52%

#16 of 50

Kim Reynolds

Iowa R | 2nd elected term

2017-05-24Took Office 9 yrs, 1 moIn Office 263Metrics Scored 859 / 1653Total Points

Section A: Governance

228/300

76%

Section B: State Outcomes

481/975

49%

Section C: Oath Fidelity

+150 (-378 to +378)

Section A — Governance 228/300

9 subsections evaluating executive performance: budget execution, legislative relations, appointments, emergency management, transparency, ethics, program management, federal relations, and constituent service.

Fiscal Responsibility — 34/45 (76%) 15 metrics

On-time budget submission

Budgets submitted on time each year since 2017. FY2026 budget compromise of $9.417B reached with Senate Republicans after negotiations on tax-cut revenue impacts.

IA Constitution; Governor's Budget Submissions; Governor's Press Release April 2025

Budget accuracy — revenue forecast vs actual

Revenue shortfall projected for FY2026 — $8.6B projected revenue vs $9.4B spending plan. Massive income tax cut from 8.98% top rate to 3.8% flat rate reduced revenue by $605M annually by FY2026. Revenue Estimating Conference repeatedly reduced projections. Structural gap emerging despite $1.8B surplus cushion inherited.

IA Revenue Estimating Conference; IA Legislative Services Agency; Iowa Capital Dispatch May 2024

Rainy day fund management

Reserves peaked at over $900M in rainy day fund plus $2.74B in Taxpayer Relief Fund. Tax cuts financed partly by withdrawals from Taxpayer Relief Fund. Reserves still provide cushion but trajectory concerning as structural revenue shortfall draws on accumulated balances.

IA State Treasurer Reserve Reports; DFM Budget Reports; Governor's FY2025 Budget Statement

State credit rating trajectory

Iowa retains AAA credit rating from Moody's, Fitch, and S&P — reaffirmed April 2024. Outlook stable. Agencies cite diversified economy, strong governance, healthy reserves, and low debt/pension burden. One of ~13 states with triple-AAA from all three agencies.

Moody's & Fitch Reaffirmation April 2024; S&P Global Ratings; Governor's Press Release April 2024

Pension funding ratio trajectory

IPERS funded ratio hit 90.75% in FY2024 — highest since FY2002 and 11th best nationally. Trust fund reached $42.9B with 9.07% investment return exceeding 7% assumption, creating $245M actuarial gain. Pays $2.6B annually in benefits. Strong trajectory under Reynolds.

IPERS FY2024 Actuarial Valuation; IPERS Press Release Dec 2024; NASRA State Profiles

Debt per capita trajectory

Iowa ranks ~40th nationally in per capita state debt (~$1,960/person). Conservative debt management maintained through Reynolds tenure. Low bonded debt consistent with AAA credit rating. No significant new debt issuances beyond routine capital needs.

IA State Treasurer Debt Reports; Ballotpedia State Debt Data; Census Population Estimates

CAFR/ACFR published on time

ACFR published within statutory timelines each year. Iowa Department of Management and State Auditor coordinate timely financial reporting. No delays noted during Reynolds tenure.

IA State Auditor ACFR Records; IA DOM Financial Reports

Audit findings — material weaknesses

No major material weaknesses identified in statewide single audits under Reynolds. State Auditor Rob Sand (elected 2018) operated independently; findings focused on Medicaid managed care issues rather than executive branch financial controls.

IA State Auditor Single Audit Reports; Federal Oversight Reviews

Federal grant fund accounting

Federal ARPA, IIJA, and CARES Act funds administered without major accounting failures. Over $533M in broadband grants distributed through Empower Rural Iowa with proper federal fund accounting. $26M Test Iowa COVID initiative accounted for.

IA Single Audit Reports; USASpending.gov; Empower Rural Iowa Grant Records

Anti-fraud controls — federal programs

Standard anti-fraud controls maintained. No documented major fraud losses in federal programs. COVID relief programs (ARPA, CARES) distributed without significant fraud findings. State Auditor reviews found no systemic fraud in federal grant administration.

IA State Auditor Reports; Federal Single Audit Reviews; IG Reports

Tax revenue vs expenditure alignment

Structural misalignment from largest tax overhaul in Iowa history. Income tax cut from 8.98% top rate (9 brackets) to 3.8% flat rate reduced revenue $605M annually by FY2026. State collecting ~$8.6B against $9.4B budget. Taxpayer Relief Fund tapped to bridge gap. Governor says 'must maintain spending discipline.' $1.8B surplus inherited now declining.

IA Revenue Estimating Conference; IA Legislative Services Agency; Governor's Budget Statement April 2025; SF 2442 (2024)

Capital budget execution rate

Capital projects proceeding within normal parameters. Identified 4,700 acres of state-owned farmland for sale as part of government reorganization. Major broadband capital investment of $533M+ through Empower Rural Iowa grants for rural connectivity infrastructure.

IA DAS Capital Budget Reports; Government Alignment Act (SF 514); Empower Rural Iowa Records

Vendor/contractor oversight

Standard procurement oversight. No major vendor scandals. Government reorganization from 37 to 16 agencies (SF 514, 2023) consolidated procurement functions. Eliminated 600+ open positions and 1,200 regulations, saving $214M over four years.

IA DAS Procurement Records; Government Alignment Act SF 514 (2023)

Federal funding maximization

Captured IIJA and ARPA funding — allocated $210M ARPA for broadband alone (Jan 2022). Secured $152M Treasury Capital Projects Fund for broadband (Dec 2022). Total broadband investment exceeded $533M. $26M Test Iowa COVID testing program. FEMA aid secured for derecho ($4B request).

USASpending.gov — Iowa; Treasury CPF Approval Dec 2022; FEMA Disaster Declarations

Program eligibility verification systems

Standard eligibility verification maintained. SAVE system used for benefits verification. E-Verify mandatory for state contractors. Medicaid managed care contractors required to verify eligibility. No major eligibility fraud findings.

IA DHS Program Integrity Reports; IA DAS Procurement Requirements

Legislative Relations — 27/39 (69%) 13 metrics

Signature legislation enacted

Signed largest tax overhaul in Iowa history — 8.98% (9 brackets) to 3.8% flat rate (SF 2442, May 2024). Signed Students First Act (Jan 2023) creating universal ESA vouchers ($7,826/student, $314M by Year 3). Signed 50% unemployment insurance tax cut saving businesses ~$1B over 5 years. Signed SF 496 (book/gender restrictions). Signed government reorganization (37 to 16 agencies). Constitutional carry (2021). Heartbeat abortion ban (2023).

IA General Assembly Bill Tracking; SF 2442; Students First Act HF 68; SF 514; Governor's Signing Records

Veto override rate

Zero vetoes overridden during entire tenure. Republican trifecta (House, Senate, Governor) maintained since 2017. Strong party discipline — even when House initially blocked vouchers in 2022, Reynolds prevailed in 2023 session.

IA General Assembly Journal; Veto Records; Legislative History 2017-2026

Bipartisan bills signed

Major legislation passed on strict party lines — Students First Act, SF 496, flat tax, gender identity removal from civil rights code. Voucher bill initially failed when 5 GOP House members broke ranks (2022) before passing 2023. Broadband and workforce bills had broader support. Very limited bipartisan achievement on signature priorities.

IA General Assembly Vote Records; HF 68 Roll Call; SF 496 Roll Call

Special sessions called

No special sessions called during Reynolds tenure. Legislative agenda accomplished within regular sessions despite ambitious scope (flat tax, vouchers, government reorganization, abortion ban). Reynolds achieved signature priorities through regular legislative process.

IA General Assembly Session Records 2017-2026

Executive orders — legal challenges

COVID executive orders faced legal challenges — school mask mandate ban challenged by disability rights groups. Heartbeat abortion ban (2018) struck down by district court; 2023 six-week ban upheld in split 3-3 Iowa Supreme Court decision (Jun 2024). SF 496 book provisions blocked by federal judge (Dec 2023). No executive orders struck down by Iowa Supreme Court.

IA Court Records; Planned Parenthood v. Reynolds; Iowa Safe Schools v. Reynolds

Line-item veto usage

Disciplined veto usage consistent with Republican trifecta. Line-item veto power used selectively on appropriations. Vetoed items aligned with fiscal conservatism priorities. Limited need for vetoes given strong legislative alignment.

IA Constitution Art. III Ã‚Â§16; Governor's Veto Records 2017-2026

Regulatory burden change

Eliminated 1,200 state regulations in first year of government reorganization (SF 514). UI tax cut (50% base reduction, max rate 9% to 5.4%) saves businesses ~$1B over 5 years. Flat income tax simplifies compliance. Government consolidation from 37 to 16 agencies reduced regulatory overlap. Business-friendly permitting environment.

SF 514 Government Alignment Act; UI Reform Bill Jun 2025; IA Administrative Code

Budget negotiation success

FY2026 budget compromise of $9.417B reached with Senate Republicans despite intra-party tensions over tax-cut sustainability. Revenue Estimating Conference projections repeatedly lowered, complicating negotiations. Budget financed partly from Taxpayer Relief Fund withdrawals. Reynolds got core priorities funded but fiscal constraints tightening.

IA General Assembly Budget Records; Revenue Estimating Conference Dec 2025; Governor's Budget Statement

Bill signing rate on popular legislation

Flat tax popular with base but ESA voucher costs ballooned 44% to $314M by Year 3 (from $107M Year 1). SF 496 book restrictions highly controversial — federal judge blocked key provisions (Dec 2023). Gender identity removal from civil rights code (Feb 2025) made Iowa first state to do so. Vouchers initially failed when 5 GOP House members broke ranks (2022). Transgender athlete ban and care restrictions signed.

IA General Assembly Records; ESA Cost Data; SF 496 Injunction; SF 538; HF 2389

Legislative relationship

Productive relationship with Republican trifecta but notable intra-party friction. House blocked vouchers in 2022 when 5 GOP members defected. Reynolds prevailed in 2023 after redistricting strengthened her caucus. Legislature passed flat tax, government reorganization, abortion ban, teacher pay increase, and UI tax cut. Some GOP resistance to property tax reform in 2025 session.

IA General Assembly Records 2017-2026; Legislative Session Summaries

Implementation of voter-approved measures

Iowa has no citizen initiative process — amendments require two consecutive legislative sessions plus voter approval. Reynolds supported constitutional amendment banning non-citizen voting, which passed Nov 2024 with 76% voter approval. Second Amendment protection amendment also advanced through process.

IA Constitution Art. X; Secretary of State Election Results Nov 2024

Task force follow-through

Future Ready Iowa workforce goal (70% post-secondary training by 2025) reached two years early. Child care reform bill failed in 2025 legislature — Reynolds used executive action to expand pilot programs and create statewide child care fund. ESA voucher program fully implemented (universal by 2025-26). Flat tax accelerated ahead of schedule via SF 2442. Teacher pay raised to $50,000 minimum (largest increase in state history).

Future Ready Iowa Jan 2024 Report; Governor's Executive Actions 2025; SF 2442; Teacher Pay Bill Mar 2024

Policy reversals under pressure

Remarkably consistent ideological direction — no major policy reversals. Flat tax, vouchers, abortion restrictions, gun rights, immigration enforcement all pursued relentlessly. COVID approach shifted steadily toward reopening (never imposed shelter-in-place). Voucher push failed 2022, succeeded 2023 — persistence not reversal. Chose not to appeal 2018 heartbeat ban loss but signed new version in 2023.

Governor's Executive Actions Timeline; Legislative History 2017-2026

Appointments & Staffing — 29/36 (81%) 12 metrics

Appointee criminal/ethics issues

No major criminal or ethics issues with Reynolds appointees. DHS Director Jerry Foxhoven asked to resign in 2019 after controversies unrelated to criminal conduct. Adam Gregg served as acting Lt. Governor (AG opinion said Reynolds lacked authority to formally appoint). Appointees generally vetted without scandal.

IA Ethics and Campaign Disclosure Board; AG Opinion on Lt. Gov. Appointment; Court Records

Agency head vacancy rate

Agency head positions generally filled. Government reorganization (37 to 16 agencies, 2023) eliminated 600+ open positions as a feature, not a vacancy. DHS Director turnover (Foxhoven ousted 2019, replaced). New department structures required fresh leadership appointments across consolidated agencies.

Governor's Appointment Records; SF 514 Government Alignment Act Implementation

State employee turnover

State employee turnover standard. Teacher vacancy rate only 1.12% in 2025-26 (vs 3% nationally) after record pay increase to $50,000 minimum. Government reorganization eliminated 600+ unfilled positions. Tight labor market (3.1% unemployment) creates recruitment challenges but Iowa's low cost of living helps retention.

IA DAS Workforce Data; IA Dept of Education Vacancy Report Jan 2026; BLS LAUS Iowa

Diversity of appointments

Iowa is ~85% white (Census). Limited demographic diversity in senior appointments. Reynolds is Iowa's first female governor. Hispanic representation growing in state (7%+) but limited in senior positions. Meatpacking communities (Storm Lake, Marshalltown) are majority-minority but leadership appointments don't reflect this diversity.

Governor's Appointment Records; Census ACS IA Demographics; Reynolds Biography

Judicial appointment quality

Reynolds shifted Iowa Supreme Court rightward through multiple appointments — majority of current justices are Reynolds appointees. Iowa uses merit selection (Judicial Nominating Commission presents shortlist, governor selects). Reynolds appointees upheld 6-week abortion ban in 3-3 split decision (Jun 2024). Conservative judicial philosophy consistent with governor's agenda.

IA Judicial Nominating Commission; Iowa Supreme Court Roster; Planned Parenthood v. Reynolds (2024)

State workforce pay competitiveness

Teacher minimum salary raised from $33,500 to $50,000 (largest increase in state history, signed Mar 2024) — $96M investment. State aims for top-5 nationally in starting teacher pay. $8.5M Teachers Accelerating Learning Incentive Fund provides $2,500 bonuses. General state employee pay competitive for Iowa's low cost of living (RPP ~88-90).

IA Teacher Pay Bill Mar 2024; IA DAS Compensation Reports; BEA RPP; BLS OES IA Data

Whistleblower protection

No documented retaliation against whistleblowers during Reynolds tenure. State Auditor Rob Sand (Democrat, elected 2018) operated independently and issued critical reports on Medicaid privatization without interference. Whistleblower protections under Iowa Code Chapter 70A maintained.

IA Ethics Board Records; Iowa Code Ch. 70A; State Auditor Independence

Inspector General independence

State Auditor Rob Sand (Democrat) operated independently throughout Reynolds tenure. Sand issued critical reports on Medicaid managed care showing 500-890% increase in illegal denials. Reynolds did not interfere with Auditor's office despite critical findings. No inspector general equivalent — Auditor serves oversight function.

IA State Auditor Office Records; Medicaid Privatization Audit Oct 2021

State employee morale

No documented systemwide morale crisis. Teacher morale initially challenged by voucher program, SF 496 book restrictions, and AEA restructuring — but record pay increase ($33,500 to $50,000 minimum) and 99% fill rate suggest stabilization. Government reorganization created uncertainty but eliminated unfilled positions rather than layoffs.

IA DAS Employee Data; IA Dept of Education Workforce Reports; Teacher Pay Bill Impact

Nepotism/cronyism

No documented nepotism in appointments. Close relationship with Iowa Select Farms owners (Jeff and Deb Hansen, ~$300K in campaign donations) raised appearance-of-access concerns but no nepotism finding. Ethics Board director said charity auction with Hansen Foundation did not violate state law.

IA Ethics Records; AP Investigation Feb 2021; Ethics Board Director Statement

Senior staff criminal charges

No senior staff charged with crimes during Reynolds tenure. DHS Director Jerry Foxhoven asked to resign (Jun 2019) over management concerns, not criminal issues. Acting Lt. Gov. Adam Gregg served without legal issues. Senior staff maintained clean records.

Court Records; Governor's Office Personnel Records

Agency performance accountability

Government reorganization (37 to 16 agencies) included performance accountability framework. $214M in savings identified over four years. 1,200 regulations eliminated. Agency heads accountable under new consolidated structure. Budget discipline maintained with spending held below revenue growth during early tenure.

IA DAS Performance Reports; SF 514 Implementation Reports; Government Alignment Act Savings

Emergency Management — 25/36 (69%) 12 metrics

Disaster declaration timeliness

Timely disaster declarations: COVID emergency (Mar 17, 2020), derecho (Aug 10, 2020 — same day as storm), 2024 flooding and tornadoes. Requested expedited federal disaster declaration for derecho within days. Multiple FEMA major disaster declarations secured during tenure.

IA HSEMD Records; FEMA Disaster Declarations DR-4557 (derecho); Governor's Emergency Proclamations

FEMA Public Assistance secured

Secured FEMA assistance for 2020 derecho — requested $3.998B in federal aid including $3.77B crop damage across 36 counties. 10 million acres (~1/3 of cropland) damaged. $82.7M in housing damage (8,273+ homes). $45.3M in public assistance needs. $100M in utility damage. President approved major disaster declaration.

FEMA PA Records DR-4557; Governor's Federal Aid Request Aug 2020; USDA Crop Damage Assessment

Emergency reserve adequacy

Reserves included $900M+ rainy day fund and $2.74B Taxpayer Relief Fund. Tax cuts financed partly from Taxpayer Relief Fund withdrawals. Reserves adequate for current emergencies but trajectory concerning — annual $605M revenue reduction from flat tax erodes long-term reserve sustainability.

IA State Treasurer Reserve Reports; FY2025 Budget Documents; Revenue Estimating Conference

Lives lost — preventable from state failure

Derecho (Aug 10, 2020) caused 4 direct deaths and massive property/crop destruction but state response mobilized quickly. COVID: 5,600+ Iowans died in first 12 months. Meatpacking plant outbreaks (Tyson Waterloo: 1,031 of 2,800 workers infected, 6-8 deaths) occurred after Reynolds refused to close plants, calling them 'essential.' No shelter-in-place order ever issued.

IA HSEMD Incident Reports; FEMA Records; CDC COVID Data; Tyson Waterloo Outbreak Data

Post-disaster recovery

Derecho recovery: 75,000+ Iowans without power one week after storm. 10 million crop acres damaged ($3.77B agricultural loss). 8,273+ homes destroyed or severely damaged. Recovery proceeded with federal aid but pace criticized in Cedar Rapids and rural communities. 90-mile-wide path of destruction across state's two largest cities.

IA HSEMD Recovery Reports; USDA Crop Damage Reports; Cedar Rapids Gazette Recovery Coverage

Public health emergency response

COVID response widely criticized. Never issued shelter-in-place order — one of few governors not to do so. Meatpacking outbreaks devastated communities: Tyson Waterloo plant had 38% infection rate (1,031 of 2,800 workers). Signed legislation banning mask mandates and vaccine mandates in schools. 5,600+ Iowans died in first 12 months. $26M Test Iowa testing program launched but capacity insufficient early on.

CDC COVID Data Tracker — Iowa; IA DPH COVID Reports; Tyson Waterloo Data; Test Iowa Program Records

Infrastructure failure prevention

No major infrastructure failures causing deaths. Derecho destroyed $100M in private utility infrastructure but grid restored within weeks. Iowa DOT maintained rural road network without catastrophic failures. Dam safety and bridge integrity maintained. 2024 flooding caused damage but levee/infrastructure systems performed adequately.

IA Utility Board Reports; IA DOT Reports; Derecho Utility Damage Assessment

National Guard deployment appropriateness

Guard deployed for derecho recovery, flooding, COVID logistics, and Texas border operations. Reynolds deployed 109 Guard troops and 31 State Patrol officers to Operation Lone Star (Aug-Sep 2023) using $1.93M ARPA funds. Additional 110 personnel deployed Apr-May 2024. Operations resulted in 40 smuggling cases, 491 migrants apprehended.

IA National Guard Records; Governor's Operation Lone Star Press Releases Oct 2023; EMAC Request Records

Emergency communication

Daily COVID press conferences held during peak periods. Derecho communication hampered by widespread power/cell outages across 90-mile-wide damage zone. COVID messaging criticized for inconsistency — promoted reopening while cases surged. Reynolds claimed state was 'leading the nation' in COVID response, contradicted by data.

IA HSEMD Communication Records; Governor's COVID Press Conferences; Media Analysis

Interagency coordination

Interagency coordination effective during derecho — HSEMD, National Guard, utilities, and federal agencies mobilized within hours. COVID coordination with Iowa DPH adequate but meatpacking plant response criticized for deferring to industry (Tyson, Iowa Select Farms) over public health officials. Multi-agency flooding response in 2024 well-coordinated.

IA HSEMD After-Action Reports; Derecho Coordination Records; ProPublica Meatpacking Investigation

Pandemic response metrics

Iowa COVID outcomes worse than national average at peak periods. 5,600+ dead in first 12 months, 360,000+ confirmed cases. Meatpacking plants doubled local infection rates (110% increase for beef plants, 160% for pork). Tyson Waterloo: 38% workforce infected. No shelter-in-place ever issued. Banned mask/vaccine mandates in schools. Poor approval for pandemic handling.

CDC COVID Data Tracker — Iowa; Johns Hopkins Data; Tyson Waterloo Data; Meatpacking Study (PNAS)

Disaster preparedness & emergency infrastructure

Derecho 2020 (Aug 10): $4B+ total damage, 90-mile-wide path, 140 mph winds. Response coordinated across state/federal agencies. 2024 flooding and tornadoes prompted additional disaster declarations. Iowa HSEMD maintains statewide emergency infrastructure. Agricultural disaster preparedness standard — USDA crop insurance covers most farm losses.

IA HSEMD

Transparency & Ethics — 30/39 (77%) 13 metrics

FOIA/open records compliance

Mixed FOIA record. ACLU filed open records lawsuit against Reynolds's office (Apr 2025) after governor invoked 'executive privilege' to withhold documents about Satanic Temple Capitol event cancellation. Iowa Supreme Court allowed lawsuit to proceed. Governor's office has resisted some records requests that critics say should be public.

ACLU of Iowa v. Reynolds (2025); Iowa Supreme Court FOIA Ruling; IA AG Open Records Guidance

Governor's schedule availability

Governor's schedule posted on official website. Reynolds maintained regular public appearances at events across Iowa's 99 counties. However, criticized for limiting press access during controversial periods (COVID, voucher debates). Schedule availability standard but not exceptional.

Governor's Office Website; Media Access Reports

Campaign finance compliance

No campaign finance violations found. Iowa Select Farms owners (Jeff and Deb Hansen) contributed ~$300K to Reynolds campaigns — among largest donors. Reynolds auctioned afternoon of her time at Hansen Foundation charity event (2019), won by pork executive for $4,250. Ethics Board director said no violation but former governors called it 'appearance of impropriety.'

IA Ethics and Campaign Disclosure Board Records; AP Investigation Feb 2021

Financial disclosure

Financial disclosures filed as required under Iowa law. Reynolds's income primarily from gubernatorial salary. No outside business interests creating conflicts. Disclosures show standard compliance but Iowa disclosure requirements are less stringent than many states.

IA Ethics Board Financial Disclosure Records; Iowa Code Ch. 68B

Open meetings compliance

No major Open Meetings Act violations during Reynolds tenure. Executive branch meetings conducted in compliance with Iowa Code Chapter 21. No AG findings of systematic open meetings violations by governor's office.

IA AG Open Meetings Decisions; Iowa Code Ch. 21

Open data portal

Iowa maintains open data portal (data.iowa.gov) with standard government datasets. ESA voucher program criticized for lack of transparency — $314M program with limited accountability reporting on student outcomes. Iowa State Daily and other outlets raised transparency concerns about private school spending of public ESA funds.

data.iowa.gov; Iowa State Daily ESA Transparency Investigation; IA DOM Data Resources

Budget transparency

Budget documents published through Department of Management website. FY2026 budget of $9.417B detailed online. Revenue Estimating Conference projections publicly available. However, Medicaid managed care savings estimates varied widely ($47M to $232M claimed) without clear explanation — Auditor criticized inconsistent financial reporting.

IA Department of Management Budget Website; Revenue Estimating Conference; State Auditor Medicaid Reports

Lobbying disclosure

Lobbying disclosure maintained through Iowa Ethics and Campaign Disclosure Board. Lobbyist registration and expenditure reports publicly accessible. No changes to weaken disclosure requirements during Reynolds tenure. Standard compliance with Iowa Code Chapter 68B.

IA Ethics Board Lobbying Records; Iowa Code Ch. 68B

IG report publication

State Auditor Rob Sand published reports including critical Medicaid privatization audit showing 500-890% increase in illegal care denials. Reports publicly available on auditor.iowa.gov. Governor did not suppress or delay publication of unfavorable audit findings despite political implications.

IA State Auditor Website (auditor.iowa.gov); Medicaid Privatization Audit Oct 2021

Legislative audit cooperation

Cooperation with legislative audits maintained. State Auditor (independently elected Democrat) conducted audits without executive interference. Medicaid managed care audits revealed significant problems but executive branch cooperated with access. Legislative Services Agency budget analyses published without obstruction.

IA State Auditor Records; Legislative Services Agency Fiscal Analysis

Press conference accessibility

Regular press conferences held, including daily COVID briefings during peak pandemic. Condition of State address delivered annually. Reynolds active on national media (RNC speech Aug 2020, Fox News appearances). However, criticized for limiting press questions during contentious periods and controlling media narrative.

Governor's Office Media Schedule; RNC Speech Aug 2020; Media Access Reports

State contract transparency

State contract transparency maintained through DAS procurement system. Medicaid managed care contracts with private insurers drew scrutiny — savings claims varied from $47M to $232M without clear explanation. Government reorganization consolidated procurement under fewer agencies, potentially improving oversight. No major contract corruption scandals.

IA DAS Procurement Records; State Auditor Medicaid Contract Reviews

Court order compliance

Complied with court orders including federal injunction blocking SF 496 book provisions (Dec 2023). Chose not to appeal 2019 heartbeat ban ruling. Complied with Iowa Supreme Court 3-3 split on six-week abortion ban. ACLU open records lawsuit proceeding — compliance pending. No contempt findings.

Court Records; Iowa Safe Schools v. Reynolds; ACLU v. Reynolds; Planned Parenthood v. Reynolds

Ethics & Integrity — 37/39 (95%) 13 metrics

Personal criminal charges

No criminal charges during governorship. Two DUI arrests (1999 and 2000) predated office by nearly two decades. 2000 arrest: BAC of .228, open whiskey bottle, charged with 2nd-offense OWI but allowed to plead to 1st offense. Reynolds has publicly discussed recovery from alcoholism as 'turning point.' Court records later sealed for privacy.

Court Records; Chicago Tribune Jun 2019; Reynolds Autobiography; Historical Records

Ethics complaints — substantiated

No substantiated ethics complaints by Iowa Ethics and Campaign Disclosure Board. Iowa Select Farms charity auction raised appearance concerns but Board director found no violation. Close ties to pork industry donors scrutinized by AP but no formal findings of impropriety.

IA Ethics and Campaign Disclosure Board Records; AP Investigation Feb 2021

Gift/travel disclosure

Gift and travel disclosures filed per Iowa Code Ch. 68B. Reynolds auctioned Capitol tour and lunch at Governor's mansion for $4,250 at Hansen Foundation charity event (2019) — disclosed but criticized by two former Democratic governors as 'error in judgment.' Travel for national GOP events and border visits disclosed.

IA Ethics Board Records; AP Investigation; Iowa Code Ch. 68B

Conflict of interest

No formal conflicts of interest documented. Iowa Select Farms relationship scrutinized — owners donated ~$300K to campaigns and Reynolds declined to close meatpacking plants during COVID outbreaks. Ethics Board did not find conflict but critics noted policy alignment with donor interests. No personal financial conflicts identified.

IA Ethics Board Records; AP Iowa Select Farms Investigation; COVID Meatpacking Response

State resources for political purposes

No documented misuse of state resources for political purposes. Used $1.93M ARPA funds for National Guard border deployment (Operation Lone Star) — legal but politically charged use of federal COVID relief money. RNC speech (Aug 2020) delivered from official capacity. No formal findings of misuse.

IA Ethics Board Records; ARPA Fund Usage Records; RNC Aug 2020

Truthfulness in official statements

Some disputed claims about education funding and Medicaid savings. Claimed Medicaid privatization saved $232M — State Auditor found $47M-$126M (varying estimates without explanation). Claimed state was 'leading nation' in COVID response while Iowa had above-average death rates. Education funding claims disputed by fact-checkers (KCRG). No false statements to official bodies documented.

KCRG Fact Check Feb 2025; State Auditor Medicaid Reports; Governor's Public Statements

Protection of ethics infrastructure

Iowa Ethics and Campaign Disclosure Board maintained with standard funding. No attempts to weaken ethics oversight or reduce Board authority. State Auditor (independently elected) maintained full independence. Government reorganization did not consolidate or diminish ethics oversight functions.

IA Ethics Board Budget Records; Iowa Code Ch. 68B; Government Alignment Act

Emoluments/self-dealing

No self-dealing or emoluments violations documented. Reynolds's income limited to gubernatorial salary. No outside business interests or investments creating self-dealing concerns. Financial disclosures show clean personal financial profile during tenure.

IA Ethics Board Financial Disclosures; Iowa Code Ch. 68B

Campaign donor to state contract pipeline

Iowa Select Farms owners (Hansen family) donated ~$300K and received favorable policy treatment (meatpacking plants kept open during COVID). Reynolds auctioned access for Hansen Foundation ($4,250). However, Ethics Board found no legal violation. No systematic donor-to-contract pipeline documented beyond pork industry relationship.

IA Campaign Finance Records; AP Investigation Feb 2021; Procurement Records

Foreign influence

No foreign influence concerns. Iowa agricultural trade interests (soybeans, pork) create foreign commercial relationships but no improper influence documented. Reynolds engaged with trade delegations as part of normal agricultural state operations. No FARA registrations connected to governor's office.

DOJ FARA Database; IA Economic Development Authority Trade Records

Sexual harassment claims

No sexual harassment claims against Reynolds or her office. Reynolds is Iowa's first female governor (succeeded Branstad as Lt. Gov. May 2017). No personal harassment allegations or office misconduct reports during tenure. Clean record on workplace conduct.

IA DAS Records; Governor's Office Personnel Files

Records preservation

No documented records destruction. Iowa court removed Reynolds's OWI arrest files from online access (2019) to protect personal information — but this was a judicial action on old records, not executive records destruction. State archives maintained according to retention schedules.

IA State Archives Records; Court Order on OWI Files Jun 2019

Revolving door

No major revolving door violations documented. Iowa has limited post-employment lobbying restrictions compared to some states. DHS Director Foxhoven departed to private sector after forced resignation (2019) without revolving door concerns. Standard transition patterns for departing officials.

IA Ethics Board Records; Iowa Code Post-Employment Provisions

Program Management — 26/36 (72%) 12 metrics

Fraud losses in state programs

No major documented fraud losses in state programs. COVID relief fund distribution (ARPA, CARES) completed without significant fraud findings. Medicaid managed care oversight identified illegal care denials (500-890% increase per Auditor) but these were improper denials, not fraud losses. ESA voucher program lacks robust accountability mechanisms.

IA State Auditor Reports; Federal Reviews; Medicaid Audit Oct 2021

Program integrity — eligibility verification

Standard program integrity for SNAP, TANF, and Medicaid. SAVE system used for benefits verification. E-Verify mandatory for state contractors. Medicaid managed care privatization (inherited from Branstad) showed 500-890% increase in improper care denials per State Auditor — program integrity concerns on provider side rather than beneficiary fraud.

IA DHS Program Reports; State Auditor Medicaid Privatization Audit

IT system modernization

State IT systems functional. Government reorganization consolidated IT under Chief Information Officer. Broadband expansion ($533M+ invested) improved rural connectivity infrastructure. No major cybersecurity breaches or IT system failures during tenure. Unemployment insurance IT system handled COVID surge without catastrophic failure.

IA OCIO Reports; Empower Rural Iowa Broadband Grants; IA DAS IT Reports

Permit processing timeliness

Business-friendly permitting environment. Government reorganization eliminated 1,200 regulations in first year. Iowa ranked among top states for business climate by multiple indices. 3.1% unemployment indicates strong business activity. Permitting streamlined through agency consolidation from 37 to 16 departments.

IA Economic Development Authority Reports; SF 514 Regulatory Reduction Data; BLS LAUS Iowa

Child welfare system

Met basic federal Child and Family Services Review requirements. DHS Director Foxhoven — who oversaw child welfare among other services — forced out in Jun 2019 amid management concerns. Government reorganization consolidated DHS into Iowa Health and Human Services. Foster care system functional but rural access challenges persist.

ACF CFSR Results — Iowa; DHS Director Transition Records; Government Alignment Act

Medicaid program management

Medicaid managed care privatized under Branstad (Apr 2016). Reynolds inherited and maintained system covering 845,000+ Iowans. State Auditor found 500-890% increase in illegal care denials post-privatization. Savings claims inconsistent ($47M to $232M depending on source). MCO contractor turnover — Amerihealth Caritas left Iowa. Reynolds defended program despite auditor criticism.

CMS Reviews — Iowa; State Auditor Medicaid Report Oct 2021; IA DHS Medicaid Data

Environmental program

EPA-delegated programs meeting standards. Water quality remains Iowa's top environmental challenge — nitrate levels in Des Moines and Raccoon rivers nearly doubled federal drinking water limits. Reynolds favors voluntary conservation over regulation: 'regulation is hardly ever the answer.' Signed $34M water quality grant program (first act as governor, 2018). Iowa Nutrient Reduction Strategy relies on voluntary practices. $8M in water quality grants to 18 communities (Feb 2025).

EPA State Program Evaluations — Iowa; Iowa DNR Reports; IA Nutrient Reduction Strategy; Governor's Water Quality Bill 2018

Transportation project delivery

Iowa DOT projects generally on schedule. Rural road network maintained for agricultural state. Derecho (2020) required massive infrastructure rebuilding — $100M in utility damage alone. IIJA funding secured for highways and bridges. Broadband infrastructure investment of $533M+ through Empower Rural Iowa connecting 39,000+ homes, schools, and businesses.

IA DOT Annual Reports; FHWA — Iowa; Empower Rural Iowa Broadband Awards; Derecho Infrastructure Damage

Unemployment insurance system

UI system functional. Unemployment 3.1% (Nov 2024) — among lowest nationally. Signed 50% UI tax base reduction (max rate 9% to 5.4%) saving businesses ~$1B over 5 years (effective Jul 2025). Labor force participation 66.3% — well above national average. COVID surge tested UI system but it handled claims without catastrophic failure.

Iowa Workforce Development UI Data; BLS LAUS — Iowa; UI Reform Bill Jun 2025

Veterans services

Iowa veterans services maintained through Iowa Department of Veterans Affairs. Iowa Veterans Home in Marshalltown continued operations. Government reorganization preserved veterans services as distinct function. Standard VA federal grant participation. No major veterans services failures or scandals during tenure.

IA DVA Annual Reports; VA State Grant Data; Government Alignment Act

Housing program effectiveness

Iowa housing highly affordable — RPP ~88-90 (well below national average). Median home price well below national average. No homelessness crisis (HUD PIT count among lowest per capita). Rural housing stock aging but not at crisis. Child care desert addressed through pilot programs and statewide fund after legislature failed to pass Reynolds's child care bill (2025).

HUD PIT Count — Iowa; Census Housing Data; BEA RPP; IA Finance Authority Reports

Corrections system

Iowa corrections system operating within standard parameters. No DOJ consent decree or federal intervention. Incarceration rate moderate for Midwest. Reynolds signed felon voting rights restoration executive order (Aug 2020) — restoring rights for completed sentences. Corrections system maintained without major incidents or overcrowding crises.

IA DOC Annual Reports; BJS NPS — Iowa; Executive Order on Felon Voting Rights Aug 2020

Federal Relations — 11/15 (73%) 5 metrics

Federal funding captured

Captured major federal funding: $210M ARPA for broadband (Jan 2022), $152M Treasury Capital Projects Fund (Dec 2022), IIJA highway/bridge funds. Total broadband investment exceeded $533M (mostly federal). FEMA disaster aid for derecho ($4B+ requested). Used $1.93M ARPA for National Guard border deployment (Operation Lone Star).

USASpending.gov — Iowa; Treasury CPF Iowa; FEMA DR-4557; Empower Rural Iowa Records

Federal corrective action plans

No major federal corrective action plans required. Medicaid managed care drew CMS attention but no federal takeover or sanctions. EPA water quality programs maintained delegation. Education funding maintained despite ESA voucher program concerns. No federal funding clawbacks or compliance failures.

Federal Agency State Reviews; CMS Iowa Reviews; EPA Delegation Records

Interstate cooperation

Midwest interstate cooperation maintained. Reynolds participated in multi-state Operation Lone Star border deployments alongside TX, FL, and other GOP governors. Agricultural trade cooperation with Midwest states. EMAC agreements active for disaster mutual aid. Left ERIC voter roll system (Jun 2023) — replacing with SAVE-based verification.

Interstate Compact Records; Midwest Governors' Association; EMAC Records; ERIC Withdrawal Jun 2023

Local government relations

Significant tensions with local governments. SF 481 (2018) preempted cities from adopting sanctuary policies. School districts concerned about ESA voucher program diverting $314M from public schools. Property tax reform (2026) would cap local revenue growth at 2% + new construction — cities and counties resist constraints. Reynolds's property tax plan estimated to save $3B over 6 years but limits local autonomy.

IA League of Cities; School Board Association; SF 481; Property Tax Reform Proposal 2026

Federal litigation costs

Limited federal litigation costs. SF 496 (book restrictions) enjoined by federal judge (Dec 2023) — ACLU lawsuit ongoing. Federal challenges to school mask/vaccine mandate bans settled or dismissed. No major DOJ civil rights investigations. Border deployment costs ($1.93M ARPA) generated political but not legal costs.

IA AG Litigation Reports; Iowa Safe Schools v. Reynolds Federal Case; ACLU Litigation Records

Constituent Service — 10/15 (67%) 5 metrics

Constituent inquiry response

Constituent services maintained through Governor's Office. Reynolds personally engaged with Iowa's 99 counties through regular travel. Constituent inquiry systems functional. Restored felon voting rights (Aug 2020 executive order) directly responding to constituent advocacy. Online child care dashboard created to help families find available slots.

Governor's Office Records; Executive Order on Felon Voting Aug 2020; Child Care Dashboard Launch

Town halls held

Regular public appearances across Iowa's 99 counties. Annual Condition of State address. COVID daily press conferences during peak. However, Reynolds criticized for avoiding hostile town hall formats and preferring controlled events. More national media appearances (Fox News, RNC 2020) than constituent-facing town halls in later tenure.

Governor's Office Schedule; Media Coverage Analysis

Constituent satisfaction

LEAST POPULAR GOVERNOR IN AMERICA for 8 consecutive quarters (Morning Consult Oct-Dec 2025). 43% approval, 49% disapproval — only governor in America 'underwater.' Iowa Poll confirmed record-low approval for Reynolds. Tied with Alaska's Dunleavy for worst disapproval (49%). Won 2022 with 58% but approval collapsed in second term. Announced will not seek third term. Dramatic fall from popular first-term governor to nation's least popular.

Morning Consult Governor Approval Q4 2025; Iowa Poll Sept 2024; NBC News Dec 2025

ADA compliance

Standard ADA compliance maintained. No DOJ ADA enforcement actions against Iowa during Reynolds tenure. Government reorganization preserved disability services under consolidated Iowa Health and Human Services. COVID response criticized by disability advocates for school mask mandate ban (students with disabilities more vulnerable).

IA HHS ADA Reports; DOJ ADA Reviews; Disability Rights Iowa

Electoral accountability

Won 2022 reelection with 58% (706,299 votes) over Democrat Deidre DeJear (40%, 481,399 votes) — 18-point margin, her strongest showing. Succeeded Branstad as Lt. Gov. (May 2017), won first full term 2018. But approval collapsed in second term to nation's worst (43% approval, 49% disapproval). Announced will not seek third term. Dramatic arc: inherited office, won landslide, became least popular governor in America.

IA Secretary of State 2022 Election Results; Morning Consult Q4 2025; NBC News Dec 2025

Section B — State Outcomes 481/975

13 categories measuring real-world outcomes: economic performance, population trends, fiscal health, public safety, education, healthcare, infrastructure, cost of living, transparency, controversy, historical context, constituent satisfaction, and immigration compliance.

Economic Performance — 40/75 (53%)

BLS LAUS: Unemployment 3.1% (among lowest nationally). BEA: GDP $201.1B but declined 0.5% in 2024. GDP per person down 1.2%. Labor force participation 66.3% (well above national average). Manufacturing strong. Agriculture volatile due to commodity prices and trade war impacts. Business tax cuts attractive but revenue impacts concerning.

Population & Demographics — 28/75 (37%)

Census: Iowa population 3.21M (Jul 2024), grew 50,942 (1.6%) since 2020 Census — below national 2.6%. Ranked 30th-32nd in growth. Net domestic migration 2020-2024: -9,482 residents lost to other states. International migration offset: +49,793 international migrants drove nearly all growth. 2024 specifically: net 19,439 international migrants but only net -231 domestic outflow (improving from -3,674 in 2023). Iowa has among highest brain drain rates nationally — young professionals leaving for Sun Belt/coast. 7th most 'outbound' state (Atlas analysis Jan 2026). Rural depopulation ongoing (-2.2/1,000 post-pandemic). Population essentially dependent on immigration: 'Iowa has an economy that needs them' (Daily Iowan Dec 2025). Median age rising — aging population with sluggish birth rates.

Budget & Fiscal Health — 38/75 (51%)

AAA credit rating maintained. Pension ~88-90% funded. Low debt. BUT: massive income tax cuts (8.98% to 3.8%) creating structural revenue shortfall. $605M annual reduction by FY2026. State projected to collect $8.6B vs $9.4B budget. Revenue Estimating Conference reduced projections. Reserves being drawn upon. Fiscal trajectory concerning despite strong starting position.

Public Safety — 45/75 (60%)

Iowa violent crime rate 287/100K — 25% below national average. Rural character contributes to lower crime statewide. Des Moines: violent crime 707/100K — 153% above state mark — person has 1-in-141 chance of violent incident annually. Des Moines 2024 crime rate fell 8% vs 2023; 7% YoY decrease in violent crime per DMPD Director Robinson. 63% of reported aggravated assaults stemmed from domestic disputes or neighborhood tensions (police-community summit finding). Property crime rate 14.41/1K — above national average. Drug issues growing: fentanyl seizures increasing, methamphetamine remains dominant in rural areas. Constitutional carry signed (2021). Iowa DCI maintains crime data. No major police funding controversies under Reynolds.

Education Outcomes — 35/75 (47%)

NAEP: Iowa scores near or slightly above national averages historically. However, voucher program costs ballooning (44% increase to $314M). Concerns about public school funding diversion. SF 496 book/content restrictions face legal and educational criticism. Teacher workforce challenges. Education spending disputes between governor and critics.

Healthcare Access — 38/75 (51%)

Uninsured rate moderate. Medicaid managed care operating. Rural hospital access significant challenge — Iowa is highly rural. Life expectancy near national average. Infant mortality moderate. Mental health services limited in rural areas.

Infrastructure Quality — 38/75 (51%)

FHWA: Iowa roads in moderate condition. Bridges maintained — many rural bridges aging. Rural infrastructure adequate for agricultural state. Broadband expansion improving but rural gaps persist. Derecho (2020) caused massive infrastructure damage.

Cost of Living — 50/75 (67%)

BEA RPP: Iowa below national average (~88-90 RPP). Affordable state. Housing costs moderate — median home well below national average. Income tax cuts improve take-home pay. Good purchasing power. Attractive for cost-conscious households.

Transparency & Accountability — 38/75 (51%)

Iowa Code Chapters 21/22 provide open meetings and open records 'sunshine laws.' Iowa Public Information Board (IPIB) adjudicates disputes. ACLU filed open records lawsuit against Reynolds's office (Apr 2025) after governor invoked 'executive privilege' to withhold documents about Satanic Temple Capitol event cancellation — Iowa Supreme Court allowed lawsuit to proceed. Budget transparency through Department of Management (DOM) website — FY2026 $9.417B budget detailed online. Revenue Estimating Conference projections publicly available. ESA voucher program ($314M by Year 3) criticized for lack of accountability reporting on student outcomes — Iowa State Daily raised transparency concerns. State Auditor Rob Sand (D) operated independently, issuing critical Medicaid reports without interference. data.iowa.gov open data portal functional.

Controversy & Scandal — 25/75 (33%)

LEAST POPULAR GOVERNOR IN AMERICA (Morning Consult, 7+ quarters). Voucher program costs ballooning 44%. SF 496 book/content restrictions highly controversial. COVID response poor approval. Income tax cuts creating revenue shortfall. Meatpacking plant outbreaks during COVID. Mask mandate ban in schools. Approved Moms for Liberty-aligned book ban stance. Population outmigration. Announced no third term under historically low approval.

Historical Context — 30/75 (40%)

Against Iowa's governors: Reynolds enacted largest tax overhaul in state history (8.98% top rate to 3.8% flat rate via SF 2442, May 2024). First female governor of Iowa. Maintained AAA credit rating from all three agencies (reaffirmed Apr 2024). But: LEAST POPULAR GOVERNOR IN AMERICA for 7+ consecutive quarters (Morning Consult: 41% approval, 53% disapproval) — record-low for an Iowa governor. Revenue shortfall from tax cuts ($605M annually by FY2026) may define fiscal legacy. Education policy most divisive in decades: universal ESA vouchers ($314M, costs ballooning 44%), SF 496 book restrictions (partially blocked by federal judge Dec 2023), teacher minimum salary raised to $50K (record). Population stagnation (1.6% vs national 2.6%) while MN, WI grew faster. COVID: never issued shelter-in-place, meatpacking outbreaks killed workers (Tyson Waterloo 38% infection). Government reorganization (37 to 16 agencies) unprecedented. Predecessors: Branstad (R, 2011-2017) longest-serving US governor; Culver (D, 2007-2011) one-term.

Constituent Verdict — 15/75 (20%)

Morning Consult: 41% approval, 53% disapproval — WORST of any US governor for 7+ quarters. Iowa Poll: lowest approval ever recorded. Won 2022 with 58.5% but approval collapsed in second term. Announced no third term. Constituent verdict decisively negative — worst in America by repeated measurement.

Immigration & Law Compliance — 61/75 (81%)

[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Section C — Oath Fidelity +150 (-378 to +378)

126 items scored -3 to +3 measuring fidelity to constitutional oath. Grounded in Supreme Court precedent and constitutional text.

+3Exemplary +2Strong +1Adequate 0Neutral -1Concerning -2Failing -3Hostile

Protection of Life

Declaration of Independence; 5th/14th Amendments

Score: 28 Range: -93 to 93 Items: 31

Violent crime rate trend

IA violent crime rate approximately 280-300 per 100K, below national average. Modest fluctuations during tenure. Generally safe state.

FBI UCR 2023; IA DPS

Homicide rate relative to national average

IA homicide rate approximately 2.5-3.0 per 100K, well below national average. Low murder rate state.

FBI UCR 2023; CDC WONDER

Homicide clearance rate

IA homicide clearance rate adequate. Small caseload allows focused investigation. DCI assists local departments.

FBI UCR; IA DCI

Law enforcement staffing adequacy

IA law enforcement staffing adequate. Some rural recruitment challenges. Standard for Midwest agricultural state.

FBI LEOKA; IA DCI

Drug overdose death rate trend

IA drug overdose death rate approximately 14-16 per 100K, near or slightly below national average. Methamphetamine and fentanyl concerns. Rate relatively stable.

CDC WONDER; IA DPH

Emergency management preparedness (FEMA rating)

IA EMA adequate. Severe weather preparedness strong given tornado/flood exposure. Standard FEMA compliance.

FEMA SPR; IA HSEMD

Preventable mass-casualty event response

Reynolds managed multiple flood and severe weather events. 2020 derecho response was a major test — some criticism of speed but overall response functional. Post-event aid delivered.

FEMA; IA HSEMD; 2020 derecho

Infrastructure safety — bridge and road conditions

IA infrastructure in moderate condition. ASCE grade C. Farm-to-market road system extensive. Some bridge deficiencies. IIJA funding improving.

FHWA NBI; ASCE IA

Water and dam safety compliance

IA water systems generally compliant. Nitrate contamination from agriculture an ongoing concern. Iowa Nutrient Reduction Strategy addressing water quality.

EPA SDWIS; IA DNR

Healthcare access — uninsured rate

IA uninsured rate approximately 5-6%. Below national average. Medicaid managed care provides coverage. Standard access.

Census ACS; KFF

Maternal mortality rate

IA maternal mortality rate moderate, near national average. Some improvement in rural access through telehealth.

CDC WONDER

Infant mortality rate

IA infant mortality rate approximately 5.0-5.5 per 1,000, near national average. Standard programs.

CDC WONDER

Self-defense rights — Castle Doctrine / Stand Your Ground

IA has Castle Doctrine, Stand Your Ground (SF 2300, 2017), and constitutional carry (HF 756, 2021 signed by Reynolds). Civil immunity for lawful self-defense.

IA SF 2300; HF 756; NRA-ILA

Death penalty procedural safeguards

IA does not have death penalty (abolished 1965). LWOP available. Victim services funded. Abolitionist with adequate alternatives.

DPIC; IA Code

Suicide prevention program funding and outcomes

IA suicide rate approximately 15-16 per 100K, slightly above national average. Funded prevention plan. Rural agricultural stress a factor. 988 integration proceeding.

CDC WISQARS; AFSP IA

911/emergency response time adequacy

IA emergency response times adequate. Mix of urban (Des Moines) and rural areas. Standard NFPA compliance where applicable.

NFPA; IA EMS

Opioid/fentanyl interdiction and treatment funding

IA has opioid response programs. Methamphetamine primary concern. Some treatment funding. Standard interdiction on I-80/I-35 corridors.

SAMHSA; IA DPH

Veteran suicide and healthcare access

IA has veteran services through Iowa Veterans Affairs. Camp Dodge supports Guard operations. Standard state veteran programs.

VA SAIL; IA DVA

Food safety and foodborne illness enforcement

IA Department of Inspections food safety adequate. No major outbreaks during tenure.

FDA; IA DIA

Workplace fatality rate

IA workplace fatality rate approximately 4.5-5.0 per 100K FTE due to agriculture. Near national average given farm sector.

BLS CFOI; OSHA

Domestic violence fatality rate and funding

IA has standard domestic violence programs. Rate near national average. Basic services.

NNEDV; IA DV data

Correctional facility death rate and conditions

IA corrections system operates with moderate population. No active DOJ investigations. Standard conditions. Reynolds signed criminal justice reforms.

BJS mortality; IA DOC

Pollution-related mortality and environmental health

IA meets most EPA NAAQS. Agricultural runoff and water quality main environmental concern. Standard compliance.

EPA Green Book; IA DNR

Pedestrian and traffic fatality rate

IA traffic fatality rate approximately 1.2-1.3 per 100M VMT, near national average. Rural road hazards.

NHTSA FARS; IA DOT

Sanctity of life legislative framework

Reynolds signed fetal heartbeat bill (2023), effectively banning abortion after ~6 weeks. Post-Dobbs framework. Clinic safety regulations maintained.

Guttmacher; IA fetal heartbeat law

Homeless mortality — exposure deaths, overdoses in encampments, violence

Relatively low homelessness. Encampment bills introduced but didn't advance. No major crisis. No specific mortality initiatives.

Iowa Capital Dispatch; Iowa Legislature

Population loss impact on services — EMS/hospital closures, tax base erosion

Net domestic loss of 9,500 (2020-2024). Rural decline continues. Population growth only via international immigration (+19,439).

Census Bureau; Iowa Data Center; The Gazette

-1

Police staffing/funding — governor's direct actions on law enforcement

Directed DPS and DOC to cooperate with ICE. Deployed National Guard for ICE. Signed death benefit bills. Consistent law enforcement support.

Iowa Public Radio; KCRG; Governor's press

Criminal recidivism from early release — parole/clemency, no-cash-bail

Standard policies without early release or no-cash-bail. Relatively tough-on-crime posture. No clemency controversies.

Iowa DOC; Governor's statements

Prison/shelter housing — biological males in women's facilities

Gender identity removed from Iowa Civil Rights Act (SF 418). Could reinforce biological sex facility assignments. No direct prison housing policy but indirect support.

Iowa Capital Dispatch; SF 418

Mental health crisis system — involuntary commitment reform, crisis intervention

Major overhaul: signed HF 2673 consolidating 32 mental health regions into 7 unified districts. YSS Ember Recovery Campus: 70 beds (largest public-private mental health investment). Full implementation by July 2026.

Quad City Times; The Gazette; Iowa Public Radio

Constitutional Rights

Bill of Rights (Amendments I-X); 14th Amendment incorporation

Score: 47 Range: -87 to 87 Items: 29

Second Amendment — right to carry status

IA has constitutional carry (HF 756, 2021 signed by Reynolds). No permit required. Strong carry rights.

IA HF 756; USCCA

Second Amendment — semi-automatic rifle restrictions

No restrictions on semi-automatic rifles beyond federal law. No assault weapons ban.

IA Code; ATF

Second Amendment — magazine capacity restrictions

No magazine capacity restrictions in IA.

IA statutes; NRA-ILA

Second Amendment — Red Flag / ERPO due process

IA has no ERPO/red flag law. Relies on existing due process mechanisms.

IA statutes; ERPO tracker

First Amendment — campus free speech protections

Reynolds signed campus intellectual diversity/free speech legislation (SF 274, 2023) protecting expression at public universities. Banned DEI offices at regent institutions.

SF 274; FIRE; DEI ban

First Amendment — anti-SLAPP protections

IA has limited anti-SLAPP protections. No comprehensive statute.

Public Participation Project

First Amendment — religious liberty protections

IA has no formal state RFRA but strong religious liberty culture. No documented restrictions. Religious organizations generally protected.

Becket Fund; IA law

Fourth Amendment — warrant requirements for digital surveillance

IA relies primarily on federal Carpenter standard. No comprehensive state electronic privacy statute.

EFF; IA statutes

Fourth Amendment — civil asset forfeiture reform

IA has some civil asset forfeiture reform. Conviction required for amounts under $5,000. Moderate protections.

Institute for Justice; IA Code

Fifth Amendment — eminent domain protections post-Kelo

IA has some post-Kelo reform. HF 2351 (2006) restricting economic development takings.

Castle Coalition; IA HF 2351

Due process — regulatory takings and permitting timelines

IA permitting generally efficient. Low regulatory burden state. Standard processing.

IA permitting data

Tenth Amendment — federal overreach resistance

Reynolds joined multistate litigation on immigration, EPA, and federal mandates. Signed laws resisting federal overreach. Active 10th Amendment posture.

Multistate litigation; IA AG

Equal Protection — state contracting nondiscrimination

Reynolds signed ban on DEI in state university hiring/admissions — SFFA-compliant race-neutral approach. Proactive nondiscrimination enforcement.

SF 274; SFFA compliance

Second Amendment — state preemption of local firearms laws

IA has state preemption of local firearms laws. Effective preemption.

IA Code Ã‚Â§724.28; NRA-ILA

First Amendment — government transparency and FOIA compliance

IA has public records law. Standard FOIA compliance. Some transparency improvements needed.

RCFP; IA open records

Sixth Amendment — public defender funding adequacy

IA public defender system faces resource constraints. Caseloads above recommended levels. Standard funding.

Sixth Amendment Center

Eighth Amendment — bail reform and pretrial detention

IA bail system standard with some reform elements. Cash bail predominates with risk assessment.

Pretrial Justice Institute; IA courts

Property rights — regulatory burden and economic freedom

IA enacted massive tax reform — flat 3.8% income tax (from 8.98% top rate). Bottom quartile regulatory burden with reform. Strong economic freedom.

Mercatus; CATO; IA tax reform

Second Amendment — governor's litigation posture on firearms cases

IA AG generally supports 2A. Filed pro-2A amicus briefs in federal cases. Supportive posture.

IA AG litigation

First Amendment — compelled speech protections

Reynolds signed anti-compelled speech measures including ban on mandatory DEI statements in university hiring. No compelled speech in state operations.

SF 274; FIRE

Commerce Clause compliance — interstate trade barriers

IA has reasonable interstate commerce environment. Standard reciprocity.

IJ; IA reciprocity

Privileges and Immunities — occupational licensing reform

IA has moderate occupational licensing reform. Some progress on universal recognition.

IJ License to Work

Contract Clause — state compliance with contractual obligations

IPERS funded ratio 90.75% (FY2024) — highest since FY2002, 11th best nationally. AAA credit rating. Strong contractual compliance.

IPERS FY2024; S&P/Moody's/Fitch

Jury trial rights — civil and criminal jury access

Standard jury trial access in IA. No significant issues.

IA court reports

Immigration law compliance — Supremacy Clause adherence

Reynolds signed SF 2340 (2024) — comprehensive immigration enforcement bill allowing state law enforcement to arrest/detain illegal aliens with prior deportation orders. E-Verify for state agencies. Anti-sanctuary posture.

SF 2340; 8 USC Ã‚Â§1373; FAIR

Qualified immunity / due process for officers

Maintains qualified immunity. Consistently expressed strong law enforcement support. No legislation to strip QI.

Iowa state law; Governor's statements

Voter ID and ballot chain-of-custody

Eliminated ballot harvesting, required absentee arrival by Election Day, prohibited auditors from proactively mailing forms. Voter ID at polls and on absentee requests. Signed 2025 recount reform and citizenship verification. Banned RCV.

Heritage Foundation; PBS; Iowa Capital Dispatch; KCRG

Non-citizen voting prevention

Signed HF 954 enabling SoS to contract for citizenship verification. Supported SoS Pate challenging 2,176 ballots. Iowa settled lawsuit for citizenship data access. Multi-layered approach.

Iowa Capital Dispatch; CBS2 Iowa; Governor's press

Women's sports / Title IX — biological sex protections in state-funded athletics

Signed HF 2416 banning transgender athletes K-12 and college. Signed SF 418 removing gender identity from Civil Rights Act — first state. Attended Trump's EO signing on women's sports.

Athletic Business; Iowa Torch; CNN; Yahoo

Child Welfare & Parental Rights

Meyer v. Nebraska (1923); Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925); Troxel v. Granville (2000)

Score: 24 Range: -75 to 75 Items: 25

Parental rights legislation — statutory recognition

Reynolds signed parental rights legislation embedded in education reforms. Parents have right to curriculum review, opt-out. Strong parental authority emphasis.

IA education code; parental rights

Education choice — school choice programs

Reynolds signed universal ESA (Students First Act, SF 2369, 2023) — all K-12 students eligible for $7,598 education savings account. Strongest school choice program nationally. Fully universal.

SF 2369; EdChoice IA

Parental notification/consent for medical procedures on minors

IA requires parental consent for abortion (minors) and medical procedures. Standard framework with judicial bypass.

Guttmacher; IA Code

Gender-transition procedures for minors — restrictions

Reynolds signed SF 538 (2023) banning gender-transition surgeries and most medical interventions for minors. Includes restrictions on school concealment of gender transition.

SF 538; Reuters tracker

Child abuse and neglect — substantiated case rate trend

IA child abuse rate near national average. DHS handles investigations. Standard system.

ACF NCANDS; IA DHS

Foster care — CFSR conformity assessment

IA CFSR performance mixed. Standard improvement plans in place.

ACF CFSR; IA DHS

Foster care — permanency outcomes

IA foster care permanency outcomes average. Standard system.

ACF AFCARS; IA DHS

Child trafficking prevention and prosecution

IA has trafficking statute and task force. AG enforcement. Standard capacity.

Polaris; Shared Hope; IA AG

Education outcomes — 4th grade NAEP reading proficiency

IA NAEP 4th grade reading approximately 33-35% proficient, near to above national average.

NCES NAEP 2024

Education outcomes — 8th grade NAEP math proficiency

IA NAEP 8th grade math approximately 30-33% proficient, above national average.

NCES NAEP 2024

Parental curriculum transparency

Reynolds signed curriculum transparency legislation. Parents have statutory right to review curriculum materials and opt out of objectionable content.

IA education code; Reynolds legislation

Social media — minor protections

IA has limited social media protections for minors beyond federal COPPA.

NCSL tracker

Juvenile justice — age-appropriate treatment

IA juvenile jurisdiction to 18. Standard transfer provisions. Some rehabilitation programs.

OJJDP IA

Child poverty rate and state response

IA child poverty rate approximately 12-14%, below national average. Agricultural economy provides stability.

Census ACS SAIPE; KIDS COUNT

Adoption and permanency — adoptive family support

Standard adoption framework in IA. Subsidized adoption available.

ACF AFCARS; IA DHS

Homeschool rights and protections

IA has moderate homeschool regulation. Notification required with optional assessment. No mandatory curriculum. Diploma recognition.

HSLDA IA; IA Code

Child sexual abuse material (CSAM) enforcement

IA ICAC task force operational. AG prosecution active. Standard capacity.

ICAC; IA AG

School safety — violence prevention and incident response

IA has school safety programs. SRO availability. Standard framework.

NASRO; IA DOE

Children's mental health services access

IA school counselor ratio moderate. Average children's mental health services access.

ASCA; SAMHSA IA

Childhood vaccination — parental choice protections

IA allows religious and medical exemptions for vaccination. No philosophical exemption. Standard framework.

NCSL; IA Code

Child care affordability and access

IA child care affordability moderate. Some subsidy programs. Rural access challenges.

ACF CCDF

Education — teacher quality and retention

IA teacher salaries near national average. Some recruitment challenges. ESA expansion may affect teacher market.

NCES; NEA; IA DOE

Child nutrition — food insecurity rate

IA child food insecurity below national average. School meal programs operational. Agricultural state with food access.

USDA ERS; Feeding America

Custody and family court — due process in child removal

IA has standard due process in family court. Santosky-compliant.

IA Code; ABA

Children with disabilities — IDEA compliance

IA IDEA compliance standard. Most districts compliant.

OSEP; IA DOE

Faithful Discharge of Duties

Gubernatorial oath; Art. IV Sec. 4; state constitutional requirements

Score: 51 Range: -123 to 123 Items: 41

Budget balance — structural surplus/deficit

IA budgets balanced but revenue shortfall emerging from massive tax cut. $8.6B revenue vs $9.4B spending. Taxpayer Relief Fund bridging gap. Structural concern.

IA DFM; NASBO

State credit rating stability

IA maintains AAA/Aaa/AAA from all three agencies. Reaffirmed April 2024. Strong fiscal reputation.

S&P; Moody's; Fitch April 2024

Rainy day / budget stabilization fund adequacy

Reserves over $900M rainy day fund plus $2.74B Taxpayer Relief Fund. Strong but Taxpayer Relief Fund being drawn down for tax cut transition.

IA Treasurer; Pew

Pension system funding responsibility

IPERS funded ratio 90.75% (FY2024) — 11th best nationally. Making full ARC. Strong pension management.

IPERS FY2024; NASRA

State debt burden

IA debt per capita ~$1,960, ranked ~40th nationally. Low debt consistent with AAA rating. Conservative debt management.

IA Treasurer; Census

Government efficiency — state employee headcount per capita

Standard government efficiency. No major headcount changes. Moderate employee per capita.

Census Public Employment

Inspector General / state auditor independence

IA State Auditor Rob Sand (D) operates independently. Active oversight including $26M Test Iowa review. Reynolds cooperated despite political tension.

IA Auditor; ALGA

Ethics violations and personal scandals

Reynolds has had some controversy over $26M Test Iowa COVID testing contract and pandemic management but no formal ethics violations. Financial disclosure compliant.

IA Ethics Commission

Executive order restraint

Reynolds used executive orders during COVID, drawing some criticism. Post-COVID EO usage standard. Special session called rather than governing by EO.

IA EO records

Emergency powers — adherence to statutory limits

Extended COVID emergency orders. Faced some criticism but eventually terminated. IA Legislature enacted limits on future emergency powers. Moderate concerns.

IA emergency statutes

Legislative cooperation — veto override rate

Low veto override rate. Works with Republican trifecta effectively. Productive legislative relationship achieving major policy agenda.

IA Legislature records

Judicial appointments — qualifications and process integrity

Standard judicial appointments through merit-based process. No unqualified appointees. Criticized nomination commission but process functional.

IA judicial records

Timely execution of laws — implementation of enacted legislation

Strong implementation: universal ESA, tax reform, immigration enforcement, campus reform all implemented on schedule.

IA agency reports

Federal fund utilization — grant management

Federal grants managed well. $533M broadband grants distributed. ARPA funds deployed. No major clawbacks.

Federal Audit Clearinghouse; USASpending

Public approval as competence indicator

Reynolds approval approximately 52-57%. Won 2022 reelection by 19 points. Generally well-regarded among Republicans.

Morning Consult; IA polls

State IT security and data protection

Standard IT security. No major breaches. Basic cybersecurity framework.

NASCIO; IA IT

Infrastructure spending — capital budget execution

Capital budget execution standard. Infrastructure in moderate condition. Some project delivery challenges.

ASCE IA; IA DOT

Disaster fund readiness

IA has adequate disaster reserves. Combined reserves provide buffer. FEMA cost-share met for flood/storm events.

FEMA; IA HSEMD

Workforce development — unemployment system integrity

IA UI system functional. Low unemployment. Trust fund adequate. Standard processing.

DOL UI; IA IWD

Medicaid program integrity

IA Medicaid managed care program. Standard PERM compliance. Reynolds proposed work requirements.

CMS; IA Medicaid

Election administration — constitutional compliance

IA has voter ID requirement (SF 413, 2017 signed by Reynolds). Paper ballots. Standard election security.

SF 413; IA SOS

Transparency — state budget accessibility

IA has basic budget transparency portal. Standard government transparency.

U.S. PIRG; IA open data

Intergovernmental cooperation — federal compliance balanced with sovereignty

Cooperative with federal enforcement. SF 2340 immigration enforcement demonstrates strong federal compliance. Balanced sovereignty posture.

Federal compliance; SF 2340

Gubernatorial succession and continuity planning

IA has Lt. Governor (Adam Gregg). Clear succession. COOP plan exists.

IA Constitution; succession

Anti-corruption — state procurement integrity

Standard procurement controls. No major corruption findings. Auditor oversight functional.

IA procurement; Auditor reports

Gas price burden — state gas taxes, refinery regulations, cap-and-trade

Gas tax ~30 cents/gallon, moderate. Flat income tax to 3.8% offsets fuel costs. In-state ethanol/biofuel benefits. No cap-and-trade.

SalesTaxHandbook; Tax Foundation

Energy affordability — residential electricity costs from state policy

Top 10 lowest electricity costs. Average bill $114/month vs $147 national. 62% wind energy provides low-cost generation. High reliability.

Electric Choice; EIA; Governor's Condition of State

Energy policy competence — forced mandates without infrastructure readiness

62% wind, 22% coal, 12% natural gas — diverse reliable mix. Nuclear task force. No forced EV mandates. Grid reliability top 10 nationally.

EIA Iowa; Governor's energy statements

Property tax burden — effective rate vs national median

Property taxes rising faster than inflation/paychecks per Reynolds herself. Made it final legislative priority. Unveiled 2026 proposal. No enacted reform yet.

Iowa Capital Dispatch; Governor's Condition of State

Regulatory cost burden — permits, compliance costs per household/business

EO 10 rulemaking moratorium. Government Regulation Review with 5-year sunset. UI reform saves businesses $1B over 5 years. SF 603 bars extra local mandates.

Governor's EO 10; Iowa Capital Dispatch; SF 603

Unfunded mandates on municipalities

SF 603 bars local unfunded requirements on contractors. Regulatory moratorium prevents new mandates. Broader deregulatory posture limits state costs on municipalities.

SF 603; EO 10

Cost of living trajectory — policy-driven affordability trend

Below national average cost of living. Income tax to flat 3.8%. UI reform reduces business costs. Low energy costs. But property taxes rising.

Tax Foundation; BLS; Governor's tax reform

Immigration fiscal burden — taxpayer cost of sanctuary/benefits policies

Created state 'illegal reentry' crime with 2-year penalty. All law enforcement ICE cooperation. National Guard deployed. E-Verify EO. Immigration license verification.

Iowa Public Radio; KCRG; Governor's press

Homelessness spending accountability — spending vs measurable outcomes

Relatively low homelessness. Encampment bills didn't pass. No significant spending to evaluate.

Iowa Capital Dispatch

Encampment enforcement — response to SCOTUS Grants Pass ruling

Bills to criminalize camping failed to advance. Neither enacted nor rejected — stalled. Reynolds hasn't publicly championed enforcement.

Iowa Capital Dispatch

Net domestic migration trend — people leaving vs arriving

Net domestic loss of 9,500 (2020-2024). Iowa lost 231 net in 2023-2024, ranked 29th. Surrounding states gained while Iowa lost.

Census Bureau; The Gazette; Atlas Van Lines

-1

Business exodus — corporate HQ and jobs relocating due to policy

No major business exodus but no standout attraction. Stable but not a magnet for relocations. Record low unemployment from tight labor.

Iowa Economic Development; general press

DA accountability — governor's power to remove rogue prosecutors

No DA accountability actions. County attorney system independent. No rogue prosecutor conflicts.

General policy review

Election infrastructure — ballot harvesting, drop box security, audit transparency

Ballot harvesting banned, voter ID with database verification, absentee deadline tightened, auditors barred from mailing forms, citizenship verification, RCV banned, recount reformed. Most robust nationally.

Heritage Foundation; PBS; Iowa Capital Dispatch; KCRG

Weaponization of state agencies — using AG/regulatory bodies against political opponents

ACLU sued over excessive executive privilege on records. Condemned UofI employee who defied DEI law, raising proportionality questions.

Iowa Capital Dispatch; The Gazette

-1

Foreign adversary protections — Chinese land, TikTok bans, Confucius Institutes

Banned TikTok on state devices (Dec 2022). Banned Chinese AI (DeepSeek) and social media from state agencies. Signed foreign farmland ownership law with AG subpoena power.

KCRG; Iowa Capital Dispatch; Governor's press

← #15 Phil Scott All Rankings Henry McMaster #17 →