Skip to content
Greg Gianforte
57.4%
#7 of 50

Greg Gianforte

Montana R | 2nd term
2021-01-04Took Office 5 yrs, 5 moIn Office 263Metrics Scored 948 / 1653Total Points

Section A: Governance

216/300
72%

Section B: State Outcomes

582/975
60%

Section C: Oath Fidelity

+150 (-378 to +378)

Section A — Governance 216/300

9 subsections evaluating executive performance: budget execution, legislative relations, appointments, emergency management, transparency, ethics, program management, federal relations, and constituent service.

On-time budget submission
Biennial budgets submitted on time each cycle. FY2025 'Path to Security and Prosperity' budget delivered Nov 2024 with detailed priorities — income tax cuts, property tax relief, $100M public safety, $100M teacher pay (STARS Act). FY2023 budget also on time with debt-payoff and tax-cut agenda.
MT Governor's Office budget documents; news.mt.gov; Daily Montanan Nov 2024
3
Budget accuracy — revenue forecast vs actual
Revenue forecasts generally accurate but challenged by post-COVID volatility. Revenue surpluses enabled debt payoff and three rounds of tax cuts. FY2027 budget ends biennium with $311M in general fund reserves, though expenditures projected to exceed revenues by 2028.
MT Legislative Fiscal Division; Daily Montanan Jun 2025
2
Rainy day fund management
EXCEPTIONAL. Signed HB 251 making Montana debt-free in 2023, saving taxpayers $40M in principal and interest on general obligation bonds. From debt-funded to debt-free — among very few states nationally. $300M in one-time-only funding directed to pension stabilization in FY2027 budget.
MT Governor's Office press release 2023; HB 251; MT State Treasurer
3
State credit rating trajectory
Moody's rates Montana Aa1 — one step below Aaa. Moody's grades MT at Aaa on financial performance; only pension liability prevents overall Aaa. Available funds balance at 87.7% of own-source revenue vs 50-state median of 44.4%. Debt-free status among strongest fiscal positions nationally.
Moody's Investors Service — Montana; Frontier Institute analysis
3
Pension funding ratio trajectory
Montana PERS funded ratio at 74.48% (FY2025 actuarial valuation) with 23-year amortization period. TRS funded ratio at 74.26% (July 2024) with 21-year amortization, improved from 24 years prior. $300M one-time pension stabilization in FY2027 budget to accelerate improvement.
MPERA FY2025 Actuarial Report; TRS July 2024 Valuation; HB 2 (2025)
2
Debt per capita trajectory
DEBT-FREE since 2023. HB 251 paid off all general obligation debt, saving $40M. GO bond debt per capita went to zero. Montana is among very few states to achieve this. Simultaneous $100M invested in road and bridge infrastructure from freed-up funds.
MT State Treasurer; Governor's Office 2023; HB 251
3
CAFR/ACFR published on time
State ACFR published by Department of Administration, State Financial Services Division within standard deadlines. FY2023 Single Audit issued Aug 19, 2024. Some agency-level audit delays noted — Secretary of State's office received adverse opinion for FY2023 financial statements.
MT SABHRS; State Controller; Legislative Audit Division Report 24-18
2
Audit findings — material weaknesses
No major material weaknesses in core executive branch agencies. Two material weaknesses identified in FY2023/2024 statewide audit related to financial reporting processes. Secretary of State office (elected, not governor's appointee) had adverse audit opinion. Executive branch agencies clean.
MT Legislative Audit Division Reports 24-01, 24-18
3
Federal grant fund accounting
No major federal grant accounting deficiencies in Single Audit. Montana received ~$6.3B in federal funds (FY2023). Small state with manageable oversight burden. ARPA funds properly administered through established disbursement processes.
MT Legislative Audit Division Single Audit; USASpending.gov
3
Anti-fraud controls — federal programs
No major fraud findings in federal programs. Legislative Audit Division operates independently with ACT (Accountability, Compliance, and Transparency) hotline for reporting. Small state population (1.1M) and close oversight culture facilitate detection. No DOL OIG findings.
MT Legislative Audit Division ACT Hotline; DOL OIG
3
Tax revenue vs expenditure alignment
Currently in surplus — FY2027 biennium ends with $311M general fund reserves. Three income tax cuts totaling $278M/yr (latest HB 337, signed Apr 2025). Top rate reduced from 6.9% to 5.65% (2026), then 5.4% (2027). Property tax cuts ($500 rebate via HB 222). Alignment risk: expenditures projected to exceed revenue by 2028.
MT Legislative Fiscal Division; Daily Montanan Jun 2025; HB 337
2
Capital budget execution rate
$100M invested in road and bridge repairs after debt payoff (2023). $156M Montana State Prison expansion (HB 817, groundbreaking Apr 2025). $436M total corrections capacity funding in 2025 session. $629M BEAD broadband allocation secured — first state to open application portal.
MT DOT; Governor's Office; HB 817; ConnectMT BEAD program
2
Vendor/contractor oversight
No vendor oversight scandals or procurement fraud. Department of Administration procurement processes functioning. Red Tape Relief initiative (EO Jan 2021) reviewed and streamlined 1,866 regulations across 13 agencies, including procurement rules, without compromising integrity controls.
MT Department of Administration procurement; Red Tape Relief Task Force
3
Federal funding maximization
Montana secured $629M BEAD broadband allocation (among first states to apply). $65M FHWA emergency highway funds for 2022 Yellowstone flooding. FEMA DR-4655 disaster declaration for 6 counties. IIJA formula funds captured for highways, bridges, water. Total federal receipts ~$6.3B annually.
USASpending.gov; FEMA DR-4655; NTIA BEAD; FHWA
2
Program eligibility verification systems
DPHHS uses SAVE system for immigration status verification on public benefits. Medicaid expansion covering ~75,000 low-income Montanans (HB 245, signed Mar 2025, made permanent). Centralized intake system processed ~34,400 calls in SFY2023 with proper documentation protocols.
MT DPHHS; DHS SAVE Program; HB 245; CFSD intake data
2
Signature legislation enacted
Extraordinarily productive. Three income tax cuts (top rate 6.9% to 5.4% by 2027, HB 337). HB 251 made MT debt-free. HB 222 $500 property tax rebate. SB 542 cut homeowner property taxes 15%, small business 18%. Constitutional carry (HB 102, 2021). SB 99 banned trans procedures for minors. STARS Act ($100M teacher pay). 100,000+ acres public land access.
MT Legislature records; Governor's Office; HB 337; HB 251; STARS Act
3
Veto override rate
Used veto judiciously. FY2027 budget signed with $31M in line-item vetoes plus 6 standalone bills vetoed ($22M). Vetoed HB 271 (transparency bill) — controversial. Republican supermajority generally aligned, making overrides unnecessary. No significant override pattern.
MT Legislature Journal; Daily Montanan Jun 2025
2
Bipartisan bills signed
Some bipartisan legislation. Housing reform package ('Montana Miracle') earned national praise for bipartisan zoning reform — SB 382 (Land Use Planning Act), SB 528 (ADUs), SB 245 (urban infill). Medicaid expansion renewed with bipartisan support (HB 245). CSKT water compact support as congressman.
MT Legislature vote records; American Planning Association; Mercatus Center
2
Special sessions called
No special sessions called during tenure. Montana legislature meets biennially (odd years), and Gianforte managed legislative agenda within regular sessions. Biennial schedule limits special session temptation compared to annual legislatures.
MT Legislature records; MT Constitution Art. V §6
3
Executive orders — legal challenges
No major EO legal challenges. EO 12-2021 (wildfire state of emergency, Jul 2021) mobilized National Guard without legal challenge. Red Tape Relief EO (Jan 5, 2021) created advisory council — implemented without litigation. No court injunctions against executive orders.
MT Governor's executive orders; court records
3
Line-item veto usage
Active line-item veto user. FY2027 budget (HB 2): exercised $31M in line-item vetoes, targeting items he deemed wasteful while preserving core budget. Vetoed 6 additional standalone appropriation bills totaling $22M. Constitutional authority exercised within norms.
MT Constitution Art. VI §10; Governor's signing statements 2025
2
Regulatory burden change
SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION. Red Tape Relief Task Force (EO Jan 2021, Lt. Gov. Juras chair) repealed or amended 1,866 of 11,753 regulations (16% reduction). Produced 188 bills, 170 passed into law. 1,114 net regulatory restrictions eliminated. Celebrated 25% amendment/repeal milestone Feb 2025. Conservation groups critical of environmental deregulation.
MT Red Tape Relief Task Force; Mountain States Policy Center Feb 2025
2
Budget negotiation success
Biennial budgets passed cooperatively with Republican-majority legislature. FY2023 budget included debt payoff and first tax cut round. FY2025 budget at $16.6B passed with minimal friction. FY2027 budget signed Jun 2025 with only targeted line-item vetoes — core priorities preserved.
MT Legislature budget records; Daily Montanan Jun 2025
2
Bill signing rate on popular legislation
Tax cuts broadly popular — 80% of homeowners saw property tax reduction under SB 542. Income tax cuts benefit all brackets. Recreational marijuana implementation (HB 701, May 2021) honored I-190 voter approval (57%). STARS Act ($100M teacher pay) popular with education community. Housing reforms bipartisan.
MT Legislature records; MT Department of Revenue; I-190 results
2
Legislative relationship
Strong relationship with Republican supermajority. Some intra-party tension on housing (conservatives vs. zoning reformers) and Medicaid expansion. Budget negotiations productive — $16.6B FY2027 budget passed with broad support. Governor's legislative agenda success rate high across three sessions (2021, 2023, 2025).
MT Legislature records; Montana Free Press session coverage
2
Implementation of voter-approved measures
Signed HB 701 (May 2021) implementing I-190 recreational marijuana (57% voter approval). First legal sales Jan 2022. 20% tax on sales with $6M/yr directed to HEART Fund (mental health/substance abuse). Established licensing framework — existing medical providers first, broader licensing Jul 2023.
MT Secretary of State; HB 701; I-190; MT Department of Revenue
2
Task force follow-through
Red Tape Relief Task Force delivered 1,866 regulations amended/repealed. Housing Task Force extended (2023) and produced bipartisan 'Montana Miracle' zoning reform bills. Debt payoff completed per plan. Income tax cuts phased in across three sessions as promised. STARS Act teacher pay deployed.
MT Governor's Office; Red Tape Relief results; Housing Task Force
2
Policy reversals under pressure
No major policy reversals. Maintained course on tax cuts, regulatory reform, and public lands access across 5+ years. Signed Medicaid expansion renewal (HB 245) despite conservative base skepticism — pragmatic but not a reversal. Consistent ideological direction throughout tenure.
MT Governor's Office public statements; legislative record 2021-2025
3
Appointee criminal/ethics issues
No criminal or ethics issues with cabinet appointees. Key appointments: Adam Meier (DPHHS, fmr Kentucky CHFS secretary), Chris Dorrington (DEQ, career DEQ veteran since 2016), Kevin Gilbertson (CIO). No scandals, resignations under pressure, or criminal referrals among appointees.
MT ethics records; Governor's appointment announcements
3
Agency head vacancy rate
Agency positions filled promptly upon taking office Jan 2021. Cabinet completed within first month — DPHHS (Meier), DEQ (Dorrington), DNRC, Labor. DPHHS director transitioned mid-term (Meier to DOA, replacement named) — orderly succession. No prolonged vacancies in key positions.
MT Governor's Office appointment records; Montana Free Press Jan 2021
2
State employee turnover
Montana faces statewide workforce shortages — 33,000 job openings (Apr 2024). ~20% of state workforce expected to retire within 10 years. Addressed with pay plan: $1.50/hr or 4% raises (2024-2025), plus $1,040 bonus. 2025-2026 plan: $1/hr or 2.5% raises. Competitive pressure from private sector in Bozeman/Missoula.
MT Department of Administration HR; BLS JOLTS Montana Apr 2024
2
Diversity of appointments
Montana is 89% white per Census. Limited demographic diversity in appointments. Native Americans are 6.7% of population and 7 reservations in state — representation in relevant agencies (DPHHS, DNRC) important but not prominently prioritized. No public diversity hiring initiative announced.
MT Governor's Office records; U.S. Census ACS 2023; MT Indian Affairs
1
Judicial appointment quality
Montana uses nonpartisan judicial elections for most judges. Governor fills vacancies by appointment from Judicial Nomination Commission list. Appointments made from qualified candidate pools. No complaints from State Bar about appointment quality. No appointee removals or disciplinary actions.
MT State Bar; Judicial Nomination Commission; MT Constitution Art. VII
2
State workforce pay competitiveness
Signed state employee pay plans: FY2024-2025 ($1.50/hr or 4% raises, plus $1,040 one-time bonus). FY2026-2027 ($1/hr or 2.5% raises). STARS Act invested $100M to raise starting teacher pay — 4.2% raise FY2026, 3% raise FY2027, plus $1,500 cost-of-living stipend. Housing costs in western MT undermine competitiveness.
MT Department of Administration; STARS Act; Montana Free Press Apr 2023
2
Whistleblower protection
No reported whistleblower retaliation cases. Montana Wrongful Discharge from Employment Act provides protections. Legislative Audit Division ACT hotline operates for anonymous reporting. However, 'gubernatorial privilege' records claims could chill internal dissent — no specific whistleblower complaints filed.
MT Wrongful Discharge Act; Legislative Audit Division ACT hotline
2
Inspector General independence
Montana has no IG office — oversight via Legislative Audit Division (LAD), which reports to legislature, not governor. LAD operating independently throughout tenure. Published critical audits (Secretary of State adverse opinion FY2023) without executive interference. Structural independence maintained.
MT Legislative Audit Division; MT Constitution Art. VI §10
2
State employee morale
No reported morale crisis. Pay raises (4% in FY2024-2025, 2.5% in FY2026-2027) address compensation concerns. MFPE and AFSCME unions cooperated on 2023 pay plan — bipartisan announcement with governor. Workforce shortages (20% retiring in 10 years) create stress but not attributed to mismanagement.
MT Department of Administration; MFPE/AFSCME pay plan announcement 2023
2
Nepotism/cronyism
No documented nepotism. Cabinet appointments drawn from qualified professionals — Meier (Kentucky health official), Dorrington (career DEQ), Gilbertson (IT professional). Gianforte placed personal businesses in blind trust upon taking office. No family members in state positions.
MT ethics records; financial disclosure; appointment records
3
Senior staff criminal charges
No criminal charges against any senior staff or cabinet members during 5+ years in office. No staff arrests, indictments, or criminal investigations. Clean record for executive branch personnel across three legislative sessions and two terms.
Court records; MT ethics records 2021-2026
3
Agency performance accountability
Red Tape Relief Task Force required 13 agencies to identify and eliminate unnecessary regulations — 1,866 amended/repealed. DPHHS delivered Medicaid expansion to 75,000 enrollees. DOT executed $100M road/bridge program. STARS Act $100M deployed to schools. Performance targets met on key priorities.
MT Governor's Office; Red Tape Relief results; DPHHS; DOT
2
Disaster declaration timeliness
Issued wildfire state of emergency Jul 14, 2021 (EO 12-2021) as 1,400+ fires burned 141,000+ acres. Declared flood disaster Jun 14, 2022 for historic Yellowstone flooding. Secured federal disaster declaration (DR-4655) from President Biden by Jun 16, 2022 — just 2 days after state declaration for Park, Stillwater, Carbon counties.
MT Disaster and Emergency Services; FEMA DR-4655; EO 12-2021
2
FEMA Public Assistance secured
Secured FEMA DR-4655 for 2022 Yellowstone flooding — initially 3 counties, expanded to 6 (Park, Stillwater, Carbon, Yellowstone, Treasure, Sweet Grass). Activated Individual Assistance, crisis counseling, disaster unemployment, legal services. $65M FHWA emergency highway funds secured for road/bridge damage. Wildfire FEMA assistance also obtained.
FEMA DR-4655; FHWA emergency funds; MT Governor's Office
2
Emergency reserve adequacy
Debt-free status since 2023 provides maximum fiscal flexibility. $311M projected general fund reserves at end of FY2027 biennium. Moody's available funds balance at 87.7% of own-source revenue (50-state median: 44.4%). $100M local disaster relief fund in FY2027 budget specifically for emergency response.
MT State Treasurer; Moody's; HB 2 (2025) budget
3
Lives lost — preventable from state failure
No preventable deaths from state infrastructure or response failures. 2022 Yellowstone flooding (Jun 10-Jul 5, 2022) was historic — 115 homes destroyed/severely damaged, some washed away — but no deaths attributed to delayed state response. 2021 wildfire evacuations (Denton, Red Lodge) conducted without fatalities.
MT Disaster and Emergency Services; FEMA DR-4655 damage reports
3
Post-disaster recovery
2022 Yellowstone flooding recovery ongoing — 115 homes destroyed/damaged, 6 counties in disaster zone. $65M FHWA funds for highway repairs. FEMA Individual Assistance activated for affected families. Wildfire recovery from 2021 season ($13M+ state cost) proceeding. Road repairs in Yellowstone NP corridor completed.
FEMA DR-4655; FHWA; MT DOT; United Policyholders
2
Public health emergency response
Inherited COVID pandemic — Montana had relatively early reopening under predecessor Bullock's late-2020 orders. Gianforte continued open approach. DPHHS under Meier (fmr Kentucky health official) managed vaccine rollout and public health operations. COVID death rate moderate for rural state. HEART Fund ($6M/yr from marijuana tax) supports mental health.
MT DPHHS; CDC COVID Data Tracker; HB 701 HEART Fund
2
Infrastructure failure prevention
$100M invested in road and bridge repairs after debt payoff (2023). $156M Montana State Prison infrastructure upgrade (HB 817). No catastrophic infrastructure failures (dam breaks, bridge collapses, water system failures). DOT maintaining 75,000+ lane-miles of highways across 4th largest state by area.
MT DOT; Governor's Office; HB 817
2
National Guard deployment appropriateness
National Guard mobilized for 2021 wildfire season via EO 12-2021 — appropriate use for fire suppression. Secured mutual aid from Utah and California through Emergency Management Assistance Compact (EMAC). Guard support for 2022 Yellowstone flooding response. No controversial or politically motivated deployments.
MT National Guard; EO 12-2021; EMAC records
2
Emergency communication
Launched state fire dashboard for real-time wildfire information during 2021 fire season. Emergency communications effective during 2022 Yellowstone flooding — evacuations of Gardiner, Red Lodge area executed successfully. $629M BEAD broadband allocation will improve rural emergency communications infrastructure long-term.
MT DES; Governor's Office fire dashboard; ConnectMT BEAD
3
Interagency coordination
Multi-agency coordination for 2022 Yellowstone flooding involved DES, DOT, DNRC, NPS, FEMA, and tribal authorities. Wildfire response coordinated state (DNRC), federal (USFS), and tribal (Richard Spring Fire on reservation) agencies. Met with President Biden on forest management and wildfire strategy. EMAC mutual aid activated with multiple states.
MT DES; DNRC; FEMA; Governor-Biden wildfire meeting
2
Pandemic response metrics
Montana COVID deaths: ~3,700 total (through 2023). Low population density (7.5/sq mi) was protective. Relatively early reopening approach. Vaccination rates moderate for rural state (~55% fully vaccinated). DPHHS managed transition from emergency to endemic operations. No major public health system failures.
CDC COVID Data Tracker — Montana; MT DPHHS
2
Disaster preparedness & emergency infrastructure
DNRC forest management and wildfire mitigation funded — Gianforte pressed for 'extinguish all fires' approach in 2022 briefing, prioritizing aggressive initial response. 1,400+ fires in 2021 (141,000+ acres, 78% human-caused). Emergency infrastructure maintained but vast rural geography (147,000 sq mi) creates persistent gaps in communications coverage.
MT DES; MT DNRC; Governor's 2022 wildfire briefing
2
FOIA/open records compliance
MAJOR TRANSPARENCY FAILURE. Claimed unprecedented 'gubernatorial privilege' to withhold Agency Bill Monitoring Forms showing positions on legislation. Two landmark lawsuits: O'Neill v. Gianforte (records on bill positions) and MEIC v. Gianforte (records on dropping mining 'bad actor' enforcement). MT Supreme Court recognized limited 'deliberative process' privilege — first time in state history. No prior governor had ever claimed such privilege.
O'Neill v. Gianforte; MEIC v. Gianforte; MT Supreme Court; Daily Montanan Feb 2025
0
Governor's schedule availability
Transparency concerns extend to general government operations. 'Gubernatorial privilege' claims established pattern of withholding executive branch deliberations. MEIC won lawsuit after Governor's Office and Department of Administration denied access to mining enforcement records. Court awarded attorneys' fees to MEIC — presumption toward fee awards in Right to Know cases.
MEIC v. Gianforte; MT Supreme Court attorney fees ruling; Daily Montanan
1
Campaign finance compliance
No campaign finance violations. Won 2024 reelection by 20-point margin over Democrat Ryan Busse. Self-funded portions of campaigns from personal wealth (co-founded RightNow Technologies, sold to Oracle for ~$1.8B in 2011). Commissioner of Political Practices found no violations. Donated $50,000 to Committee to Protect Journalists as part of 2017 assault settlement.
MT Commissioner of Political Practices; 2024 election results; CPJ donation
3
Financial disclosure
Financial disclosures filed as required. Gianforte is independently wealthy — co-founded RightNow Technologies in 1997 in Bozeman, sold to Oracle for ~$1.8B (2011). He and wife Susan held 20-25% of stock ($300-400M). Placed businesses in blind trust upon taking office. Net worth estimated in hundreds of millions.
MT financial disclosure records; Forbes; Oracle acquisition records 2011
2
Open meetings compliance
No major open meetings violations by executive branch during tenure. Montana Land Board meetings (Gianforte chairs) conducted publicly — approved Big Snowy WMA purchase, 33,000-acre Northwest MT access expansion in open proceedings. AG open meetings opinions show no executive branch violations.
MT AG open meetings decisions; Land Board meeting records
3
Open data portal
Montana maintains data.mt.gov open data portal. ConnectMT broadband mapping data publicly available. CIO Kevin Gilbertson (appointed by Gianforte) adding data officer position and focusing on government transparency through technology. State fire dashboard launched 2021 for real-time wildfire data.
data.mt.gov; ConnectMT; StateScoop CIO appointment
2
Budget transparency
Budget documents published on budget.mt.gov. Legislative Fiscal Division publishes independent analyses. FY2027 $16.6B budget details publicly available including line-item vetoes ($31M). Property tax rebate portal (HB 222) — 235,000+ homeowners claimed rebates through transparent online system.
budget.mt.gov; MT Legislative Fiscal Division; HB 222 portal
2
Lobbying disclosure
Commissioner of Political Practices maintains lobbying disclosure database. Montana lobbying registration and reporting requirements enforced. No changes to weaken lobbying disclosure during tenure. Standard compliance with reporting deadlines across biennial legislative sessions.
MT Commissioner of Political Practices lobbying database
2
IG report publication
Legislative Audit Division reports published online and presented at public legislative committee meetings. Reports include critical findings — Secretary of State adverse opinion (FY2023), Single Audit results, agency performance audits. No executive interference with audit publication.
MT Legislative Audit Division; report archive.legmt.gov
2
Legislative audit cooperation
Executive branch agencies cooperating with Legislative Audit Division on routine audits. No reports of stonewalling auditors. However, 'gubernatorial privilege' claims on records create tension between executive transparency and audit access. LAD independence maintained — reports published without executive veto.
MT Legislative Audit Division; audit cooperation records
2
Press conference accessibility
Contentious relationship with press dating to May 24, 2017 assault of Guardian reporter Ben Jacobs — grabbed by neck with both hands and slammed to ground (3 Fox News witnesses). Pled guilty to misdemeanor assault Jun 12, 2017. Sentenced to 40 hours community service, 20 hours anger management, $385 in fines/fees. Donated $50,000 to CPJ. Press access questioned throughout governorship.
MT Justice Court; Guardian reporting; Fox News witness accounts; 2017 conviction
1
State contract transparency
Department of Administration maintains contract transparency through procurement portal. Red Tape Relief initiative streamlined 1,866 regulations without reducing contract disclosure requirements. No controversies over hidden state contracts or procurement irregularities during tenure.
MT Department of Administration procurement; Red Tape Relief records
2
Court order compliance
Complied with MT Supreme Court order on document review in O'Neill case — but court recognized limited 'gubernatorial privilege,' not full disclosure. Continuing to resist broad records access. MEIC case: lost on merits, ordered to pay attorneys' fees. Vetoed HB 271 (May 2025), which would have limited future privilege claims.
O'Neill v. Gianforte; MEIC v. Gianforte; HB 271 veto May 2025
2
Personal criminal charges
MISDEMEANOR ASSAULT CONVICTION (Jun 12, 2017). Grabbed Guardian reporter Ben Jacobs by neck with both hands, slammed to ground, punched him (per 3 Fox News eyewitnesses). Night before 2017 congressional special election. Sentence: 40 hrs community service, 20 hrs anger management, $385 fines/fees, 6-month deferred. Initially lied to police claiming reporter was aggressor — audio contradicted. Also: illegally killed elk (2000, $70 fine) and killed Yellowstone wolf (Feb 2021) without required trapping certification — written warning from FWP.
MT Justice Court; Gallatin County; Guardian audio; Fox News witnesses; MT FWP
1
Ethics complaints — substantiated
No formal ethics complaints substantiated through Commissioner of Political Practices beyond criminal assault matter. Campaign finance clean. No pay-to-play allegations. No misuse of office for personal gain. Ethics record apart from criminal conviction and wildlife violations is clean.
MT Commissioner of Political Practices records 2017-2026
3
Gift/travel disclosure
Financial disclosures filed as required. Gianforte's personal wealth (hundreds of millions from RightNow Technologies/Oracle sale) makes gift acceptance less relevant. Wolf killed Feb 2021 at ranch owned by Robert E. Smith (Sinclair Broadcasting director, campaign donor) — raised appearance questions but no gift violation found.
MT financial disclosure records; wolf trapping incident details
2
Conflict of interest
Placed businesses in blind trust upon taking office. No documented state-level conflicts of interest. Personal wealth from private tech sector (RightNow Technologies CRM software), not state-regulated industries. Commissioner of Political Practices found no conflict violations.
MT Commissioner of Political Practices; financial disclosures; blind trust
3
State resources for political purposes
No documented misuse of state resources for political campaigns or personal purposes. Self-funded significant portions of campaigns from personal wealth. No state employee time, vehicles, or equipment diverted to campaign use. Ethics records clear on this metric throughout tenure.
MT ethics records; Commissioner of Political Practices
3
Truthfulness — official statements
DOCUMENTED FALSEHOOD TO LAW ENFORCEMENT. After assaulting Ben Jacobs (May 24, 2017), told police that reporter 'prior to entering the prior interview prior the prior interview prior the prior interview' was aggressive — audio recording and 3 Fox News eyewitnesses directly contradicted account. Later changed story and pled guilty. Pattern: initial statement to police was false, corrected only under weight of evidence.
MT Justice Court records; Guardian audio recording; Fox News eyewitness statements
1
Ethics protection — strengthened or weakened
WEAKENED. Vetoed HB 271 (May 2025), which would have limited governor's ability to withhold public records under 'executive privilege.' Actively created new 'gubernatorial privilege' doctrine — unprecedented in MT history. Fought multiple lawsuits to maintain secrecy. MEIC case: administration dropped mining 'bad actor' enforcement case, then refused to release records about why.
HB 271 veto May 2025; Montana Free Press; MT Public Radio; MEIC v. Gianforte
0
Emoluments/self-enrichment
No self-enrichment from public office. Already worth hundreds of millions from RightNow Technologies sale to Oracle ($1.8B, 2011). Governor's salary trivial relative to personal wealth. No state contracts steered to personal businesses. Blind trust established for private holdings. No emoluments complaints.
Financial disclosures; blind trust records; Oracle acquisition 2011
3
Donor-to-appointment pipeline
No documented donor-to-appointment pipeline. Key appointees drawn from professional backgrounds — Meier (Kentucky health administration), Dorrington (career MT DEQ since 2016), Gilbertson (IT professional). Wolf killed at donor Robert Smith's ranch raised proximity questions but no appointment connection found.
MT Commissioner of Political Practices; appointment records
3
Foreign influence
No foreign influence connections. RightNow Technologies was a Bozeman-based American company (sold to Oracle, an American corporation). No foreign campaign contributions. No foreign business entanglements. Montana's geographic isolation and small population limit foreign influence vectors.
Ethics records; campaign finance records; financial disclosures
3
Harassment — workplace/sexual
No workplace or sexual harassment complaints against governor or senior staff during 5+ years in office. Reporter assault (2017) was physical assault pre-governorship, not workplace harassment. State employee HR processes functioning without harassment scandals in executive branch.
MT Department of Administration HR records; ethics records
3
Records preservation
Not destroying records but functionally preventing public access through 'gubernatorial privilege' claims. O'Neill case: withheld Agency Bill Monitoring Forms showing governor's positions on legislation. MEIC case: withheld records about dropping mining enforcement case. Created de facto barrier to records access unprecedented in MT history — functional equivalent of concealment.
O'Neill v. Gianforte; MEIC v. Gianforte; MT Supreme Court
1
Revolving door compliance
No revolving door violations documented. Cabinet members who departed (e.g., Meier moved from DPHHS to DOA within state government, not to lobbying). No former staff hired by companies receiving state contracts within prohibited periods. Montana's revolving door rules enforced without issue.
MT ethics records; appointment/departure records
3
Major fraud in state programs
No major fraud in state programs during 5+ years. Legislative Audit Division ACT hotline operational for anonymous fraud reporting. No federal OIG findings of fraud in Montana-administered programs. Small state population (1.1M) and close oversight culture reduce fraud risk compared to larger states.
MT Legislative Audit Division; ACT hotline; federal OIG records
3
Program integrity — improper payments
No major improper payment issues identified in Single Audit or state audits. Medicaid expansion (~75,000 enrollees) administered through DPHHS without improper payment scandals. UI system operating at 2.8% unemployment — minimal fraud pressure from low claim volume. Standard federal program compliance maintained.
MT Legislative Audit Division; DPHHS Medicaid reports; UI Division
3
IT modernization vs failures
Gianforte's tech background (founded RightNow Technologies, $1.8B CRM company) informs approach. Appointed CIO Kevin Gilbertson — adding data officer, shifting to zero-trust cybersecurity architecture. SITSD dismantling decades-old mainframe for cloud-based virtual environment. Cybersecurity workforce development at Missoula College (NCAE-CD). No major IT failures or data breaches.
MT SITSD; StateScoop; CIO appointment; Missoula College cybersecurity
2
Permit/license processing
Business-friendly approach — Red Tape Relief eliminated 1,114 net regulatory restrictions since 2021. SB 240 exempted smaller subdivisions from DEQ review. Processing times improved for business permits. Recreational marijuana licensing rolled out (HB 701) — existing medical providers first, broader licensing Jul 2023. Montana ranked #2 economy by WalletHub 2025.
MT regulatory agencies; Red Tape Relief; SB 240; WalletHub 2025
2
Child welfare outcomes
DPHHS Child and Family Services Division (CFSD) processed ~34,400 centralized intake calls in SFY2023, with 7,567 requiring investigations. 18% of foster care children exited through adoption in SFY2023. CFSR Round 4 scheduled Aug 2025. Youth-Centered Meetings (YCM) model piloted Jul 2024-Oct 2025 for 112 youth — permanency-focused innovation.
MT DPHHS CFSD; CFSR Round 4; APSR data; ACF
2
Medicaid administration
Medicaid expansion (originally Bullock era, SB 405/2015) maintained and made permanent under Gianforte — signed HB 245 (Mar 2025) removing sunset date. Covers ~75,000 low-income Montanans. Gianforte supports work requirements and 'guardrails.' DPHHS administration functioning without major enrollment errors or access complaints.
MT DPHHS Medicaid; HB 245; Montana Free Press Mar 2025
2
Environmental compliance
PERSONAL WILDLIFE VIOLATIONS. Illegally killed elk (2000, $70 fine). Killed Yellowstone wolf (wolf 1155, radio-collared from park) via trapping without required certification (Feb 2021) — received written warning from FWP. MEIC lawsuit: administration dropped mining 'bad actor' enforcement, refused to release records about decision. Conservation groups critical of DEQ approach. 100,000+ acres public land access is positive counterbalance.
MT FWP; MEIC v. Gianforte; MT DEQ; conservation group reports
1
Transportation project delivery
$100M in road and bridge repairs funded from debt-payoff savings (2023). $65M FHWA emergency funds for Yellowstone flooding highway damage. DOT manages 75,000+ lane-miles across 4th-largest state. $10M allocated for 500 bridge repairs over 5 years in FY2027 budget. Highway reconstruction in Yellowstone corridor completed after 2022 flooding.
MT DOT; FHWA; HB 2 (2025) budget
2
Unemployment insurance system
UI system functioning well with 2.8% unemployment (first half 2025) — lowest since Sep 2023. 43 consecutive months at or below 3.4%. Record 560,000+ Montanans employed (2024). 578,000+ in labor force — record high. UI contribution rates stable. Healthcare sector adding most jobs. System not stress-tested by high claims volume.
MT Department of Labor and Industry; BLS LAUS; Governor's Office
2
Veterans services
Montana Veterans Affairs Division services maintained. Malmstrom AFB (Great Falls) is one of three ICBM bases nationally — 341st Missile Wing operates Minuteman III force across 13,800 sq mi. Governor supports military community. Veterans services funded in budget. No VA service complaints or access failures reported during tenure.
MT Veterans Affairs Division; Malmstrom AFB; budget documents
2
Housing/homelessness
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY CRISIS — worst in nation. Montana Realtors Affordability Score: 0.40, lowest nationally. Bozeman/Gallatin County median home: $810,000 (2024 record). Missoula median: $550,000. Statewide median: $460,700. Median income $100,900 can afford ~$410,000 home. Bipartisan 'Montana Miracle' zoning reforms (SB 382, SB 528, SB 245) address supply. HB 222 $500 property tax rebate (235,000 homeowners). SB 542 cut property taxes 15%. But crisis deepening — forecast: $932,000 median by 2030.
MT Realtors; Norada Real Estate; Montana Free Press Feb 2026; HB 222; SB 542
0
Corrections system
OVERCROWDING CRISIS. Men's facilities 5% over capacity, women's 14% over capacity. 600+ Montana men imprisoned out of state (60% Arizona, 40% Mississippi). $156M prison expansion (HB 817, 2023) groundbreaking Apr 2025 — adds 117 beds. 2025 legislature: $436M total corrections capacity funding, $250M (HB 833) for new construction. Need: 1,300 more male beds and 230 female beds by 2044.
MT DOC; HB 817; HB 833; Montana Free Press Apr 2025
1
Federal funding captured
Montana receiving ~$6.3B annually in federal funds. Secured $629M BEAD broadband allocation — first state to open application portal. $65M FHWA emergency highway funds for Yellowstone flooding. FEMA DR-4655 disaster declaration (6 counties). IIJA formula funds for highways, bridges, water. ARPA funds administered. STARS Act leverages state funds for teacher pay alongside federal education dollars.
USASpending.gov; NTIA BEAD; FEMA; FHWA; IIJA
2
Corrective action compliance
No federal corrective actions or sanctions against Montana during Gianforte tenure. Single Audit (FY2023, issued Aug 2024) showed no findings requiring corrective action plans. Federal grant compliance maintained across DPHHS, DOT, and other agencies. BEAD proposal received NTIA approval without revision requirements.
Federal grant compliance records; Single Audit; NTIA BEAD approval Aug 2024
2
Interstate compacts/cooperation
Active in Western Governors' Association on wildfire, water, public lands. Activated EMAC (Emergency Management Assistance Compact) for wildfire mutual aid from Utah and California (2021). Supported CSKT water compact ($1.9B settlement) as congressman. Regional cooperation on Yellowstone flooding response with Wyoming and NPS.
WGA; EMAC; CSKT water compact; interstate coordination records
2
State-local government relations
Generally cooperative with municipalities. Property tax reforms (SB 542) addressed local government revenue concerns — 80% of homeowners saw cuts. Housing zoning reforms (SB 382) require local government planning commission action — some local resistance. $100M local disaster relief fund in FY2027 budget. League of Cities and Towns relationship functional.
MT League of Cities and Towns; SB 542; SB 382; HB 2 (2025)
2
Litigation cost to state
Multiple transparency lawsuits costing state in legal fees. O'Neill v. Gianforte: state defended 'gubernatorial privilege' through MT Supreme Court. MEIC v. Gianforte: state lost, ordered to pay plaintiffs' attorneys' fees under Right to Know statute (MT Supreme Court established fee presumption). State AG defending novel legal theories at taxpayer expense. HB 271 veto ensures future litigation continues.
MT AG office; O'Neill v. Gianforte; MEIC v. Gianforte; HB 271 veto
1
Constituent response time
Governor's Office constituent services operating at standard level. Online property tax rebate portal (HB 222) served 235,000+ homeowners efficiently. ESA application portal for special-needs students (HB 393) established. State fire dashboard provides real-time emergency information. Digital government services expanded under CIO Gilbertson.
MT Governor's Office; HB 222 portal; fire dashboard; SITSD
3
Town halls/public engagement
Limited formal town hall schedule. Public engagement primarily through official events, press releases, and agency-specific channels. Press relationship strained by 2017 assault conviction — reporter body-slam shapes ongoing media dynamics. Public schedule available but not robust with open-forum town halls. Montana's vast geography (147,000 sq mi) complicates statewide public engagement.
MT Governor's Office public schedule; media coverage
1
Satisfaction/approval rating
Won 2024 reelection by 20-point margin over Democrat Ryan Busse (Libertarian Kaiser Leib also ran). First Republican governor reelected in Montana since Marc Racicot (1996). Margin increased from 13 points (2020) to 20 points (2024). Morning Consult tracking shows moderate approval — popular enough for strong reelection but not universally beloved.
MT Secretary of State 2024 results; Morning Consult; 2020 comparison
2
ADA/accessibility compliance
No reported ADA violations or accessibility complaints against executive branch. HB 393 Education Savings Accounts specifically targeted students with special needs (IDEA-eligible) — $7,000/yr for private school, tutoring, therapies. Program blocked by court Dec 2025 on appropriations grounds, not accessibility. State facilities and digital services accessible.
MT Governor's Office; HB 393; ADA compliance records
2
Electoral mandate/succession
Won 2024 reelection by 20-point margin — expanded from 13 points in 2020. First Republican reelected governor of Montana since Marc Racicot (1996). Clear mandate for second term: voters endorsed tax cuts, debt-free record, and public lands access despite transparency controversies and assault conviction. Term-limited after second term.
MT Secretary of State 2024 results; MT Constitution Art. VI §4
3

Section B — State Outcomes 582/975

13 categories measuring real-world outcomes: economic performance, population trends, fiscal health, public safety, education, healthcare, infrastructure, cost of living, transparency, controversy, historical context, constituent satisfaction, and immigration compliance.

BLS LAUS: unemployment 3.3% (well below national 4.3%). 560,000+ Montanans employed — all-time record. Montana ranked #2 economy nationally in 2025 WalletHub study. RightNow Technologies founder brought tech-sector lens to economic policy. BEA: GDP ~$65B, growing ~3% annually. Average weekly earnings rising. In 2024, Gianforte earned more votes than any gubernatorial candidate in MT history. Tech sector growth in Bozeman corridor. But housing costs ($510K median in Bozeman, $575K in Missoula per Zillow) limiting worker recruitment in western MT.
Census: MT population 1,137,223 (July 2024), up 5,931 from 2023 (0.52% growth, ranking 37th nationally). Growth slowing sharply from 1.7% pandemic boom to 0.3-0.4% by 2025 — 25-year low. Added only 7,137 residents mid-2024 to mid-2025. Deaths exceeded births by 90 in 2025 (natural population decline). 6th highest percentage over age 65 (~19.7%). Migration overwhelmingly domestic — lowest international migration of any state. Kalispell fastest-growing city (~4% growth, +1,100 residents). Bozeman growth slowed to 1.4%. Affordability crisis driving slowdown.
STRONGEST AREA. Montana DEBT-FREE since 2023 — among very few states. Three income tax cuts signed ($850M combined). Property tax cuts. Revenue surpluses funding tax relief. AAA fiscal position. But aggressive tax cutting may create future revenue challenges if economy slows.
FBI UCR 2024: violent crime rate 424/100K (total crime 3,449.5/100K — 25% above national average of 2,752.3). Violent crime down 5.6% in 2024 (near national 5.4% decline). 80.9% of violent crimes are aggravated assaults. Property crime rose 12.3% (vs national 9% decrease). Over 6-year period (2019-2024), total crime decreased 23% from 4,482 to 3,450/100K. Missoula felony violent crimes down ~10% over 3 years. $100M public safety funding in FY2027 budget (HB 2). Meth trafficking on I-90/I-15 corridors remains challenge. Low population density aids rural safety.
Record education funding in FY2027 budget. STARS Act: $100M for teacher pay increases (starting salary boosted). NAEP: Montana scores near or above national averages (4th grade reading 223 vs national 216, 2022). Montana University System (16 campuses) maintained flat tuition for multiple years. HB 393 Education Savings Accounts ($7,000/yr for IDEA-eligible special needs students) — signed but blocked by court Dec 2025. K-12 enrollment declining in some rural areas due to population aging. Rural school access challenges across 147,000 sq mi state.
Medicaid expansion maintained (HELP Act, originally 2015, reauthorized 2019) — covers ~100,000 Montanans. Gianforte did not attempt repeal despite initial skepticism. Healthcare access severely limited in rural/frontier areas — only 3 Level I/II trauma centers (Billings, Missoula, Great Falls). Mental health provider shortage acute: 56 of 56 counties federally designated Mental Health Professional Shortage Areas. Life expectancy ~77.5 years (below national ~78.6). Uninsured rate ~8.5% (moderate). Indian Health Service facilities serve 7 reservation communities.
FY2027 budget includes $100M for road/bridge repairs. IIJA: Montana receiving $3.7B+ over 5 years for highways, bridges, broadband, water. Broadband: $629M BEAD allocation for last-mile connectivity. 100,000+ acres of public land access expanded (Gianforte signature priority). Wildfire infrastructure: EMAC mutual aid activated 2021 (Utah, California); state fire dashboard for real-time emergency info. MDT managing 34,000+ lane miles. But 147,000 sq mi geography creates persistent maintenance challenges. $100M local disaster relief fund in FY2027 budget.
SIGNIFICANT CONCERN. Housing prices surged dramatically post-2020. Western MT (Bozeman, Missoula) extremely unaffordable. 64% of renters cost-burdened per MT Budget and Policy Center. Property tax cuts help but don't address root supply crisis. Population growth slowing because people can't afford to live there.
WEAKNESS. Claimed unprecedented 'gubernatorial privilege' (deliberative process exemption) to withhold records — O'Neill v. Gianforte and MEIC v. Gianforte both litigated through MT Supreme Court. MEIC: state ordered to pay plaintiffs' attorneys' fees under Right to Know statute. Vetoed HB 271 (May 2025) which would have limited executive privilege claims — sponsor called it 'largest setback to open government since the Copper Kings.' Montana has transparency.mt.gov portal with Checkbook AP data and OPIR (Office of Public Information Requests) for standardized records access. But gubernatorial resistance to disclosure undermines framework. 2017 reporter body-slam (misdemeanor conviction) shapes ongoing media dynamics.
2017 reporter assault (misdemeanor conviction, initially lied to police). Illegal elk kill (2000). Yellowstone wolf trapping violation (2021). Vetoed transparency bills. 'Gubernatorial privilege' controversy. Multiple lawsuits over records. Strong fiscal record partially offsets personal conduct issues.
Historic: Made Montana debt-free (2023) — among very few states nationally. First Republican governor reelected since Marc Racicot (1996). Earned most votes of any gubernatorial candidate in MT history (2024). Won reelection by 20 points (up from 13 in 2020). Ended 16 years of Democratic gubernatorial control. Three income tax cuts totaling $850M. Record employment (560K+). Predecessor comparisons: followed Democrat Steve Bullock (2013-2021) and 4 consecutive Democratic governors. Founded RightNow Technologies (500+ jobs in Bozeman) before office. But transparency failures (gubernatorial privilege, HB 271 veto), 2017 assault conviction, and housing crisis ($510K median Bozeman) complicate legacy.
Won reelection 2024 — voters endorsed record despite controversies. Tax cuts popular. Debt-free status resonates. But housing affordability anger growing. Environmental and transparency concerns from significant minority. Net positive mandate from voters.
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Section C — Oath Fidelity +150 (-378 to +378)

126 items scored -3 to +3 measuring fidelity to constitutional oath. Grounded in Supreme Court precedent and constitutional text.

+3Exemplary +2Strong +1Adequate 0Neutral -1Concerning -2Failing -3Hostile

Protection of Life

Declaration of Independence; 5th/14th Amendments
Score: 27 Range: -93 to 93 Items: 31
Violent crime rate trend
MT violent crime rate ~340/100K (2023), slightly below national 364. Rate stable during Gianforte tenure despite rapid population growth.
FBI UCR/NIBRS; MT DCI
+2
Homicide rate relative to national average
MT homicide rate ~5-6/100K, near national average ~6.3. Small population creates volatility. Reservation violence contributes.
FBI UCR; CDC WONDER
0
Homicide clearance rate
MT homicide clearance rate ~50-55%, near national average.
FBI UCR Supplementary Homicide Reports
+1
Law enforcement staffing adequacy
MT law enforcement staffing stretched across 147,040 sq mi (4th largest state). 7.5 people/sq mi. Some rural shortages. Montana State Prison staffing crisis.
FBI LEOKA; BJS CSLLEA
0
Drug overdose death rate trend
MT overdose death rate ~18-20/100K, below national ~33. Methamphetamine more prevalent than opioids historically. Fentanyl growing.
CDC WONDER; NCHS
0
Emergency management preparedness
MT DES well-organized. 2022 Yellowstone flooding response effective — secured federal disaster declaration within 2 days. 2021 wildfire response (141K+ acres) managed adequately.
FEMA SPR; MT DES
+2
Preventable mass-casualty event response
2022 Yellowstone flooding: 115 homes destroyed but no deaths from delayed response. Evacuations of Gardiner/Red Lodge executed successfully. Wildfire evacuations (2021) without fatalities.
FEMA DR-4655; MT DES
+2
Infrastructure safety — bridge and road conditions
$100M invested in road/bridge repairs after debt payoff. DOT maintaining 75,000+ lane-miles. No catastrophic failures. Yellowstone road repairs completed.
FHWA NBI; MT DOT
+1
Water and dam safety compliance
MT water systems generally compliant. DNRC maintains dam safety. CSKT water compact support. Agricultural water infrastructure functional.
EPA SDWIS; MT DNRC
+1
Healthcare access — uninsured rate
MT Medicaid expansion (HB 245, made permanent Mar 2025) covers ~75K. Uninsured rate ~8-9%. Bipartisan support for expansion.
Census ACS; KFF; HB 245
+1
Maternal mortality rate
MT maternal mortality approximately 15-20/100K, near national average. Rural access challenges. Small birth population creates volatility.
CDC WONDER; NCHS
+1
Infant mortality rate
MT infant mortality ~5.0-5.5/1,000, near national average. Adequate outcomes.
CDC WONDER; NCHS
+1
Self-defense rights — Castle Doctrine / Stand Your Ground
MT has Castle Doctrine + no duty to retreat + statutory self-defense protections (MCA §45-3-103). Constitutional carry (HB 102, 2021, signed by Gianforte).
MCA §45-3-103; HB 102; NRA-ILA
+3
Death penalty procedural safeguards
MT retains death penalty with mandatory appellate review. Limited use. Last execution 2006. Adequate safeguards.
DPIC; MCA §46-18-301
+1
Suicide prevention program funding and outcomes
MT has among highest suicide rates nationally (~26/100K vs ~14 national). Rural isolation, firearms access, and reservation conditions contribute. HEART Fund ($6M/yr marijuana tax) supports mental health but outcomes poor.
CDC WISQARS; AFSP MT; HB 701 HEART Fund
-1
911/emergency response time adequacy
Urban areas (Billings, Missoula, Great Falls) meet NFPA standards. Vast rural areas face inherent long response times. 147,040 sq mi with 1.1M people.
NFPA; MT EMS registry
0
Opioid/fentanyl interdiction and treatment funding
MT overdose deaths below national average. PDMP operational. HEART Fund provides mental health/substance abuse treatment funding ($6M/yr).
SAMHSA; CDC WONDER; HEART Fund
+1
Veteran suicide and healthcare access
MT veteran suicide elevated consistent with high overall state rate. Fort Harrison VA serves state. 7 reservations have some VA outreach.
VA SAIL; HUD PIT count
0
Food safety and foodborne illness enforcement
MT Dept of Agriculture food safety adequate. Ranching/agricultural economy. No major outbreak failures.
FDA Conformance; MT Dept of Agriculture
+1
Workplace fatality rate
MT workplace fatality rate ~5-6/100K FTE, above national average. Mining, timber, ranching, and energy extraction industries contribute.
BLS CFOI
0
Domestic violence fatality rate and funding
MT has DV programs. Rural isolation limits shelter access. Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW) crisis on reservations. Average overall performance.
NNEDV; MT DPHHS
0
Correctional facility death rate and conditions
Montana State Prison expansion ($156M, HB 817). $436M total corrections capacity. Staffing challenges. Some overcrowding. Conditions strained but investment underway.
BJS; MT DOC; HB 817
0
Pollution-related mortality and environmental health
MT generally good air quality. Wildfire smoke seasonal concern. Libby asbestos Superfund cleanup ongoing. Mining remediation. Generally healthy environment.
EPA Green Book; MT DEQ
+1
Pedestrian and traffic fatality rate
MT traffic fatality rate ~1.5-1.8/100M VMT, above national average. Long distances, high speeds, and wildlife collisions contribute.
NHTSA FARS; MT DOT
0
Sanctity of life legislative framework
MT has near-total abortion ban (HB 862, 2023, signed by Gianforte). Voter-rejected CI-128 (Nov 2024) to enshrine abortion access — 53% no. Strong pro-life framework enacted and defended.
Guttmacher; HB 862; CI-128 results
+2
Homeless mortality — exposure deaths, overdoses in encampments, violence
Montana had 89% increase in homelessness 2007-2023, 45% increase 2022-2023. Invested $300M in behavioral health but homelessness continues rising.
theelectricgf.com; news.mt.gov
0
Population loss impact on services — EMS/hospital closures, tax base erosion
Montana population growth slowing (0.62% in 2025) but still positive. Net 7,247 new residents. Rural service challenges persist.
dailymontanan.com; montanafreepress.org
0
Police staffing/funding — governor's direct actions on law enforcement
Budget includes $150M for prison expansion, $250M for long-term public safety, $7M for Highway Patrol pay increases, $6.5M for corrections officer pay.
news.mt.gov; kpax.com
+2
Criminal recidivism from early release — parole/clemency, no-cash-bail
$150M prison expansion to 'keep violent criminals off the street.' Additional prosecutors and judges. Drug treatment courts funded at $2M.
news.mt.gov; montanafreepress.org
+1
Prison/shelter housing — biological males in women's facilities
Signed HB 121 requiring prison housing based on biological sex at birth. Signed bathroom bill applying biological sex standards to correctional facilities and schools.
nbcnews.com; dailymontanan.com
+2
Mental health crisis system — involuntary commitment reform, crisis intervention
$300M 'generational investment' in behavioral health. CMS waiver approved for HEART program with three new Medicaid-funded behavioral health services.
dphhs.mt.gov; news.mt.gov
+2

Constitutional Rights

Bill of Rights (I-X); 14th Amendment
Score: 46 Range: -87 to 87 Items: 29
Second Amendment — right to carry status
Signed constitutional carry (HB 102, Feb 2021). Permitless concealed carry in all locations including university campuses. Strong 2A.
HB 102; MCA; NRA-ILA
+3
Second Amendment — semi-automatic rifle restrictions
No restrictions beyond federal law. No assault weapons ban.
MT Code; NRA-ILA
+3
Second Amendment — magazine capacity restrictions
No magazine capacity restrictions.
MT Code; NRA-ILA
+3
Second Amendment — Red Flag / ERPO due process
MT has NO red flag/ERPO law. Full due process maintained.
MT Legislature records; NRA-ILA
+3
First Amendment — campus free speech protections
HB 102 expanded carry to university campuses — unusual free exercise protection. UM and MSU generally respect free expression.
FIRE campus rankings; HB 102
+1
First Amendment — anti-SLAPP protections
MT has no specific anti-SLAPP statute. Montana Constitution Art. II §7 provides broad speech protections.
Public Participation Project; MT Constitution
0
First Amendment — religious liberty protections
Strong religious liberty tradition. Conservative culture supports religious freedom. Montana Constitution has robust religious liberty provisions.
MT Constitution Art. II; Becket Fund
+2
Fourth Amendment — warrant requirements for digital surveillance
MT follows federal Carpenter standard. Montana Constitution Art. II §10 provides stronger privacy protections than federal baseline.
EFF; MT Constitution Art. II §10
+1
Fourth Amendment — civil asset forfeiture reform
MT has moderate forfeiture protections with some reform enacted.
Institute for Justice; MT forfeiture statutes
+1
Fifth Amendment — eminent domain protections post-Kelo
MT has strong property rights protections. Ranching culture reinforces property rights. Post-Kelo reforms enacted.
MT eminent domain statutes; Castle Coalition
+2
Due process — regulatory takings and permitting timelines
Red Tape Relief eliminated 1,866 of 11,753 regulations (16% reduction). 1,114 net regulatory restrictions eliminated. Significant deregulation.
Red Tape Relief Task Force; Mountain States Policy Center
+2
Tenth Amendment — federal overreach resistance
Gianforte pressed for 'extinguish all fires' approach challenging federal forest management. Met with Biden on wildfire strategy. Moderate sovereignty assertion.
Governor's wildfire briefing; WH meeting
+1
Equal Protection — state contracting nondiscrimination
MT has merit-based contracting. Standard nondiscrimination provisions.
MT procurement data
+1
Second Amendment — state preemption of local firearms laws
MT has strong firearms preemption. HB 102 expanded preemption to university campuses. No local restrictions permitted.
MT Code; HB 102; NRA-ILA
+3
First Amendment — government transparency and FOIA compliance
MAJOR NEGATIVE. Claimed unprecedented 'gubernatorial privilege' to withhold records on bill positions. Two lawsuits lost (O'Neill, MEIC). Court ordered fee payment. Vetoed HB 271 transparency bill.
O'Neill v. Gianforte; MEIC v. Gianforte; HB 271 veto
-1
Sixth Amendment — public defender funding adequacy
MT public defender system has capacity constraints. Remote locations underserved.
Sixth Amendment Center; MT public defender
0
Eighth Amendment — bail reform and pretrial detention
MT has standard bail system. No extreme pretrial detention patterns.
Pretrial Justice Institute; MT court records
+1
Property rights — regulatory burden and economic freedom
MT improved economic freedom ranking through Red Tape Relief, three rounds of income tax cuts, and debt payoff. Strong property rights environment.
Cato Freedom Index; Fraser Institute
+2
Second Amendment — governor's litigation posture on firearms cases
Gianforte/MT AG supportive of 2A. Joins pro-2A multistate amicus briefs.
MT AG amicus filings
+2
First Amendment — compelled speech protections
No significant compelled speech mandates. DEI not mandated in state government.
MT administrative rules
+1
Commerce Clause compliance — interstate trade barriers
MT has minimal interstate trade barriers. Energy and agricultural exports flow freely.
IJ licensing data
+1
Privileges and Immunities — occupational licensing reform
Red Tape Relief reduced licensing barriers. 1,866 regulations amended/repealed. Military spouse reciprocity.
IJ License to Work; Red Tape Relief
+2
Contract Clause — state compliance with contractual obligations
PERS 74.48%, TRS 74.26%. $300M one-time pension stabilization in FY2027. Improving but underfunded.
MPERA; TRS actuarial
+1
Jury trial rights — civil and criminal jury access
MT has standard jury trial access. Montana Constitution Art. II §26 protects jury rights. No documented access crisis.
MT Judiciary; NCSC
+1
Immigration law compliance — Supremacy Clause adherence
MT complies with 8 USC §1373. No sanctuary cities. Standard immigration enforcement. Small undocumented population.
8 USC §1373; MT DCI
+2
Qualified immunity / due process for officers
Strong pro-law enforcement posture with significant funding increases. No efforts to weaken qualified immunity.
news.mt.gov
+1
Voter ID and ballot chain-of-custody
Signed SB 276 implementing photo ID for voting. Signed bills eliminating same-day voter registration. 'Model for the rest of the nation.'
sosmt.gov; news.mt.gov
+2
Non-citizen voting prevention
Photo ID requirement for voting. Eliminated same-day registration. Signed bill preventing college students from voting unless intending permanent residency.
sosmt.gov; montanafreepress.org
+2
Women's sports / Title IX — biological sex protections in state-funded athletics
Signed HB 112 in 2021 banning transgender athletes from K-12 and college. After court block, lobbied Board of Regents. Signed 2025 bathroom bill with comprehensive sex protections.
news.mt.gov; montanafreepress.org
+3

Child Welfare & Parental Rights

Meyer v. Nebraska (1923), Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925), Troxel v. Granville (2000)
Score: 20 Range: -75 to 75 Items: 25
Parental rights legislation — statutory recognition
MT has common law parental rights protections. Conservative culture supports parental authority.
MT statutes; Parental Rights Foundation
+1
Education choice — school choice programs
MT has modest education choice through tax credit scholarship program. Not universal ESA/voucher but some choice. STARS Act ($100M teacher pay) improves public education.
EdChoice MT; STARS Act
+1
Parental notification/consent for medical procedures on minors
MT requires parental consent for most medical procedures on minors. Standard consent framework.
MT minor consent statutes; Guttmacher
+1
Gender-transition procedures for minors — restrictions
SB 99 (2023) banned trans procedures for minors. Signed by Gianforte. Clear restriction.
SB 99; MT Code
+2
Child abuse and neglect — substantiated case rate trend
MT child maltreatment rate near national average. DPHHS CFSD handled ~34,400 intake calls (SFY2023). Standard performance.
ACF NCANDS; MT DPHHS CFSD
0
Foster care — CFSR conformity assessment
MT has mixed CFSR results. Standard foster care challenges for rural state with 7 reservations creating jurisdictional complexity.
ACF CFSR; MT DPHHS
0
Foster care — permanency outcomes
MT foster care permanency outcomes near national average. Reservation jurisdiction complicates some permanency cases (ICWA compliance).
ACF AFCARS; MT DPHHS
0
Child trafficking prevention and prosecution
MT has child trafficking statute. ICAC participation. I-90/I-15 corridors monitored. MMIW crisis intersects with trafficking on reservations.
Polaris Project; MT DOJ
+1
Education outcomes — 4th grade NAEP reading proficiency
MT 4th grade NAEP reading ~34% proficient (2022), above national average of 32%.
NCES NAEP 2022
+1
Education outcomes — 8th grade NAEP math proficiency
MT 8th grade NAEP math ~30% proficient (2022), above national average of 26%.
NCES NAEP 2022
+1
Parental curriculum transparency
No specific statutory parental curriculum transparency law. Local district policies vary.
MT Education Code
0
Social media — minor protections
MT relies on federal COPPA. No state social media minor protection legislation.
NCSL social media tracker
0
Juvenile justice — age-appropriate treatment
MT has adequate juvenile justice system. Low juvenile incarceration. DPHHS handles juvenile services.
JJDPA; OJJDP MT profile
+1
Child poverty rate and state response
MT child poverty rate ~12-14%, below national average of 16%. Economic growth and low unemployment support families.
Census ACS SAIPE; KIDS COUNT
+1
Adoption and permanency — adoptive family support
MT has standard adoption programs. ICWA compliance adds complexity for reservation cases.
ACF AFCARS; MT DPHHS
0
Homeschool rights and protections
MT has permissive homeschool framework — notification required but no testing mandates. Among more homeschool-friendly states.
HSLDA MT; MCA
+2
Child sexual abuse material (CSAM) enforcement
MT DOJ and ISB participate in ICAC task force. Adequate enforcement.
ICAC; NCMEC; MT DOJ
+1
School safety — violence prevention and incident response
MT has low school violence rates. Small rural communities provide natural safety. STARS Act investment improves school environment.
NASRO; MT education safety
+1
Children's mental health services access
MT children's mental health access limited in rural areas. HEART Fund ($6M/yr) supports behavioral health including youth services. Reservation mental health severe gap.
ASCA ratio; SAMHSA MT; HEART Fund
0
Childhood vaccination — parental choice protections
MT allows religious and medical exemptions for school immunization. Standard parental choice protections.
NCSL vaccination data; CDC
+2
Child care affordability and access
MT child care access limited in rural areas. Western MT (Bozeman/Missoula) housing costs strain families. State subsidy exists but limited.
ACF CCDF; NWLC
0
Education — teacher quality and retention
STARS Act invested $100M to raise starting teacher pay — 4.2% raise FY2026, 3% FY2027, plus $1,500 stipend. Significant investment improving recruitment.
NCES; STARS Act; MT OPI
+1
Child nutrition — food insecurity rate
MT child food insecurity ~12-13%, near or slightly below national average. Agricultural state provides food access.
USDA ERS; Feeding America
+1
Custody and family court — due process in child removal
MT District Courts have standard due process. ICWA compliance for reservation cases adds protections.
MT District Courts; ABA
+1
Children with disabilities — IDEA compliance
MT IDEA compliance adequate. Small special education population allows individualized services.
OSEP; IDEA Part B data
+1

Faithful Discharge of Duties

Sworn oath: 'faithfully discharge the duties of office'
Score: 57 Range: -123 to 123 Items: 41
Budget balance — structural surplus/deficit
Currently in surplus — FY2027 ends with $311M reserves. Three rounds of tax cuts funded by revenue growth. Risk: expenditures may exceed revenue by 2028.
MT Legislative Fiscal Division; NASBO
+2
State credit rating stability
Moody's Aa1 — one step below Aaa. Financial performance graded Aaa. Debt-free status among strongest. Only pension liability prevents overall Aaa.
Moody's; MT State Treasurer
+2
Rainy day / budget stabilization fund adequacy
Debt-free since 2023 ($40M saved). $311M projected reserves. Available funds 87.7% of own-source revenue (median: 44.4%). Extraordinary position.
NASBO; Pew; Moody's
+3
Pension system funding responsibility
PERS 74.48%, TRS 74.26%. Below ideal but $300M one-time stabilization in FY2027 budget. Improving trajectory.
MPERA; TRS actuarial
+1
State debt burden
DEBT-FREE since 2023. HB 251 paid off all GO debt. Among very few states nationally. Extraordinary achievement.
Census; MT State Treasurer; HB 251
+3
Government efficiency — state employee headcount per capita
Red Tape Relief reduced regulatory overhead. State employee pay plans (4% then 2.5%) maintain workforce. ~20% expected to retire in 10 years.
Census Public Employment; MT DOA
+1
Inspector General / state auditor independence
Legislative Audit Division operates independently. Published critical audits (SOS adverse opinion) without interference. Structural independence maintained.
MT Legislative Audit Division
+2
Ethics violations and personal scandals
MISDEMEANOR ASSAULT CONVICTION (Jun 2017). Body-slammed Guardian reporter. Pled guilty. 40 hrs community service. Also illegally killed elk (2000) and Yellowstone wolf (2021) without required certification. Multiple personal conduct issues.
MT Justice Court; MT FWP; Guardian
-1
Executive order restraint
Conservative EO usage. Red Tape Relief EO properly delegated. Wildfire emergency EO within authority. No overreach.
Governor's EOs; court records
+2
Emergency powers — adherence to statutory limits
Wildfire emergency (2021) and flood emergency (2022) declarations within proper authority. No overreach. Powers properly exercised and relinquished.
MT emergency statutes
+2
Legislative cooperation — veto override rate
Strong relationship with R supermajority. $31M in line-item vetoes accepted without override. Budget negotiations productive. High legislative success rate.
MT Legislature Journal
+2
Judicial appointments — qualifications and process integrity
Uses Judicial Nomination Commission process. Appointees from qualified pools. No complaints from State Bar. Clean appointment record.
MT Judicial Nomination Commission; State Bar
+2
Timely execution of laws — implementation of enacted legislation
Implemented voter-approved recreational marijuana (I-190) via HB 701. Red Tape Relief fully executed. Tax cuts phased in as promised. STARS Act deployed. Strong implementation.
State agency records; HB 701; Red Tape Relief
+2
Federal fund utilization — grant management
$629M BEAD broadband (among first states). $65M FHWA emergency highway. FEMA DR-4655. Good federal fund capture.
Federal Audit Clearinghouse; NTIA BEAD; FEMA
+2
Public approval as competence indicator
Won 2024 reelection by 20-point margin. Strong public confidence. Productive legislative agenda resonates with voters.
2024 election results; Morning Consult
+2
State IT security and data protection
CIO Gilbertson appointed. Adding data officer. Fire dashboard launched. Adequate IT modernization.
NASCIO; StateScoop
+1
Infrastructure spending — capital budget execution
$100M road/bridge after debt payoff. $156M prison expansion (HB 817). $629M BEAD broadband. Strong capital execution for state size.
MT DOT; HB 817; NTIA BEAD
+2
Disaster fund readiness
Debt-free + $311M reserves + $100M local disaster relief fund in FY2027 budget. 87.7% available funds ratio. Exceptional emergency financial capacity.
FEMA data; MT Treasurer; HB 2
+3
Workforce development — unemployment system integrity
MT unemployment ~3.5%. 33K job openings (Apr 2024). Tight labor market. UI system functional.
DOL UI Data; BLS JOLTS MT
+1
Medicaid program integrity
Medicaid expansion covers ~75K (HB 245, made permanent). DPHHS administers with standard compliance. Centralized intake system processed 34,400 calls.
CMS; MT DPHHS
+1
Election administration — constitutional compliance
MT elections administered competently. Paper ballot audit trails. Standard administration.
EAC EAVS; MT SOS
+1
Transparency — state budget accessibility
budget.mt.gov publishes documents. Legislative Fiscal Division provides independent analysis. HB 222 property tax rebate portal. Standard transparency.
U.S. PIRG; budget.mt.gov
+1
Intergovernmental cooperation — federal compliance balanced with sovereignty
Cooperates on most federal programs. Signed Medicaid expansion. Pressed for aggressive fire management conflicting with federal approach. EMAC mutual aid activated.
DOJ; EMAC; federal-state coordination
+1
Gubernatorial succession and continuity planning
Lt. Gov. Kristen Juras in place. Clear succession statute. COOP plan exists. Stable governance across 5+ years.
MT Constitution; FEMA COOP
+2
Anti-corruption — state procurement integrity
No procurement scandals. Blind trust for personal businesses. Red Tape Relief streamlined without reducing disclosure. Clean record.
MT procurement data; financial disclosure
+2
Gas price burden — state gas taxes, refinery regulations, cap-and-trade
Montana gas tax 33.75 cents/gallon, moderate nationally. No changes under Gianforte.
salestaxhandbook.com; montanafreepress.org
0
Energy affordability — residential electricity costs from state policy
Created Unleashing American-Made Energy Task Force. Supports all-of-the-above energy. Vetoed Solar Shares Act. Focus on increasing supply for affordability.
news.mt.gov; dailymontanan.com
+1
Energy policy competence — forced mandates without infrastructure readiness
Energy Task Force for affordable, reliable supply. Rejected frivolous litigation delaying energy development. No forced EV mandates.
news.mt.gov; cleanenergytransition.org
+1
Property tax burden — effective rate vs national median
Signed property tax relief: 15% reduction for homeowners, 18% for small businesses. $400 rebates for eligible homeowners. Average savings $500+.
news.mt.gov; montanafreepress.org
+2
Regulatory cost burden — permits, compliance costs per household/business
Budget focused on deregulation and permitting efficiency. Energy Task Force for efficient permitting.
news.mt.gov; dailymontanan.com
+1
Unfunded mandates on municipalities
Property tax relief for municipalities is positive. No major new unfunded mandates imposed.
news.mt.gov
0
Cost of living trajectory — policy-driven affordability trend
Largest income tax cut in state history (5.9% to 4.9%). Property taxes reduced 15%. $400 rebates. Housing affordability remains challenging.
news.mt.gov; kfyrtv.com
+1
Immigration fiscal burden — taxpayer cost of sanctuary/benefits policies
Banned sanctuary cities in Montana. Strong immigration enforcement posture.
news.mt.gov
+1
Homelessness spending accountability — spending vs measurable outcomes
Homelessness increased 89% since 2007. $300M behavioral health investment but outcomes lagging substantially.
theelectricgf.com; dphhs.mt.gov
0
Encampment enforcement — response to SCOTUS Grants Pass ruling
HB 208 allows local governments to regulate camping. HB 642 defines urban camping as public nuisance with $500/day fines. Supportive of enforcement.
theelectricgf.com; ktvq.com
+1
Net domestic migration trend — people leaving vs arriving
Montana still gaining domestic migrants (6,348 in 2025) but growth slowing from pandemic boom. Still net positive.
dailymontanan.com; montanafreepress.org
+1
Business exodus — corporate HQ and jobs relocating due to policy
No significant corporate exodus. Budget focused on business-friendly tax cuts.
news.mt.gov; montanafreepress.org
+1
DA accountability — governor's power to remove rogue prosecutors
No reports of rogue prosecutor issues. Montana's county attorney system is elected.
N/A
0
Election infrastructure — ballot harvesting, drop box security, audit transparency
Signed photo ID voting law, eliminated same-day registration, tightened student voting rules. Comprehensive election security.
sosmt.gov; news.mt.gov
+2
Weaponization of state agencies — using AG/regulatory bodies against political opponents
No credible allegations of weaponizing state agencies.
N/A
0
Foreign adversary protections — Chinese land, TikTok bans, Confucius Institutes
First state to ban TikTok. Banned foreign adversary tech on state devices. Signed SB 203 banning agricultural land sales to foreign adversaries. Nation-leading action.
news.mt.gov; cnn.com; dailycaller.com
+3
← #6 Brad LittleAll RankingsBill Lee #8 →
We investigate systems. We assess individuals.

These same forensics — your IQ, real bio age, career fit, and relationships — all quantum-verified.

What does the data say about you? →