transparency • GRAMA backlog averaged 156 days (vs 73-day statutory requirement) • 2024 Legislature cast 'shadow' over transparency with additional GRAMA restrictions (Salt Lake Tribune) • Budget transparency excellent via GOPB; open data portal functional; governor personally accessible; press access generally good
Among least controversial governors nationally. • Transgender sports ban veto (then override) was notable • Legislature's attempt to curtail citizen initiative power controversial • Great Salt Lake crisis management questioned • Amendment A controversy • 'Disagree Better' initiative praised
Among strongest fiscal governors in UT history, with legacy still developing. • Cox is Utah's 18th governor, reelected in 2024 after defeating Trump-backed primary challenger Phil Lyman • Cut $1.1B in taxes while maintaining AAA credit and 95% pension funding — fiscal performance among best in state history • Predecessor Gary Herbert (2009-2021, also R) maintained similar fiscal trajectory; Cox continued strong economic development • Served as 2023-24 NGA Chairman — first UT governor as NGA Chair since Jon Huntsman • 'Disagree Better' initiative became standalone nonprofit • Signed Utah Social Media Regulation Act — national model • Great Salt Lake ecological crisis ($200M+ combined funding, commissioner appointed) is the defining environmental challenge • Housing affordability deterioration ($510K median, 2024) a growing concern vs Herbert era
Strong constituent support with rare bipartisan appeal. • Morning Consult: 55-65% approval — among highest nationally • Won 2020 with 63.2% • 'Disagree Better' initiative reflects popular desire for civil governance • Won 2024 primary against Trump-backed challenger
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Section C — Oath Fidelity +186 (-378 to +378)

126 items scored -3 to +3 measuring fidelity to constitutional oath. Grounded in Supreme Court precedent and constitutional text.

+3Exemplary +2Strong +1Adequate 0Neutral -1Concerning -2Failing -3Hostile

Protection of Life

Declaration of Independence; 5th/14th Amendments
Score: 36 Range: -93 to 93 Items: 31
Violent crime rate trend
UT violent crime rate 230/100K (2024), down from 237/100K pre-pandemic (2019). Overall crime down 11.4% from 2023-2024. Steady declining trend during Cox tenure.
FBI UCR/BCI 2024; UT DPS Crime Reports
+2
Homicide rate relative to national average
UT homicide rate ~2.3/100K vs national ~6.3/100K — approximately 63% below national average.
FBI UCR 2023; CDC WONDER
+2
Homicide clearance rate
UT homicide clearance rate estimated 55-60%, near or slightly above national average of ~50%.
FBI UCR Supplementary Homicide Reports; UT DPS
+1
Law enforcement staffing adequacy
UT law enforcement staffing approximately 2.1-2.3 per 1,000 residents. Some rural shortages but generally adequate.
FBI LEOKA; BJS CSLLEA
+1
Drug overdose death rate trend
UT overdose death rate below national average (~22/100K vs ~33 national) but has been relatively stable, not declining significantly.
CDC WONDER; NCHS provisional data
+1
Emergency management preparedness
UT Division of Emergency Management well-organized. EMAP accreditation maintained. Effective wildfire and earthquake preparedness. No major preparedness failures documented.
FEMA SPR; UT DEM
+2
Preventable mass-casualty event response
No major mass-casualty events during tenure. Proactive earthquake preparedness improvements for Wasatch Front. Wildfire response adequate.
FEMA after-action reports; UT DEM
+2
Infrastructure safety — bridge and road conditions
UDOT well-managed; structurally deficient bridges below 5%. Roads in good condition. ASCE grade above national average. Infrastructure investment ongoing.
FHWA NBI; ASCE UT report card
+2
Water and dam safety compliance
Great Salt Lake crisis is an ecological emergency — lake level dropped to historic lows threatening dust/arsenic exposure. Cox invested $200M+ and appointed commissioner but crisis remains severe. Dam safety adequate.
EPA SDWIS; UT Division of Water Resources
0
Healthcare access — uninsured rate
UT uninsured rate ~8.4% — at the boundary of the 8-10% neutral range. Partial Medicaid expansion via 1115 waiver improved access.
Census ACS; KFF State Health Facts
0
Maternal mortality rate
UT maternal mortality rate approximately 15-17/100K live births — below national average of ~23/100K and within the 12-18 strong range.
CDC WONDER; NCHS
+2
Infant mortality rate
UT infant mortality rate ~4.5/1,000 live births — well below national average of ~5.6 and within the 4.0-5.0 strong range.
CDC WONDER; NCHS
+2
Self-defense rights — Castle Doctrine / Stand Your Ground
Utah has Castle Doctrine + Stand Your Ground + no duty to retreat + civil immunity for lawful self-defense (UT Code §76-2-402).
UT Code §76-2-402; NRA-ILA
+3
Death penalty procedural safeguards
Utah retains death penalty with mandatory appellate review and post-conviction DNA access. Firing squad as backup method is unusual but procedurally sound. Limited use (last execution 2010).
DPIC; UT Code §77-18a
+1
Suicide prevention program funding and outcomes
Utah has funded suicide prevention plan and 988 integration, but suicide rate remains significantly above national average (~22/100K vs ~14 national). Youth suicide rates particularly alarming.
CDC WISQARS; AFSP UT fact sheet
-1
911/emergency response time adequacy
Urban areas (Wasatch Front) meet NFPA standards in most jurisdictions. Rural response times longer but adequate given geography.
NFPA; UT EMS registry
+1
Opioid/fentanyl interdiction and treatment funding
Utah has funded opioid strategy with PDMP operational. Overdose deaths below national average but not declining dramatically. I-80/I-15 corridor interdiction ongoing.
SAMHSA; CDC WONDER; UT DOPL PDMP
+1
Veteran suicide and healthcare access
Utah has veteran services programs and strong VA facilities (Salt Lake VA). Some state-funded programs supplement federal VA. Veteran suicide rate concerning given overall high state suicide rate.
VA SAIL; HUD PIT count
+1
Food safety and foodborne illness enforcement
UT Department of Agriculture and Food maintains adequate food safety program. No major outbreaks linked to inspection failures.
FDA Conformance Standards; UT DAF
+1
Workplace fatality rate
UT workplace fatality rate approximately 3.5-4.5/100K FTE — near national average. Construction and mining sectors contribute to elevated rates.
BLS CFOI
+1
Domestic violence fatality rate and funding
Utah has domestic violence fatality review board and funded shelters. DV rates remain a concern but programs are in place and funded.
NNEDV; UT DCFS
+1
Correctional facility death rate and conditions
UT DOC in-custody death rate near national average. No active DOJ CRIPA investigations. New state prison facility opened to improve conditions.
BJS Mortality in Prisons; UT DOC
+1
Pollution-related mortality and environmental health
Salt Lake City area has significant air quality nonattainment (PM2.5 winter inversions). Great Salt Lake crisis threatens toxic dust exposure. Moderate environmental health concerns.
EPA Green Book; UT DEQ
0
Pedestrian and traffic fatality rate
UT traffic fatality rate approximately 1.1/100M VMT — slightly above national average but within adequate range. Zero Fatalities campaign active.
NHTSA FARS; UT DOT
+1
Sanctity of life legislative framework
Signed 18-week ban (SB 174) and trigger law (HB 136) banning abortion from conception. Trigger law blocked by court but 18-week ban enforceable. Clinic safety regulations maintained. Informed consent required.
Guttmacher; UT Code; Dobbs
+2
Homeless mortality — exposure deaths, overdoses in encampments, violence
Proposed 1,300-bed homeless campus including civil commitment beds. $81.2M for services.
governor.utah.gov; UT News Dispatch
+1
Population loss impact on services — EMS/hospital closures, tax base erosion
UT fastest-growing state by percentage. 2.8% unemployment. No service erosion.
Deseret News; edcutah.org
+2
Police staffing/funding — governor's direct actions on law enforcement
Signed $100M law enforcement grant program. Ordered LEO coordination with federal immigration partners.
governor.utah.gov; Deseret News
+1
Criminal recidivism from early release — parole/clemency, no-cash-bail
Launched criminal justice task force. Concerned about overcriminalization. Mixed approach.
Deseret News 2025-03-28
0
Prison/shelter housing — biological males in women's facilities
Vetoed transgender athlete ban HB 11 in 2022. Legislature overrode. Has since signed surgery restrictions. Mixed.
Washington Post; governor.utah.gov
0
Mental health crisis system — involuntary commitment reform, crisis intervention
Proposed homeless campus with civil commitment beds. Signed mental health bills. $81.2M for services.
mindsitenews.org; governor.utah.gov
+2

Constitutional Rights

Bill of Rights (I-X); 14th Amendment
Score: 46 Range: -87 to 87 Items: 29
Second Amendment — right to carry status
Utah enacted constitutional/permitless carry (HB 60, Feb 2021, signed by Cox). Strong preemption. Civil liability protections for lawful carriers.
HB 60 (2021); UT Code §76-10-523
+3
Second Amendment — semi-automatic rifle restrictions
No restrictions beyond federal law. Utah has 2A sanctuary/protection provisions. No assault weapons ban.
UT Code; NRA-ILA
+3
Second Amendment — magazine capacity restrictions
No magazine capacity restrictions. Preemption of local magazine laws.
UT Code; NRA-ILA
+3
Second Amendment — Red Flag / ERPO due process protections
Utah has no ERPO/red flag law. Relies on existing due process mechanisms (involuntary commitment, criminal charges). Strong due process for all firearm proceedings.
UT Code; ERPO state tracker
+3
First Amendment — campus free speech protections
Utah enacted campus free speech statute (HB 261, 2019) banning free speech zones and protecting invited speakers at public universities.
HB 261 (2019); FIRE rankings
+2
First Amendment — anti-SLAPP protections
Utah has anti-SLAPP statute (UT Code §78B-6-1401 et seq.) with moderate scope covering protected speech.
UT Code §78B-6-1401; Public Participation Project
+1
First Amendment — religious liberty protections
Utah has strong religious liberty protections. While no formal RFRA, the state's constitutional and statutory framework provides robust protection for religious exercise. Strong faith-based organization partnerships. No documented state actions penalizing religious exercise.
UT Constitution Art. I; Becket Fund index
+3
Fourth Amendment — warrant requirements for digital surveillance
Utah passed Electronic Information or Data Privacy Act (HB 57, 2019) requiring warrants for electronic communications data — partial protections enhancing Carpenter standard.
HB 57 (2019); EFF state database
+1
Fourth Amendment — civil asset forfeiture reform
Utah requires criminal conviction for most forfeiture (UT Code §24-4-102). Transparency reporting and elevated burden of proof. Some equitable sharing participation remains.
UT Code §24-4-102; IJ Policing for Profit
+2
Fifth Amendment — eminent domain protections post-Kelo
Utah enacted post-Kelo reform restricting economic development takings (UT Code §78B-6-501 et seq.). Strong statutory protections with narrow public use definition.
UT Code §78B-6-501; Castle Coalition
+2
Due process — regulatory takings and permitting timelines
Utah has statutory permitting timelines and GOPB regulatory review processes. Generally business-friendly regulatory environment with adequate compliance.
UT GOPB; state permitting data
+2
Tenth Amendment — federal overreach resistance
Cox has selectively pushed back on federal overreach (joined some multistate litigation) but also cooperated extensively on federal programs. Mixed posture — 'Disagree Better' approach limits aggressive resistance.
UT AG litigation; gubernatorial EOs
+1
Equal Protection — state contracting nondiscrimination
Utah uses race-neutral contracting and hiring. University admissions SFFA-compliant. Proactive nondiscrimination enforcement.
UT procurement data; USHE admissions
+2
Second Amendment — state preemption of local firearms laws
Utah has state preemption of local firearms laws (UT Code §76-10-500). Enforcement mechanism exists but penalties for noncompliant localities limited.
UT Code §76-10-500; NRA-ILA
+2
First Amendment — government transparency and FOIA compliance
Cox signed multiple bills weakening GRAMA in 2025. SPJ gave UT Legislature 2025 'Black Hole Award.' GRAMA response backlog averaged 156 days vs 73-day statutory requirement. Transparency declining.
SPJ Black Hole Award 2025; Salt Lake Tribune
-1
Sixth Amendment — public defender funding adequacy
Utah has statewide indigent defense commission. Caseloads somewhat elevated but improved from prior years. Funding adequate but not exemplary.
Sixth Amendment Center; UT Indigent Defense Commission
+1
Eighth Amendment — bail reform and pretrial detention
Utah implemented some pretrial reform with risk-based assessment tools. Cash bail still used but with modifications. Reasonable balance.
Pretrial Justice Institute; UT Courts
+1
Property rights — regulatory burden and economic freedom
Utah ranks in the bottom quartile for regulatory burden nationally. Strong economic freedom. Regular regulatory review mechanisms in place.
Mercatus RegData; Pacific Research Institute
+2
Second Amendment — governor's litigation posture on firearms cases
UT AG defends state pro-2A laws and has filed supportive amicus briefs in federal firearms cases.
UT AG amicus filings; state litigation dockets
+2
First Amendment — compelled speech protections
No compelled speech laws in Utah. Some specific protections for healthcare workers and teachers regarding ideological statements.
UT Code; FIRE analysis
+2
Commerce Clause compliance — interstate trade barriers
Minor barriers exist (some licensing restrictions) but Utah works toward reciprocity. Generally open interstate commerce environment.
IJ licensing data; state reciprocity
+1
Privileges and Immunities — occupational licensing reform
Utah enacted significant licensing reform including military spouse expedited licensing and partial out-of-state recognition. Below-average licensing burden.
IJ License to Work; NCSL
+2
Contract Clause — state compliance with contractual obligations
Utah pension funded at ~95%. AAA bond rating from all three agencies. Zero contract impairments documented.
URS actuarial; S&P/Moody's/Fitch
+3
Jury trial rights — civil and criminal jury access
Standard jury access environment. No documented courthouse closures or systematic diversion to administrative tribunals.
UT Courts annual report; NCSC
+1
Immigration law compliance — Supremacy Clause adherence
Mixed record. No formal sanctuary law but SB 81 restricts ICE cooperation. E-Verify for large employers only. Issues driving privilege cards to undocumented (HB 259). In-state tuition for undocumented (HB 144). SAVE verification recently enacted. General ICE cooperation but with conditions.
SB 81; HB 259; HB 144; FAIR sanctuary database
0
Qualified immunity / due process for officers
No specific action on qualified immunity.
No relevant findings
0
Voter ID and ballot chain-of-custody
Signed HB 300 overhauling election law. Requires ID on ballot envelopes. Transition to opt-in mail system.
abc4.com; SLTrib
+1
Non-citizen voting prevention
HB 209 allows targeted citizenship review. Audit found only 1 non-citizen among 2M+ registrations.
KSL.com; Democracy Docket
+1
Women's sports / Title IX — biological sex protections in state-funded athletics
Vetoed transgender athlete ban in 2022 (overridden). Signed surgery restrictions in 2025. Ambivalent.
Washington Post; abc4.com
0

Child Welfare & Parental Rights

Meyer, Pierce, Troxel, Yoder, Parham; 14th Amendment
Score: 38 Range: -75 to 75 Items: 25
Parental rights legislation — statutory recognition
Utah has enacted parental rights provisions covering education, medical, and religious domains. Strong statutory protections consistent with state culture.
UT Code; NCSL parental rights tracker
+2
Education choice — school choice programs
Universal ESA/voucher program enacted — all UT K-12 students eligible. Open enrollment. Robust charter sector. Education savings deductions available. National model.
EdChoice UT guide; UT Code
+3
Parental notification/consent for medical procedures on minors
Utah requires parental consent for most medical procedures on minors. SB 16 (2023) banned gender-transition procedures for minors, reinforcing parental authority.
UT Code; SB 16 (2023)
+2
Gender-transition procedures for minors — restrictions
Signed SB 16 (Jan 2023) banning gender-transition medical procedures for minors including puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries. Limited exceptions. Criminal penalties not included (unlike FL/ID).
SB 16 (2023); Reuters tracker
+2
Child abuse and neglect — substantiated case rate trend
UT child maltreatment rate near national average. DCFS programs functioning. No dramatic improvement or deterioration.
ACF NCANDS; UT DCFS data
+1
Foster care — CFSR conformity assessment
Utah's foster care system performs at or near average on CFSR metrics. Some improvement areas identified but no systemic failures.
ACF CFSR; UT DCFS
+1
Foster care — permanency outcomes
Permanency timelines near national average. Adequate reunification rates. Some children remain in care longer than optimal.
ACF AFCARS; UT DCFS
+1
Child trafficking prevention and prosecution
Utah has comprehensive trafficking statute, funded task force through AG office, and safe harbor provisions. I-15 corridor monitored. Adequate prosecutions.
Polaris Project; Shared Hope; UT AG
+2
Education outcomes — 4th grade NAEP reading proficiency
UT 4th grade NAEP reading ~34% proficient (2022) — slightly above national average of 32%, within adequate range.
NCES NAEP 2022
+1
Education outcomes — 8th grade NAEP math proficiency
UT 8th grade NAEP math ~30% proficient (2022) — near national average, within adequate range.
NCES NAEP 2022
+1
Parental curriculum transparency
Utah has statutory right for parents to review curriculum materials. Public comment on textbook adoption. Opt-out provisions for sensitive content.
UT Code; USBE policies
+2
Social media — minor protections
Utah Social Media Regulation Act — NATIONAL MODEL. Requires age verification, parental consent for minors, data privacy protections, and platform liability. First-in-nation comprehensive approach.
UT Social Media Act; NCSL tracker
+3
Juvenile justice — age-appropriate treatment
Juvenile jurisdiction to 18. Limited transfer provisions for violent offenses. Some rehabilitation programs funded. Standard framework.
OJJDP UT profile; UT Juvenile Justice Services
+1
Child poverty rate and state response
UT child poverty rate approximately 9-10% — well below national average of ~16%. Strong family-oriented economy contributes.
Census ACS SAIPE; KIDS COUNT
+2
Adoption and permanency — adoptive family support
Utah has subsidized adoption, streamlined home study processes, and faith-based agency protections. Strong adoption culture.
ACF AFCARS; UT DCFS adoption data
+2
Homeschool rights and protections
Utah requires notification only (no curriculum mandates, no mandatory testing). Homeschool diplomas recognized. Sports access available. Moderate regulatory burden.
HSLDA UT; UT Code §53G-6-204
+2
Child sexual abuse material (CSAM) enforcement
Utah participates in ICAC task force. AG maintains proactive enforcement. Mandatory reporting compliance adequate. Increasing digital investigations.
ICAC data; NCMEC; UT AG
+2
School safety — violence prevention and incident response
Utah funds school safety grants, SRO programs, and threat assessment protocols. School safety center operational. Regular drills conducted.
NASRO; UT School Safety Center
+2
Children's mental health services access
UT school counselor ratio approximately 450-550:1 — near neutral range. Youth mental health crisis significant given high suicide rates. Some funded programs but access gaps remain.
ASCA; UT DSAMH
0
Childhood vaccination — parental choice protections
Utah allows religious and personal belief exemptions to vaccination requirements. Informed consent maintained. Parental decision respected without penalty.
NCSL vaccination data; UT Code
+2
Child care affordability and access
UT child care subsidy at approximately 150% FPL. Waitlists moderate. Quality rating system in place. Large family sizes create demand pressure.
ACF CCDF; NWLC
+1
Education — teacher quality and retention
UT teacher salaries among lowest nationally due to lowest per-pupil spending (~$9,500). Vacancy rates 7-10%. Retention challenges in STEM and special education. Compensation below regional average.
NCES; NEA salary rankings; USBE
0
Child nutrition — food insecurity rate
UT child food insecurity approximately 11-13%. School meal participation adequate. Below national average but not exemplary.
USDA ERS; Feeding America
+1
Custody and family court — due process in child removal
Utah has clear statutory criteria for child removal with judicial review requirements. Appointed counsel available. Standard due process framework.
UT Code; ABA Center on Children
+1
Children with disabilities — IDEA compliance
Utah generally rated 'Meets Requirements' by OSEP on IDEA compliance. Most districts compliant. Standard performance.
OSEP annual determinations; UT USBE SPED
+1

Faithful Discharge of Duties

Gubernatorial oath; Art. IV Sec. 4; state constitutions
Score: 66 Range: -123 to 123 Items: 41
Budget balance — structural surplus/deficit
Structural surplus every year of tenure. Zero budget gimmicks. General fund reserves growing. AAA credit from all three agencies reflects fiscal excellence.
UT GOPB; NASBO Fiscal Survey
+3
State credit rating stability
AAA from all three agencies (S&P since 1965, Moody's since 1973, Fitch since 1992). Stable outlook. Among only 14 states with triple-AAA.
S&P/Moody's/Fitch; UT State Treasurer
+3
Rainy day / budget stabilization fund adequacy
Rainy Day Fund at record levels, approximately 10-12% of general fund. Growing with statutory protection. But Pew notes UT below median on days-of-spending metric.
Pew rainy day fund data; UT GOPB
+2
Pension system funding responsibility
URS aggregate funded ratio 92.1% (Jan 2024). Making 100%+ ARC. Unfunded liability declining. Tier 2 DC plan limits future growth. Among best-funded nationally.
URS Actuarial Valuation 2024
+3
State debt burden
UT ranks 49th nationally in per capita debt (under $1,000). Debt at 14.4% of constitutional limit — 35-year low. Active debt reduction during tenure.
UT State Treasurer; Reason Foundation
+3
Government efficiency — state employee headcount per capita
Utah has below-average state employee headcount per capita. Stable during tenure. Efficiency improvements through technology investment.
Census Public Employment Survey; BLS
+2
Inspector General / state auditor independence
State Auditor John Dougall operates independently (elected position). Governor generally responsive to audit findings. Reports published publicly.
UT State Auditor Office; ALGA
+2
Ethics violations and personal scandals
Zero ethics complaints upheld. Zero personal scandals. Full financial disclosure. 'Disagree Better' initiative reflects ethical governance approach. Clean personal record.
UT Ethics Commission; financial disclosures
+3
Executive order restraint
Executive orders limited to legitimate administrative function. None struck down by courts. Volume near historical norms for UT governors.
UT EO database; court rulings
+2
Emergency powers — adherence to statutory limits
COVID emergency powers relinquished in appropriate timeframe. Supported legislative reform of emergency powers. No extended declarations beyond statutory limits.
UT emergency statutes; legislative records
+2
Legislative cooperation — veto override rate
Notable veto of HB 11 (trans athlete ban) was overridden by legislature. Otherwise, generally cooperative relationship with R supermajority. Override rate approximately 5-10%.
UT Legislature records
+1
Judicial appointments — qualifications and process integrity
Utah uses Judicial Nominating Commission for all judicial appointments. Cox has followed the process. Appointees generally qualified.
UT Judicial Nominating Commission; state bar
+2
Timely execution of laws — implementation of enacted legislation
Generally timely implementation of enacted legislation. No documented selective non-enforcement or court orders compelling enforcement.
UT agency rulemaking; legislative oversight
+2
Federal fund utilization — grant management
Federal grants managed within compliance. Single Audit findings minimal. No suspended or disallowed grants. $50M federal Bureau of Reclamation investment secured for Great Salt Lake.
Federal Audit Clearinghouse; UT ACFR
+2
Public approval as competence indicator
Morning Consult: 55-65% average approval — among highest nationally. Won 2024 primary against Trump-backed challenger. Strong bipartisan appeal.
Morning Consult quarterly; UT election results
+3
State IT security and data protection
Utah has CISO appointed with adequate budget. No major breaches documented during tenure. Basic NIST framework in place. Standard cybersecurity program.
NASCIO; UT DTS
+1
Infrastructure spending — capital budget execution
Capital budget execution adequate. Infrastructure investment ongoing including UDOT projects and broadband expansion. ASCE grade above national average.
ASCE UT; UT DOT; budget execution reports
+2
Disaster fund readiness
Utah maintains dedicated emergency fund. FEMA cost-share obligations met. Pre-positioned resources for earthquake/wildfire risk adequate.
FEMA BRIC; UT DEM fund balances
+2
Workforce development — unemployment system integrity
UT UI trust fund above DOL minimum. Low unemployment (2.9%) limits fraud exposure. Processing timely. Standard performance.
DOL UI Data Summary; UT DWS
+2
Medicaid program integrity
Partial Medicaid expansion via 1115 waiver. Error rates near national average. Standard integrity program. No major sanctions.
CMS PERM; UT DOH
+1
Election administration — constitutional compliance
Utah has voter ID requirement, paper ballot audit trail, and post-election audits. SAVE verification recently enacted (2026). Accurate voter rolls via ERIC membership.
EAC EAVS; UT SOS
+2
Transparency — state budget accessibility
GOPB maintains online budget portal with searchable spending data. Open data functional. Budget documents accessible. But GRAMA weakening offsets.
U.S. PIRG; GFOA; GOPB
+2
Intergovernmental cooperation — federal compliance balanced with sovereignty
Generally compliant with federal requirements. Some selective pushback on overreach. NGA Chairman 2023-24. But less aggressive 10th Amendment posture than peer R governors.
NGA records; federal compliance data
+1
Gubernatorial succession and continuity planning
LG Deidre Henderson confirmed and functional. Succession clear. COOP plan maintained and tested.
UT Constitution succession; UT DEM COOP
+2
Anti-corruption — state procurement integrity
Competitive bidding maintained above 80%. Standard procurement controls. Zero documented scandals or procurement irregularities during Cox tenure.
UT DAS procurement; State Auditor reports
+2
Gas price burden — state gas taxes, refinery regulations, cap-and-trade
UT gas prices moderate. No cap-and-trade. All-of-the-above energy strategy.
KSL.com; UT energy legislation
+1
Energy affordability — residential electricity costs from state policy
UT historically lowest electricity but costs climbing 15.2%. Rocky Mountain Power seeking 30.5% increase.
Axios SLC 2025-08-07
0
Energy policy competence — forced mandates without infrastructure readiness
All-of-the-above energy: nuclear, gas, coal, geothermal. 'Operation Gigawatt' to double production.
KSL.com; UT energy legislation
+1
Property tax burden — effective rate vs national median
UT effective property tax 0.49-0.52%, well below median. Signed SB 295 modifications.
SmartAsset; taxfoundation.org
+1
Regulatory cost burden — permits, compliance costs per household/business
UT ranked #1 best state to live. Low unemployment (2.8%). Business-friendly.
edcutah.org; Deseret News
+1
Unfunded mandates on municipalities
No specific action on unfunded mandates.
governor.utah.gov
0
Cost of living trajectory — policy-driven affordability trend
UT cost of living ~8-10% below average overall but housing 40.8% above median. Mixed.
movebuddha.com; edcutah.org
0
Immigration fiscal burden — taxpayer cost of sanctuary/benefits policies
Ordered LEO cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. Addressing $16M undocumented prisoner costs.
Deseret News; KSL.com
+1
Homelessness spending accountability — spending vs measurable outcomes
$147.3M for Homeless Services FY2026. Moving from Housing First to accountability model.
governor.utah.gov; UT News Dispatch
+1
Encampment enforcement — response to SCOTUS Grants Pass ruling
HB 421 bans camping on state property. HOME Court pilot. $81.2M combined with enforcement.
SLTrib 2025-03-14; governor.utah.gov
+2
Net domestic migration trend — people leaving vs arriving
UT growing (50,000+/year) but domestic migration slowed — growth more from high birth rate.
Deseret News; Kem Gardner Institute
+1
Business exodus — corporate HQ and jobs relocating due to policy
No business exodus. #1 ranked state. Strong tech sector.
edcutah.org; Deseret News
+1
DA accountability — governor's power to remove rogue prosecutors
No specific actions on DA accountability.
No relevant findings
0
Election infrastructure — ballot harvesting, drop box security, audit transparency
Signed HB 300 requiring ID on envelopes. Transition to opt-in mail voting.
governor.utah.gov; abc4.com
+1
Weaponization of state agencies — using AG/regulatory bodies against political opponents
No evidence of weaponization. Openly independent, criticizing both parties.
Deseret News 2025-12-30
+1
Foreign adversary protections — Chinese land, TikTok bans, Confucius Institutes
Blocked Chinese-owned corporation from buying land near airport. Forced Mitime Utah to divest. Partners with Strider AI.
Deseret News 2025-07-15; SLTrib 2026-02-13
+2
All RankingsKelly Ayotte #2 →
We investigate systems. We assess individuals.

These same forensics — your IQ, real bio age, career fit, and relationships — all quantum-verified.

What does the data say about you? →